How I Met Your Mother This Or That

mikee21 posted on Aug 14, 2009 at 01:32AM
Choose which you like better and dont forget to leave one for the NEXT person

I'll star

Drunk Ted or Sober Ted

How I Met Your Mother 760 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-200 of 760

over a year ago Saul_Mikoliunas said…
Sober Ted.
If we saw Drunk Ted too often then it wouldnt be as funny, we need drunk Ted in short bursts =P

Stella or Victoria.
over a year ago germany123 said…
victoria!! though she was a bit *yawn* i really hated stella in the end.


environmental lawyer marshall or selling oot marshall
over a year ago moeexyz said…
Selling oot Marshall, he's mush funnier!

Robin Sparkles or Robin Sherbatsky
over a year ago oblix said…
cool
Scherbatsky, although i love robin sparkles.. i mean she is one of my mobile backgrounds but Scherbatsky is just so darn cool!

Lilly pad or marshmallow
over a year ago jameswilson said…
big smile
Marshmallow!
Hah, Jason Segal is awesome.

One slap right now or 5 slaps randomly for the rest of your life?
over a year ago Saul_Mikoliunas said…
One slap right now =D

Staying on the same track, Slapped by Barney or slapped by Lily?
over a year ago silverlotus said…
Slapped by Barney, just because I love nph.

Barney in love or Barney being himself?
over a year ago oblix said…
tongue
Barney being himself (as much as i love him in love he's sooo cute like that)

strict teacher Ted or laid back teacher Ted ?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Laid back teacher Ted. He seems cool.

Roommates or friends with benefits?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Roommates :)

Lily or Robin?
over a year ago Hello1578 said…
I pick Robin. She is cool.

Barney in a suit or Barney without suits?
over a year ago ncisfan001 said…
In a suit. Barney just isn't Barney without it.

Barney or Ted?
over a year ago ajhalecullen said…
I have to say Barney hes so awesome =]

Lily or Marshall?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lily :)

Barney's brother or Ted's sister?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Barney's brother!

Rabbit or Duck?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Duck.

Lily or Alyson?
over a year ago ajhalecullen said…
Hard choice!!! Lily

Robin or Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
urm Barney :D. Love both though :)

Which Barney phrase: "Suit Up" or "Legend..wait for it..dary"?
over a year ago NCIS1002 said…
"Legend...wait for it..dary"

Stella or Victoria?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Defiently Stella :)

Who would you rather kiss Marshall or Ted?
over a year ago Saul_Mikoliunas said…
Ted, I dont want another woman kissing Marshall, he is for Lily only!

Lily as a brunette or Lily with red hair?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lily as a brunette :) she looks gorgeous with both though!

Better nickname: Marshmallow or Lilypad?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Marshmallow

Professor Mosby or Architect Ted?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Architect Ted.

Robin with Ted or with Barney?

over a year ago 123Naki456 said…
Robin with Barney. :]]

Lilly or Robin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Robin :D Love both though.

Stella or Victoria?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Victoria!

Single Robin or Robin with Don?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Single Robin! Hate Don.

Jason Segel or Marshall?
over a year ago Saul_Mikoliunas said…
I liked Don!

Marshall. Although Jason is hilarious, Marshall is cute and sweet and cuddly =D

Lily as a painter or a teacher?

over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Er both! But i'll go with as a painter :)

Season 1 or Season 2?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Season 2.

Ted with Robin or Victoria?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
With Victoria :)

Slapsgiving or Slapsgiving 2: Revenge Of The Slap?
over a year ago LaPiccolaFra said…
Slapsgiving

Barney and Ted or Marshall and Ted?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney and Ted :)

Lily and Robin or Marshall and Barney?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Lily and Robin

Slap Bet or Slapsgiving?
over a year ago esiu093 said…
Slap bet :D:D:D


Barney vs Swarley
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney

Stella or Tony?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Stella :)

Barney and Lily's Friendship or Marshall and Robin's?
over a year ago LaPiccolaFra said…
Barney and Lily's FTW!

Let's go to the mall or Sandcastles in the sand? (considering the musicvideo AND the song itself)
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Eline_K said…
smile
Sandcastles in the sand! Gotta love the robot! ;)

Marshall & Lily as pirate & parrot or as Sonny & Cher?
over a year ago MetallicarXD said…
Sonny and Cher!

Hmmm...

boy kid or girl kid
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Girl kid!

Mustache Marshall or Lesbian Robin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
AHA! Mustache Marshall xDD

Which Barney/Robin kiss: Their First Kiss or the one in "The Leap"?

over a year ago AnaHallam said…
First one I think

Lily's hair: Season One or Season 3?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Season 3

Barney as Lorenzo von Matterhorn or as the Eastern European Street artist?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Lorenzo von Matterhorn every time!

