Which Runner Up Should Have Won? Poll Results - American Idol

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

American Idol Which Runner Up Should Have Won?

168 fans picked:

Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks)

24%

Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks)

19%

David Archuleta (over David Cook)

17%

Clay Aiken (over Ruben Studdard)

15%

Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen)

14%

Diana DeGarmo (over Fantasia)

Bo Bice (over Carrie Underwood)

Justin Guarini (over Kelly Clarkson)

pieguy3 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

34 comments

	Amoora picked Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks): I just found Jordin a bit too girly and fake. But Blake was just great! posted over a year ago.

	moosie picked Clay Aiken (over Ruben Studdard): I still can't believe he didn't win...everyone I know voted for him! posted over a year ago.

	jamfan4 picked Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks): I don't really like the rest of them, except Bo. posted over a year ago.

	obsessedwithmd picked Bo Bice (over Carrie Underwood): i hate carrie so yeah posted over a year ago.

	Priscilita22 picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): ok really it should have been Chris Daughtry, but when it was down to Katharine and Taylor, katharine was the better singer. She should have won that one. The other ones were ok, except I think Clay should have won over Ruben.. posted over a year ago.

	solsis picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): I think Clay should have won over Ruben but I chose Katherine cause I liked her so much more than Taylor. I really think she should have won! posted over a year ago.

	farawayx13 picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): def! WHAT THE HECK HAPPENED TO TAYLOR?!?! my point exactly. posted over a year ago.

	bfbf picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): farawayx13 exactly. TAYLOR HICKS SUCKS!! I also agree with priscilita look Chris Daughtry made it to Grammy nomations he sold so many more albums than Katharine and Taylor. HE SOOO should have one i was disappointed with that season of idol. posted over a year ago.

	tipsy416 picked Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks): I believe that they all should have won over the real winners except for Kelly in the 1st season! But I majorly think that Blake should have won over stupid Jordin, and Clay over Ruben!!!! posted over a year ago.

	harold picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): Both Jordin and Blake were good - in very different ways. I was just satisfied that they both made it to the finals - happy with either of them winning. But Taylor??? I've said it elsewhere in this forum: he was like a drunken uncle singing karaoke! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Frances_17 picked Bo Bice (over Carrie Underwood): i lov bo bice better that carrie underwood posted over a year ago.

	thegame998 picked Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks): my all-time idol favorite. posted over a year ago.

	Caliban picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): blake sucks posted over a year ago.

	chcolatecake picked Clay Aiken (over Ruben Studdard): i love clay more then ruben posted over a year ago.

	mollyx365 said: i love blake! jordin ugh .. katharine would be next then clay! posted over a year ago.

	dogsrule369 picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): u people are stupid david archelata should of won!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 posted over a year ago.

	BigSis35 picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): Taylor Hicks was the worst singer ever! He should'nt have made it to Hollywood in the first place!! posted over a year ago.

	JoeJonasIzMyne picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): David A should've won posted over a year ago.

	Fashion_life picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): David Archuleta should have won he is ameazing!!! posted over a year ago.

	MissSelenaGfan picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): him and blake. If i had to choose posted over a year ago.

	PotterGal picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): I don't think i'll ever be able to get over th injustice of Taylor Hicks winning..i mean come on, where the heck is he now?! posted over a year ago.

	BeSafe picked Bo Bice (over Carrie Underwood): And Blake! I don't really think anybody else should have won...I mean personally I voted for Taylor Hicks, I wanted Daughtry to win that year but I really didn't like Kathrine McPhee! No offense to anybody who likes her. posted over a year ago.

	Team_Edward77 picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): I love Blake too :) posted over a year ago.

	Off-My-Rocker picked Blake Lewis (over Jordin Sparks): Jordin was annoying. I think Clay was better than Rueban too. posted over a year ago.

	Mafz picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): c'mon, adam was much better than kris, vocally you just can't compare them. kris just won 'cause he is cute and sweet posted over a year ago.

	Sterlinghot picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): Adam was so better than Kris!!! Adam Go Robbed!!!! posted over a year ago.

	musicluva246 picked Katharine McPhee (over Taylor Hicks): Taylor didn't deserve to win! posted over a year ago.

	Orsolya picked Clay Aiken (over Ruben Studdard): I loved Taylor Hicks and I'm glad he won his season! But Clay definitely deserved to win. posted over a year ago.

	lostlover picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): adam is a perfect singer no wonder he sold much more copies than kris ! i still dont know how the hell did kris win o_O posted over a year ago.

	lambertglam picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): ME NEITHER! BTW ADAM IS THE MOST ROBBED CONTESTANT EVER! STINKY SMELLY SALLEN HAD NOTHING OVER HIM!!! HE SUCKS :P posted over a year ago.

	Luna--Lovegood picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): I think Adam, Kris was sort of a fade-into-the-background kind of guy that you might find singing witha guitar in a coffee shop. Adam, on the other hand was memorable and quite epic, plus he has a more interesting voice, also, when their albums came out, Kris's wasnt memorable or exceptional, Adams definetly was better than Kris's though I do think Allison should have replaced Kris or Danny in the top 3 and come in at LEAST 2nd if not 1st. Also 2nd choice Katharine over Taylor, I just hated Taylor plus he's so boring. posted over a year ago.

	kingJfan3 picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): I think Adam becuase he had a way better voyce then Kris, I have Adams whole album on my ipod, wooohooo!!! Go Glam Fans!!! most ppl think Adam Lambert should of won rather then Kris, Adam has dramatic vocles, Kris has a flat voyce. He sold way more copies then Adam. Ok I will say a couple songs by Kris Allen are better the the origenle like....uhhhhh.....i gess the song Apoliglze, but come on Adam should of won, they just did't vote for Adam because he's a freek and gay! my mum hats him but she thinks he should of won!!!! posted over a year ago.

	Tasha1993 picked David Archuleta (over David Cook): David Archuleta should have won. He's a way better singer. posted over a year ago.

	gagastar169 picked Adam Lambert (over Kris Allen): Lambert had a good voice... a really good voice. posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

American Idol

American Idol Which Runner Up Should Have Won?

34 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

American Idol more polls