Edward and Bella Question
Why Have They Decided to cut the birth/sex scene from breaking dawn ???
Edward and Bella Answers
|
sarabeara said:
Well, it hasn't been confirmed that they will cut those scenes.
But if they decide to, it will be because pregnancy and sex scenes are too graphic for the main demographic of Twilight fans (sorry to be so blunt, but would you really want to see Kristen Stewart shoving a baby out of her vajayjay?). Seriously, most fans are about ages 12-14, therefore causing the movies makers to keep the movie on a PG-13 rating if they still want loads of ticket sales.
Plus, parents would flip if their precious children loved a series of books where the movie included a graphic sex scene (it's two verrrrry different things to read a sex scene and to actually see one acted out i.e. with noises). How scandalous [insert melodramatic gasp here]! Since you know, parents should keep their children sheltered and all. Anyways, I'm getting off topic.
It hasn't been confirmed by anyone that those scenes will be cut (just because they want to keep the movie PG-13 doesn't imply that the scenes will be cut altogether), but if they're not cut, they'll most likely be very mild and tame.
|
|
|
renesmee09 said:
I didn't realize they were going to cut those scene of the movie. I think it would be a big mistake for them to do that...those scenes are important scenes that would have a big impact in the story of Breaking Dawn. In the book it gives details of Bella after Edward takes the baby...removing it with his teeth.
|
|
|
Hellohoudini said:
Have they? I mean we're just now getting bits and pieces of Eclipse ...I havent heard anything about Breaking Dawn yet.. let alone something that big. But I'm keeping my fingers crossed that they dont.
|
|
|
Hermione65236 said:
I guess so kids can see it. I also geuss that if they do show that some people may not like it and never watch it again.
|
|
|
TEAM-EDWARDxxx said:
Okay this is what i think, Twilight is a series for people all different ages, My 8 year onld brother likes watching the movie,and i would think he would want to watch all the others aswell, But i dont think he would want to watch them have sex, and many other young kids wouldnt want to see that either. Thats proably why they cut it out. But i dont get why they decided to cut out the birth scene?? maybe it was too hard to do, or maybe to grewsome.?? i dunno.
|
|
|
chagrin91 said:
i reallly dont want them to cut those scenes they are important in some way i just hope they dont cut those scenes
|
|
|
laspanglish said:
what have they?if yes...WELLLLLL!!!!WHER 2 BEGIN!!! ha ha ha ha ooo...*rollseyes*
|
|
|
lexybabe88 said:
Maybe for younger people. I don't think it's right. "Love story" type movies aren't usually for younger viewers. And they are both important, you can't have BD w/o Renesmee and you can't have her without the sex scenes. It's changing too much if those are cut cus they're both too important.
|
|
|
LightningWolf said:
I doubt they will. The Twilight movies are rated PG-13, so I see no good reason to skip these scenes altogether. Maybe make them a little milder, yes, but that's it.
|
|
|
Kelly42 said:
well that's just stupid. i mean it comes out of her stomach nothing graphic. and little kids shouldn't even WANT to watch twilight so its annoying. like wow. i mean make it pg-13 and then have a parent have to come in with the child or something. but like wow. most of all. its a book. come on. that would be the BEST out of all the movies. so they shouldn't even bother to cut it out.
|
|
|
mylilangelbug said:
I hope not cause two totally bad and immature ctors should have to do some real acting for once instead of living of daddys trustfund and getting high every moment and besides twilight is already graphic a baby and some naked parts aint soo bad cause its not lke there gonna shoot them actully having sex, exuse me i mean making love(piuk)
And if parent are soo worried then why are you taking you 8 years old that still thinks girls are yucky
|
|
|
opalrose said:
they are just going to make sure that they aren't R rated
|
|
|
teambella23 said:
people i agree with all of you that they should not cut out any senses for breaking dawn,but i got the facts see at first the move was going to be rated-R but that was only because of the sex and birth senses.see if it was rated-R the movie would had lost millions of dollar's because of the numbers of teen fans so they decided to cut all non-teen appropriate senses from the film.:(
|
|
|
kaitlyn12348 said:
They shouldn't cut it out because it wouldn’t make sense if they had Renesmee without the sex and birth scenes.... I think it would be good if they had it because then the adults wouldn’t be bored and maybe more teens would watch it........ it's not only 12-14 year olds there are a range of 12- mid 20's and I know a lot of people that have read the book and would be disappointed if they were gone.
|
|