Advertisement

What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Girls Generation/SNSD For SNSD Next Comeback in 2012, which would you prefer they come back as? Why?

36 fans picked:
Full SNSD
   67%
Another Subunit
   33%
 tiagih posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

26 comments

user photo
vinxinc picked Full SNSD
vinxinc picked Full SNSD:
my only wish is that Yoona is not in the center.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Moofysnowman picked Another Subunit
Moofysnowman picked Another Subunit:
I want a Hyoyeon, Sooyoung, and Yuri subunit :)!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
nacchiee picked Full SNSD
nacchiee picked Full SNSD:
vinxinc! my wish too :)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD:
another subunit for 2013. not now... and let it be SooSicHyo, since my dream for SooYulHyo is destroyed lol

my wish for a full SNSD comeback
-a much better song than "the boys". not that it was bad, but it's one of my least favorite songs of SNSD
- a rock concept...especially after seeing Sooyoung as a rocker twice, this month(one was on her MC show "hanbam", the other was on her recent magazing "1st look")...it could a hint xD
-more screentime and center to Sooyoung, and more lines that can showcase her voice. "the boys" didn't help at all
-no rap this time. at least not for the tittle track
-an MV with a STORY. i'm tired of seeing the same thing over and over again: some dance and closeups -___-
-Yoona with less lines. i know this sounds harsh, but she doesn't deserve more than one line. why would they give one singing line in "the boys" for Yoona, but not one for Yuri or Sooyoung, since they're much better singers? "hoot" was perfect for Yoona, only one line and that's it. saying that she deserves more, is bullshit, because she doesn't. she already has a great amount of closeups and she gets to be in the center for most of the coreography. that's the job of most of the visuals in kpop.
trying to change that, just because of some buthurt fans that will bash the company for not letting their visual sing more, is stupid. SM needs to learn that once and for all. or maybe they don't want to learn it because Yoona is their precious little girl
-good outfits. "the boys" outifts were good, so i'm expecting great outfits once again

i think it's all. sorry if i offended someone, it's just my opinion
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
GDheaSONE picked Full SNSD
GDheaSONE picked Full SNSD:
OT9 Korean comeback juseyo D:
or SunSica duo T.T
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih said:
vinxvinc, any subunit Yoona will be in, I highly doubt she won't be the center.

I personally think that another subunit would be great. All of them are from 21-23, so they aren't babies that need to rely on others to perform or cover their weakness. Tiffany is a great example of what I mean, she used to sound really weak live but now she has improved and can hold her own on stage (better). Sububnits would benefit everyone in the group because it can challenge them on overcoming a weakness that they have on stage.

Jessica-Sounds kinda weak live and lazy dancing. With a subunit she may bring back her debut dancing skills
Sunny-Sounds quiet live and dancing is decent. With a subunit perhaps she will learn to breath properly and get better dancing esp if rumors are correct about the next subunit.
Hyoyeon -She needs to work on her vocals but does better rapping. Maybe in the subunit she won't be required to dance so hard as much as she needs to sing
Yuri-similar with hyoyeon but perhaps she will have more confidence on stage so she won't mess up dances
Sooyoung- similar with Sunny but if if rumors are right she needs to work on her vocals for her subunit since she tends to sound flat or off pitch
Yoona- perhaps she will be able to show more singing talent

Thier comeback should be for october so I hope its true because I am excited
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
YushiGirl picked Full SNSD
YushiGirl picked Full SNSD:
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
dinsangi picked Full SNSD
dinsangi picked Full SNSD:
i miss them
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit:
i will tell u why
coz as taetiseo fans was happy that the members they love the most have own album and have much screen time and a lot of lines coz 3 singer not like 9 members and taetiseo appeared in a lot of shows and sings a lot that their fans can see them every day
to be honest i want to feel like yeah finally yul have alot of lines and dance more like taetiseo fans feel
esp yul deosnt have much lines even much screen time as 9 members like soo and hyo i think they much give chance as 3 to shining and ppl know how much they can do the best and they can be more confidence con i swear they r the best but they just need to be in light spot
i dont said that the 3 members must be in the same subunit but they the most members underrated in mv lately and they must get the chance

posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih said:
^ ? You do know that Yuri gets more singing lines then all the dancers right?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit:
like what? like in the boys listen to the music and u will know she has less lines than the other
paparazzi she get only one line and the other with fany like the other and i said lately not from the beginning and i only talk about mvs and the dancer take more lines is yoona
so tell me how yuri get more lines lately than the other in what mv again my all talk about only mvs
but iam sure that yul soo hyo the most members underrated in mvs lately
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD:
tiagih no she doesn't, Sooyoung gets the most lines. i actually counted all Yul's and Soo's lines in ALL of their songs(really ALL), and the difference is actually huge. Sooyoung has much more singing lines overall(if you count the repeated lines and the hidden lines that most people don't know about)
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD:
sweet_yuri in paparazzi, Yuri gets 4 lines. not 2

