answer this question

Critical Analysis of Twilight Question

Why did Bella become a vampire? (Please read for more info...)

With the recent Eclipse promotion (not to mention the leaked script, which was absolutely horrid) I've begun to question if the people at Summit have comprehended the books, or let alone, read the same ones us fans have.

ECLIPSE is about Bella finally choosing. She chooses Edward. With Edward comes becoming a vampire. In a recent press conference interview with Kristen ([here[/www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDn1Pje5XbM&feature=...ed]) , the last question mentioned that [in the movie] Bella not only becomes a vampire to be with Edward but also for personal reasons.

For now, or forever, forget Breaking Dawn ever happened. My fear for the Eclipse movie is them not seeing that she did, in fact, do it for Edward. No point in forever without him. In your opinion, from what you read in Eclipse, why did she become a vampire?
*
sorry about the html fail. Lol
mandapanda posted over a year ago
 mandapanda posted over a year ago
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Answers

rachaelwsz said:
Well, I've read the same books as you did... And I always thought that she wanted to become a vampire because she wanted to be with Edward. It would have been easier for her that way. She didn't need to become one but she wanted to. I don't think there was any other reason.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
XbloodyXroseX said:
Even though she was made a vampire to keep her from dieing the big picture (during New Moon and Eclipse) for me was a tie between
1. She was afraid of getting older and Edward not wanting her anymore/dieing or...
2. Because of her love/obsession with Edward she wanted to be with him forever.
In the New Moon movie Bella tells Edward that if he turns her into a vampire she could protect him from Victoria. I guess that they want to make her sound less selfish because I don't remember reading anything like that in the book, I think.

On a separate note Kristen is so awkward I would be a little freaked out if I met her.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I don't know if I'm understanding you correctly. Did you say you didn't remember reading about Bella wanting to protect Edward by becoming a vampire? I remember that in the books, but what they are trying to imply in this movie, about Bella being a vampire for personal reasons such as: never fitting in with humans, it's ludicrous. But I do agree with the opinions you put. The first one, I always forget that one. I always thought it was a petty little thought, but now I think it kind of played a big part in her urgency.
mandapanda posted over a year ago
*
i think the age thing was just to get the story going n finish it before there like 30
ami_loves_damon posted over a year ago
*
I thought I remember Bella actually saying in the books that she never really felt she fit in with other humans - that she felt the most at home with the Cullens. I'm curious now...
snoznoodle posted over a year ago
ami_loves_damon said:
the only reason bella became a vampire is because she loves edward and wanted to spend eternity with him. she did it all for him and him alone. in the book edward says: "you only want to become a vampire to be with me not for eternal life" then bella says "theres no point to forever without u"(something along the lines of that)
so bella did not became a vampire for personal reasons but only for edward <3
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I'm glad you realize that too :) I think it's page 257 or something. But that's the answer I was looking for. It just irritates me that they are translating that wrong. For Eclipse.
mandapanda posted over a year ago
*
i kno its really frustrating. also i refuse to watch breaking dawn cauz there changing the actors for jacob, alice and emmet. that is totally wrong and it is rediculous, u cant just go changing the actors in the last movie. especially alice and jacob cauz there main and every1 knows and remembers them, i love emmett to so that is really pissing me off
ami_loves_damon posted over a year ago
*
Good, because that would make the movie messed-up to even the biggest fan of Twilight
HecateA posted over a year ago
snusnu13 said:
i think Bella wanted to become a vampire because she has a fear of aging and she wants to live with Edward forever. also the fact that the volturi will kill her if someone doesn't turn her into a vampire.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »