To tell the truth, I liked twilight when I read it for the first time, because it was a good time pass and okay it was tolerable. But when I read neww moon, eclipse and breaking dawn, They all appeared the same.
Two guys fighting over a blank faced, whiny girl with no personality
and it was about Edward and his family trying their level best to protect her from evil vampires
The villain Victoria's boy died and she created an army of new borns and that includes millions of young and innocent boys and girls
They all got killed and Bella and the Cullens were like, That sucks
Bella just can't seem to make up her mind can she?
okay here it goes.
Harry Potter is a legend. The end of Harry potter is like an era's end.
Hoe can someone possibly compare Harry Potter and twilight.
Twilight is nothing but a triangle love story. Harry Potter has a lot in it. Both these films are different point of view. They are different genres as well. But of course when one compare the plots of both these films. Harry Potter is a lot better because the twilight's characters have a lot of flaws.
When I saw the first twilight film I found the characters pretty nice in it (not Bella).
My opinion on Edward's greatness changed completely after seeing new moon.
He was shown as a suicidal guy. There is absolutely nothing romantic or great abou that boys and girls.
From then on I saw a lot of flaws in Edward.
He is suicidal. That is biggest flaw he has. It is like a big monster behind a pretty face. I found the suicide part in new moon really ridiculus. I mean how come the dumb girls ( and some boys) Still find him great after an incident like that.
If he really can't live without Bella then he should have tried to kill himself the day he left Bella. Or above all he should never allowed Carlisle to convert him in the first place.
I felt like laughing when i saw that scene where takes his shirt off to expose himself in the sunlight in new moon.
I was like What the hell?
Is this what all girls want their dudes to do when they die?
Being able to move on when your boy/girl die (Doesn't mean that you immediately look for another person)
earns you more respect, than trying to kill yourself.
If the Edward was lonely, that is if he was orphan who has no job or family to live for then again it was okay.
But Edward has a beautiful family. His Dad loves him. His mom (Esme who lost her son before she became a vampire) saw her son in him.
Then there Alice, Rosalie, Emmett and Jasper. How could he possibly turn his back on them?
Besides, The villain Victoria was alive. And leaving her alive is equal to allowing her to kill and ruin more people's lives. Above all his family was vulnerable to her. He wasn't bothered about that.
If he really wanted protect Bella, he should left long before their relationship developed.
But no, Edward and Bella's relationship is nothing but a pure case and example of obsession. That is what these 'bonds' and vampire couples are all about. It clearly rules out everything else necessary.
Bella was not bothered about her dreams, her goals, her father, mother, friends etc.
Reading or watching twilight as a story or entertainment is fine but the fans are taking it too far.
Harry Potter is faaaaar better in that manner. Even though he is not the best wizard, He is tolerant, dedicated, loving, caring, gracious and brave. He was never obsessed about his girls. He cared for family and friends.