Doctor Who Who does the doctor love more? Rose or River Song?

Rose42012 posted on Oct 02, 2011 at 08:45AM
Everybody who watched the last episode of Dr Who
knows that River and him r married and they fancy each other BUT he fanicied rose tyler as well so what do u think guys?
save

Doctor Who 30 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-25 of 30

over a year ago Kantoe said…
10 loved rose. 11 loves river.
blindingriver commented…
TEn would chop off both of his arms for Rose, we all know that, but Eleven… I don’t know. River can take care of herself I guess. over a year ago
Kacy_Myth commented…
I whole-heartedly agree. Rose is awesome!!!!!!! over a year ago
TARDIS-Granger commented…
you guys they are THE SAME PERSON he just looks different over a year ago
12thdoctor commented…
He JUST looks different? Please, the difference between David's Doctor and Matt's Doctor stretches as far and wide as the inside of the TARDIS itself over a year ago
over a year ago huddygirl2 said…
Yeah Ten loves Rose 11 no longer but remembers her fondly 11 loves River and Ten is wondering who the heck River is.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago hutpallarka said…
Doctor loves Rose. He knows River Song is going to die after the first time she met him. There is no chance he has to take. He knows she and him will be together and that she will die. There is no surprise... it's somewhat like dictated fate or a prophecy of sorts. Caring for River Song means that he has nothing to lose. Even if he tells her his name, he knows she won't abuse it because she will die when she is still in love with him.
over a year ago Rose42012 said…
wink
i agree with all of ya but did 11 not say 'Dorium i'm a time traveler, i can help Rose Tyler with her homework'
carcar5911 commented…
yeah over a year ago
Kacy_Myth commented…
I know right? How brilliant! over a year ago
over a year ago Fanpup10101 said…
over a year ago Ahthen said…
I'm not even convinced that 11 loves River... I know they were "married" but It felt like he was just flirting with her more then real love.

He and Rose are Soul-mates I swear to it.
last edited over a year ago
Kacy_Myth commented…
Oh totally!!!! I couldn't agree more! over a year ago
over a year ago DW_girl said…
I really want the doctor to still love rose- i want it to be true
Kacy_Myth commented…
Yup, Rose and the Doctor have true love. over a year ago
over a year ago no1drwhofan said…
heart
I think, in his heart-no matter which incarnation-the Doctor will always love Rose Tyler. In my view, the Doctor just sees River as an object of flirting rather than someone to love and cherish. <3 <3
Rainshadow999 commented…
Wow...thta's much... over a year ago
over a year ago Mithrilneth said…
I'd rather neither i mean i hate River, their "love"seems sorta one-way with that flirt. And i think love for rose sort of died with 10...

I don't think either of them were good matches for the Doctor, any day now someone will come along and will be a perfect fit ^^
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago HelloThereBud said…
10 loved Rose. 11 loves River. End of discussion.
TARDIS-Granger commented…
good lord.....SAME PERSON over a year ago
12thdoctor commented…
They may be the same person, but they are very different. over a year ago
4thblacksister commented…
Thankyou!!!! I love 11xRiver a lot more than 10xRose, but I can appreciate that they were in love too. Btw TARDIS-Granger, would yiu like me to actually write a list of how 10 and 11 are different???????? over a year ago
AdmirePhelps commented…
Of course they are differen! THEY'RE DIFFERENT ACTORS! But you should remember this. Same software different case. Perraonality traits may have changed. Because he gets older and gets a new body and new metabolism. But all the memories and all the people he's met( what makes him who he is) is with him till he dies. ( Unless he loses his memory, but it happened once and yet he still remembered Rose, altough he didnt know who she is) ANYWAY. What makes doctor , The doctor is same. But due to different actors playing them, its okay for him to have new interests, such as River or fish fingers in custard, 4 months ago
over a year ago Jadis-the-White said…
The Doctor is in a paralal universe with rose but he is human and will die there with her.
over a year ago carcar5911 said…
And guys don't 4get the doctor is 1 peson he just changes his face...duhhhh
Kacy_Myth commented…
Well. Sort of. I like to think so, but his personality is slightly different. I have a theory that each Doctor is an aspect of his personality. over a year ago
TARDIS-Granger commented…
thank you someone who is makeing sense.I mean come on do you watch the show!!? over a year ago
12thdoctor commented…
When the Doctor regenerates, he becomes a different person. He's biologically, technically, whatever you want, the same being, but his personality, looks, and reactions are all different. He has his memories and that's it. That's all that stays constant. over a year ago
4thblacksister commented…
I'm listening tp an audio aventure, legit bbc, where the 7th Doctor is flying around saving stuff because his next body might be to weak to make the right choices. He says that it's not just your body that changes, it's the personality, and how they act over a year ago
over a year ago NOCTURNL said…
Rose...Always Rose
over a year ago Rainshadow999 said…
heart
River Song is his wife! And after watching "Angels Take Manhattan" I think he really cares about River...
Doctor_Who_Girl commented…
I agree, I mean he uses up a generation of his life just to heal River's wrist. That's love. <3 over a year ago
Rainshadow999 commented…
Yeah… over a year ago
4thblacksister commented…
Because, River said she married the Doctor, but then says to Amy that the universe then doesn't exist. So OBVIOUSLY they get married again over a year ago
over a year ago Chockspelvis said…
Well, you have to remember, The Doctor told River his real name. The Doctor never tells anybody else his real name at all.
CassandraMariee commented…
He didn't tell River his name over a year ago
Chockspelvis commented…
Yeah, in Silence in the library, River whispers his name into his ear and that is when he beleives that she is somebody important over a year ago
Rainshadow999 commented…
Oh yeah! That's right! over a year ago
over a year ago iamawhovian said…
No matter what Doctor it is he will ALWAYS love Rose. River doesn't compare to her what so ever. I think that in the 50th anniversary episode we will be able to tell whom the doctor cares for more.
over a year ago Kacy_Myth said…
I agree with iamawhovian, and all who are pro-Rose. 11 likes River, but Rose is the best. 10 LOVES Rose and knows it, but I reckon 11 doesn't realize he still LOVES Rose because River is confusing him.


