You might have contributed more stuff to the spot but it isn't fanned as much as say someone with less content but fanned higher content, you still have more contributions. That's the only thing I can come up with.
Are you talking about on the right side, that box thingy? That changes all the time. It's reflective of who is recently active in that club, not over-all in the history of the spot.
For example. I have a die-hard medal in the Harry Potter club. But I haven't been active in that club for a while. I bet if I went over there, people with only dedicated medals (or who recently got die-hard medals) would show up ahead of me (if I show up at all).