Bareny with Robin or Bimbos?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
With Robin!<3

Season 2 or Season 3?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Season 2

Bros (Barney, Marshall and Ted) or Hoes (Lily and Robin)
over a year ago oblix said…
Bros

lilyandmarshallselltheirstuff.com OR tedmosbyisajerk.com
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
tedmosbyisajerk.com

Dead Wife's Kidney or Prince of Norway?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Prince of Norway

Ted & Robin's apartment or Marshall & Lily's apartment?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Marshall and Lily's

Barney dressed as a pilot or a devil?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Horny devil :P

Slutty Pumpkin or Penguin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Slutty Pumpin aha.

The Bro Code or The Chick Code?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
The Bro Code! XD

Laser Tag or Marshgammon?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Laser Tag!

Drunk or a kid?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
A Kid :P

Teddy Bear or T-Mose?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
T-Mose ;)

The Crazy/Hot Scale or The Lemon Law?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Crazy/Hot Scale everytime XD

Barnman & Robin or Swarley & Roland?
over a year ago HowIMetRobin said…
heart
I want Robin to get back together with Ted so Swarley and Roland :D

Robin/Ted or Lilly/Marshall
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Lily/Marshall. Sorry but I'm Barney/Robin all the way.

Stella or Scooter?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Stella. I didn't actually mind her.

Barney or Marshall/Lily?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney

Ted with blonde hair or Robin with highlights?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Robin with highlights.

Nothing Suits Me Like A Suit or You Just Got Slapped?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Nothing Suits Me Like A Suit! (yeej on the Emmy's nom! :D)

Scotch or beer?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Beer

Girls or Suits?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Suits xD

Barney/Robin or Marshall?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney/Robin XD

Marshall forgetting his pants or a monkey wearing two tuxedos?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Marshall forgetting his pants LOL

The Pilot or Season 1 Finale?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Season 1 finale

Say Cheese or Home Wreckers?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Say Cheese :)

The Leap or Sandcastles In The Sand?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
The Leap

Ted's sister or Robin's sister?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Hmmm, Robin's Sister :)

Marshall's Brothers or Barney's Brother?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney's brother XD

Canada or America?
over a year ago germany123 said…
canada!


wow i havent been playing so sorry if this is a repeat:


thanksgiving in a strip club VS thanksgiving at the apartment
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Thanksgiving in a strip club XD

Lesbian Barney or Lesbian Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
laugh
gotta go with lesbian Barney! xD

stripper Lily or Mexican wrestler Ted?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Oooo both aha. Mexican Wrestler Ted :)

The Three Days Rule or The Platinum Rule?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
the platinum rule.

Barney Stinson or Neil Patrick Harris?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
WOW that's a really difficult one. Gonna have to go with Barney though xD

Stella or Scooter?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm... Scooter's adorable plus he's played by NPH's boyfriend... so I feel like I'm gonna have to go with him. ^^

Definitions or Robin 101?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Definitions

Natalie or Tony?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
mmm... Natalie.

The "Burt Reynolds" or the "Olympic Gymnast"?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
The "Burt Reynolds" ;)

Season 1 or 2?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Season 2.

Shannon or Karen?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oh man, I can't stand Karen! definitely Shannon.

season 3 or season 4?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
season 4

A P in the gutter or Julia Roberts?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
I'd take a P in the gutter over Julia Roberts any day! xD

The third slap (Slapsgiving) or the second slap (During Barney's show)
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
The second slap all the way. It was so unexpected and hilarious.

Slut up or Snowsuit up?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
slut up!!

Benefits or The Fight?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Benefits :)

The yellow umbrella or the house Ted bought?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The yellow umbrella! :D

Wendy the waitress or Ranjit?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Ranjit.

Ranjit's wife or Robin's dad?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Ranjit's wife.

"Hi, haaaave you met Ted?" or "Hi, haaaave you met my brother?"?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Have you met Ted of course XD

Drunk Ted or Angry Ted?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
drunk Ted practically trumps all!

laser tagging or an all night rave in an abandoned tire factory?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Laser tag!

Screw getting old or I'm too old for this 'stuff'?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
screw getting old!

Barney's mom or Lily's dad?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney's Mum :)

The Scuba Diver or The SNASA?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
SNASA XD

Lily's english accent or Marshall's hat?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall's hat. Lily's British accent is soooooo painful.

Barney not wearing suits to get laid or Barney trying to get laid wearing overalls?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Overalls :) for the brotp moments XD

Don or Karen?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oohh.. I hate them both! Karen cause she wasn't interfering with BRotp.

Barney and Robin or Marshall and Lily?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney and Robin but I do love Marshall and Lily. I just love brotp a lot more!

