How I Met Your Mother This Or That

mikee21 posted on Aug 14, 2009 at 01:32AM
Choose which you like better and dont forget to leave one for the NEXT person

I'll star

Drunk Ted or Sober Ted

How I Met Your Mother 760 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 101-150 of 760

over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall's hat. Lily's British accent is soooooo painful.

Barney not wearing suits to get laid or Barney trying to get laid wearing overalls?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Overalls :) for the brotp moments XD

Don or Karen?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oohh.. I hate them both! Karen cause she wasn't interfering with BRotp.

Barney and Robin or Marshall and Lily?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney and Robin but I do love Marshall and Lily. I just love brotp a lot more!

Ted's daughter or Ted's son?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm... Ted's daughter.

Alyson Hannigan or Jason Segel?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Both, Jason Segel a little more :)

Lily or Barney?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney

Lily and Barney or Marshall and Ted?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm..... that's a tough one. I'm going with Lily and Barney.

Lily and Barney or Lily and Ted?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Lily & Ted. But only just.

Suits or a pot of gold?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Given that I don't know how good I look in suits, I'll take a pot of gold and sneak off to buy a suit with some of it. ;)

Ted's little dance in Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Ted singing Cheap Trick in The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Cheap Trick. He is so cute in that scene XD

Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit. There is no comparison.

Let's Go to the Mall or You Just Got Slapped?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Has to be You Just Got Slapped! xD

Season 3 or 4?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
season 4

Rain Dance or Cheap Trick Karaoke?
over a year ago hstb said…
Cheap Trick Karaoke. I love drunk Ted!

Don or Tony?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oh man that's a hard one... Don. he didn't make our boy Ted into a total asshole while glorifying himself in a major motion picture. lol.

Crazy Meg or Abby?
over a year ago hstb said…
Crazy Meg.

The Yellow Umbrella or The Pinneaple
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple!

Not a Father's Day or The Naked Man?
over a year ago hstb said…
Naked Man

Come On or The Leap?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Leap!

Twin Beds or Of Course?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm... I think Of Course

Ted's Mom or Barney's Mom?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Barney's Mom

Ted's Mom or Lily's Dad
over a year ago hstb said…
Ted's Mom

You Just Got Slapped or Barney's Christmas Carols?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ohh... that's a tough one....... umm... You Just Got Slapped.

Carl or Wendy the Waitress?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Carl

Something borrowed or Something Blue?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Something Borrowed :)

The Stinsons or Not A Father's Day?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Stinsons-- for the nice BRotp moment at the end! <3

Lily and Robin or Ted and Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Woah that's a difficult one. Gonna have to go Ted and Barney though :)

Cobie Smulders or Robin Scherbatsky?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Scherbatsky... I've never seen Cobie Smulders in anything else.

Alyson Hannigan or Lily Aldrin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lily Aldrin :)

Sarah Chalke or Britney Spears?
over a year ago hstb said…
Sarah Chalke

Trudy or Natalie?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Trudy

Robin Mosby or Robin Stinson?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Stinson!!!

Dirty Barney or Sweet Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Hmmm that's difficult. Sweet Barney :)

Sandy Rivers or Crazy Meg?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Crazy Meg. Sandy Rivers is a douche.

Crazy Meg or the girl who wouldn't leave Barney's apartment in World's Greatest Couple?
over a year ago hstb said…
Umm... That's a difficult one... Crazy Meg

Voices or You Give Love A Bad Name?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
VOICES!

Not Moby or Regis Philbin?
over a year ago hstb said…
Not Moby.

Blue French Horn or Yellow Umbrella?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
SMURF PENIS!

Barney's daddy issues or Robin's daddy issues?
over a year ago hstb said…
Robin's daddy issues

Game Night or The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple Incident! As much as I ADORE Game Night, the Pineapple Incident makes me laugh more than anything ever.

Spoiler Alert or Intervention?
over a year ago hstb said…
Gosh that's difficult... Spoiler Alert, but Intervetion is a great episode!!

"Where Were We?" or "Definitions"?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Definitions for sure!!

Barney's "FINISH HIM!" or Barney's Pac-Man noise?
over a year ago hstb said…
Pac-Man noise

12 Hours To Live Girl or Fake Proposal Girl?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
12 hours to live.

Let's Go To The Mall or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm.. Let's Go To The Mall, I think...

Marshall or Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall!

Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits or Barney's frantic "dashing off to locate Robin Sparkles memorabilia" bar exits?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits!

Lily's Dad or Robin's Sister?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin's sister.

Barney's perfect pictures or his one bad picture from Say Cheese?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney's perfect pictures!...Hey there, sexy!

Zip, Zip, Zip or Murtaugh?