Harper's Island Would you rather....

katie11 posted on Nov 04, 2010 at 08:23PM
I will just give you an example:

I put: Would you rather kill Abby or Kiss Uncle Marty?

Next person: Kiss Marty. Kiss Katherine or kiss Lucy?

And so on...

Hope you get it, and please join!

Harper's Island 28 replies

Click here to write a response...
over a year ago katie11 said…
heart
Would you rather: Kiss Katherine or Lucy? (And if you are a girl it can be on the cheek. Lol)
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
smile
Kiss Lucy. Would you rather: Kiss Hunter or kill Thomas?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
zzz
Kiss Hunter. Would You Rather: Kiss Maggie or Kill Chloe?
over a year ago katie11 said…
wink
Kill Chloe. No brainer

Kill Cal or Kill Sully
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
wink
Kill Cal :p

Kiss Wakefield or Kill Sully? :)
over a year ago alirioaguero2 said…
big smile
Kiss Wakefield, however horrid that might be. I love Sully:)

Kiss Henry or Kill Abby?
over a year ago katie11 said…
Kisss Henry :(

Couldn't kill Abby

Kill Wakefield or Kill Sully
over a year ago alirioaguero2 said…
big smile
Wakefield, of course:)

Kiss Lucy or Kiss Shane?
over a year ago katie11 said…
Lucy (On Cheek)

Kiss Katherine or Rev Fain lol
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
wink
Kiss Katherine

Kiss Sheriff Mills or Kill Gigi?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
Kiss Sheriff Mills :)

It would be terrible to kill a little dog

Kiss Cole harkin or Kill Trish?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago katie11 said…
big smile
Kill Trish, defo i don't like Trish!

Go on holiday with Abby or Shea?
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
cool
With Abby :)

Go to a movie with Jimmy or go to a restaurant with Shane?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
Go to a movie with jimmy

he's hot. ;)

Cook a meal for Shea or Give Flowers to Maggie??
over a year ago katie11 said…
big smile
Give flowers to Maggie, she's a sweet thing, lol :)

Cheat on Jimmy or Kill Henry??
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
laugh
Cheat on Jimmy I guess, I could never kill Henry!

Poison Cal's food or break the Sheriff's arm?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
laugh
Poison Cal's Food

I could,nt break the Sheriff's arm

Sleep with Wakefield or Cole Harkin?
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
meh
Well, sleeping with Wakefield would probably make me a target of his rampages later on, so... I'll go with Cole Harkin I guess :/

Dance with Danny or sleep with Thomas?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
smile
Dance with Danny :)


Slap Reverend Fain or Kick Wakefield?
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
smile
Kick Wakefield

Punch Abby or Hug Beth?
over a year ago katie11 said…
Hug Beth xx

Kill Lucy or Kill Karena
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
Kill Karena


Go to the beach with Jimmy or go skiing with Sully?
over a year ago katie11 said…
Beach with Jimmy. I dislike Sully.

Hug Kelly or Slap Lucy
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
big smile
Hug Kelly

Go to a concert with Trish or go fishing with Henry?
over a year ago katie11 said…
Fishing with Henry

Kill Jimmy or Henry??
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
wink
Henry, but only because he killed so many others.

Kill Katherine or Lucy?
over a year ago sheaallenfan said…
worried
Kill Lucy...

that's a tough one..like em both

Marry Danny or Booth?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago HarperIslandFan said…
wink
Marry Danny, probably.

Kiss Malcolm or Richard?