Just to be clear, I think nobody is ugly.

absolutely hott are:

Trish
Sully
Shea
Richard
Cal
Chloe
Jimmy
Abby
Henry
Katherine
Lucy
Shane
Booth
Robin
Nikki
Hunter (I think that Victor is hot, although the character is too 'Ken' by his attitude to be as attractive as he could be)
Wakefield (IDK why, but he just is)
JD (kinda hot too in a very unconventional way)


pretty/handsome are:

Danny
Malcolm (chubby yes, but pretty face and he's cute)
Beth
Kelly
Thomas (very handsome for 53)
Ben
Officers

Too old/weird to be hot, but not ugly:

Julia (actually, very pretty for 70s)
Maggie
Sheriff
Marty
Karena (she's not that old, but she's average looking imo)
Cole (least attractive, but that's only his mask, actor is actually average at least)





Well, there it goes. It's just my opinion. I know everyone has theirs.