Yuri isn't underrated at all. especially in the MV's. she gets tons of closeups....the really underrated members are Soo and Hyo, we all know that
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit
sweet_yuri picked Another Subunit:
pretty_angel92 yeah sorry i counted it know and yeah it is 4
so who is underrated in mvs after hyo and soo (lately ) i think it will be yul and i think it is must be the fact cz who will get less lines like yulsoohyo will be underrated in mvs right?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih said:
Sweet_yuri, YouTube it Yuri gets more singing parts then all the dancers overall, I will provide a link in a min. There is a difference in face time and singing lines. You are mention title songs not album songs. Just because Yuri doesn't get a lot of screen time doesn't mean she doesn't sing alot.
edit: Here are all the dancers (except Yoona) singing parts in order from most to least:Yuri,Sooyoung, Hyoyeon,Yoona. You can't just count mv as singing parts because most mv aren't meant to show off vocal talent as much as a nice catchy song with some eye candy.

link of Yuri singing parts:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYs29WBTTQJ­k&a­mp;­fea­tur­e=p­lcp

link of Sooyoung parts:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rxHXbDsVVz4­g&a­mp;­fea­tur­e=p­lcp

link of hyoyeon parts:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72N2hNnii6y­k&a­mp;­fea­tur­e=p­lcp
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
vinxinc picked Full SNSD
vinxinc picked Full SNSD:
^ Sooyoung also gets many random English parts. The official lyrics of Paparazzi credits "With the girls, with the Girls' Generation" to Sooyoung/Tiffany. In "Tell me your wish," two spoken lines "I'm genie for your wish" and "I'm genie for your world" are both Sooyoung's lines.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
nacchiee picked Full SNSD
nacchiee picked Full SNSD:
actually i hope Yoona to get more singing lines , so she can show more her talent in singing xD THAN getting many close-ups and being in the center (but.. she is the visual, so ..still.. maybe)
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
tiagih said:
^^link please because in no performance does Sooyoung say "Were the girls generation".
link:http://kpoplyricscc.wordpress.com/2012//06­/14­/sn­sd-­pap­ara­zzi­/

You forgot Sooyoung shares a part with tiff in "tell me what you need, tell me what you heard"
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD:
tiagih most of those videos are missing a lot of lines, just saying
well yeah, you're saying she doesn't say "with the girls generation" on their performances but how do you know that, since they didn't even showed her face? Tiffany and Jessica's faces weren't shown either and they sing that line with Sooyoung. it was the camera's fault..besides, there was aonly 2 or 3 performances of "paparazzi"

the MV shows that Sooyoung sing that line with Jessica and Tiffany, that's a fact. not only she gets two closeups in the official MV while saying that line, but she also does a different move at the second "with the girl's generation" on the dance version(normal and gold) along with Fany and Sica. you seem to ignore that
and why are you relying on a stupid color coded website, anyway? those things are made by people like us, it's not official

first "with the girl's generation"- Tiffany and Sooyoung
second "with the girl's generation"(after the dance break"- Tiffany, Sooyoung and Jessica

Jessica doesn't sing the first one because she's already singing "uh la la la" at the same time, so, it overlaps
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
tiagih said:
^I don't look to mvs for member lyrics because if I did then you can't proof that Sooyoung singings "tell me what you need, tell me what you heard" you would have to watch a live performance in order to be sure. So therefore I don't trust the paparazzi mv I am waiting until their japanese tour and see if someone makes a good fancam then I am absolutely sure. But until then in the songs it didn't sound like Sooyoung so I am gonna stand by what I say until proven otherwise,
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD
pretty_angel92 picked Full SNSD:
you didn't need a live performance to know that she sings "i'm genie for your wish and i'm genie for your world", right? SM doesn't even let her sing it live but we know it's her...and they always show her face on the MV's, when it comes to those lines(korean, japanese and 3D version)

so, live performances aren't always reliable

but ok, let's wait for the japanese tour
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih said:
^no live performances are more liable because in the Korean version of Genie you don't know if sooyoung is singing those parts because you don't see her singing them. You would only confirm by watching live performances, Which is why i said mvs aren't reliable for the same reason you said that soo sings"were the girls generation" because you saw her singing that, if we use mvs are judgement then lots of members don't or do sing parts that they or may not be actually singing ie Genie with Soo "tell me what you need" or "Im genie for your wish/dream". Do you understand what I mean?

Back to the main point, Yuri does get more singing parts overall, that is just the fact of the matter. Sooyoung may have more "unknown" singing parts but even if you add them all up (and people have for a hobby) it still is less than what Yuri sings. That is why I was confused about sweet_yuri saying that Yuri doesn't get a lots of singing parts, when Yuri gets more singing parts then all the dancers in the group.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Miyuki-hime picked Full SNSD
Miyuki-hime picked Full SNSD:
I wanted Yoonyulhyun as a subunit but it looks like that won't happen
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pearlxashxdawn picked Another Subunit
pearlxashxdawn picked Another Subunit:
i want SooSunSic!!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SugarBell20 picked Another Subunit
SugarBell20 picked Another Subunit:
I want to see other members shine on their own merit so give me another subunit
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Yurisistiblow picked Another Subunit
Yurisistiblow picked Another Subunit:
i don't wnt yoona to bein the center again and why does yoona get more lines than the dancers in dancing queen? she's the worst singer ftw
posted over a year ago.