Ish.
over a year ago darange said…
ROSE+DOCTOR=TRUE LOVE !!!! :')

RIVER+DOCTOR= flirting. :-/


The doctor loves Rose end of story
over a year ago PantheraTigris said…
If the Doctor married River in a time that never actually happened, what's to say he ever married her. Also on that point he would know that time would never of happened so he did it just to get everything back to normal.
over a year ago TARDIS-Granger said…
He has feelings for River but ultimetly loves Rose and his wife from when he still lived in Gallifrey.End of discussion. gooday and good night.And Romana beats both of em she is smarter prettier and braver.also a Time Lord.Watch the classic series.Just sayin
over a year ago thegirlwhowait said…
River Song, its adorable how akward he act when they kiss! :-)
4thblacksister commented…
thankyou, someone talking sense!!! over a year ago
over a year ago scientificdoc said…
Guys please look at the big picture. Rose is a human, will die in a short. According to doctor (may be he liked him very much) Rose is a child who needs help. River, is a time lord too. She is doctor and later professor. She is the woman doctor who try to find out "who is the doctor song". She is genius as doctor. She can regenerate as doctor (we know she gave her all regenerations to doctor). She isn't a companion of doctor. A companion goes and does what doctor says. But River had her own adventures and invite doctor to come with her. And the doctor always is there. Doctor couldn't direct her. And we saw at the last episode Doctor kiss her (never did before with any of women) and called her his wife. I was'nt sure before last episode if he is love or like as the other companions. But I'm sure now. And she is professor (higher than the doctor) and she knows a lot about the doctors past and future, and this make doctor proud of her and respect her. And the other things make them two sides of a coin: they are both psychopat, genius, time lord, hot and flirty (to each other). She is also well trained warrior as the doctor. She uses gun, doctor uses screwdriver. And another point, they both like to wear remarkable. Doctor wears bow tie and River generally night dress. They are born for each other. We will see again River, maybe in different face. And also say last thing about Clara, isn't she like a machine, cold, nothing special of her? She is like a game. When game over, you can restart from the beginning. And I think River has a hand about that.
AdmirePhelps commented…
But I think you miss the IMPORTANT Little picture while you're dealing with the bigger picture. Rose is not just a child who needs help. She is an ordinary human with a big love for the Doctor, big enough to lleave everyhing she ever had behind. She absorbed the time vortex, she looked in the tardis' heart. River was born there, so she was the child of the Tardis. But Rose let the whole time and space in her mind. That's such a great power but she managed to keep alive with it. Because you know, her intension was pure, that was an act of true care, and love. Also that's an action big enough to cause the Doctor to die/ regenerate. River married the man in whose Tardis he was born. But Rose chose living spending her life with the man who grabbed her hand and simply said "Run" 4 months ago
over a year ago PondandOwsin34 said…
I think that the doctor cares for River, but some part him still loves Rose and his other companions wether they are jus friends are not but he still thinks of them as his family besides the TARDIS
over a year ago ghostkeeperxoxo said…
Well...the 9th and 10th doctor loves rose but matt forgot her soooo i uess its hem both
over a year ago ghostkeeperxoxo said…
Guess*