Ted's daughter or Ted's son?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm... Ted's daughter.

Alyson Hannigan or Jason Segel?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Both, Jason Segel a little more :)

Lily or Barney?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Barney

Lily and Barney or Marshall and Ted?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm..... that's a tough one. I'm going with Lily and Barney.

Lily and Barney or Lily and Ted?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Lily & Ted. But only just.

Suits or a pot of gold?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Given that I don't know how good I look in suits, I'll take a pot of gold and sneak off to buy a suit with some of it. ;)

Ted's little dance in Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Ted singing Cheap Trick in The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Cheap Trick. He is so cute in that scene XD

Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Nothing Suits Me Like a Suit. There is no comparison.

Let's Go to the Mall or You Just Got Slapped?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Has to be You Just Got Slapped! xD

Season 3 or 4?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
season 4

Rain Dance or Cheap Trick Karaoke?
over a year ago hstb said…
Cheap Trick Karaoke. I love drunk Ted!

Don or Tony?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
oh man that's a hard one... Don. he didn't make our boy Ted into a total asshole while glorifying himself in a major motion picture. lol.

Crazy Meg or Abby?
over a year ago hstb said…
Crazy Meg.

The Yellow Umbrella or The Pinneaple
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple!

Not a Father's Day or The Naked Man?
over a year ago hstb said…
Naked Man

Come On or The Leap?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Leap!

Twin Beds or Of Course?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm... I think Of Course

Ted's Mom or Barney's Mom?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Barney's Mom

Ted's Mom or Lily's Dad
over a year ago hstb said…
Ted's Mom

You Just Got Slapped or Barney's Christmas Carols?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ohh... that's a tough one....... umm... You Just Got Slapped.

Carl or Wendy the Waitress?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Carl

Something borrowed or Something Blue?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Something Borrowed :)

The Stinsons or Not A Father's Day?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Stinsons-- for the nice BRotp moment at the end! <3

Lily and Robin or Ted and Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Woah that's a difficult one. Gonna have to go Ted and Barney though :)

Cobie Smulders or Robin Scherbatsky?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Scherbatsky... I've never seen Cobie Smulders in anything else.

Alyson Hannigan or Lily Aldrin?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lily Aldrin :)

Sarah Chalke or Britney Spears?
over a year ago hstb said…
Sarah Chalke

Trudy or Natalie?
over a year ago AnaHallam said…
Trudy

Robin Mosby or Robin Stinson?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin Stinson!!!

Dirty Barney or Sweet Barney?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Hmmm that's difficult. Sweet Barney :)

Sandy Rivers or Crazy Meg?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Crazy Meg. Sandy Rivers is a douche.

Crazy Meg or the girl who wouldn't leave Barney's apartment in World's Greatest Couple?
over a year ago hstb said…
Umm... That's a difficult one... Crazy Meg

Voices or You Give Love A Bad Name?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
VOICES!

Not Moby or Regis Philbin?
over a year ago hstb said…
Not Moby.

Blue French Horn or Yellow Umbrella?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
SMURF PENIS!

Barney's daddy issues or Robin's daddy issues?
over a year ago hstb said…
Robin's daddy issues

Game Night or The Pineapple Incident?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Pineapple Incident! As much as I ADORE Game Night, the Pineapple Incident makes me laugh more than anything ever.

Spoiler Alert or Intervention?
over a year ago hstb said…
Gosh that's difficult... Spoiler Alert, but Intervetion is a great episode!!

"Where Were We?" or "Definitions"?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Definitions for sure!!

Barney's "FINISH HIM!" or Barney's Pac-Man noise?
over a year ago hstb said…
Pac-Man noise

12 Hours To Live Girl or Fake Proposal Girl?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
12 hours to live.

Let's Go To The Mall or Sandcastles in the Sand?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mmm.. Let's Go To The Mall, I think...

Marshall or Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall!

Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits or Barney's frantic "dashing off to locate Robin Sparkles memorabilia" bar exits?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney's Angry "storming out" bar exits!

Lily's Dad or Robin's Sister?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Robin's sister.

Barney's perfect pictures or his one bad picture from Say Cheese?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney's perfect pictures!...Hey there, sexy!

Zip, Zip, Zip or Murtaugh?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
how is there even a question? ZIP, ZIP, ZIP OF COURSE!

Barney comforting Robin in Sandcastles in the Sand or Barney being all jealous because of Ted and Robin hooking up in Benefits?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago hstb said…
Oh!... That's difficult!!... Barney being jealous in Benefits. It means that he really cares about her. Also, NPH is really funny in there!

Benefits or The Possimpible?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Benefits! best episode ever!!

Ted's naked lady noise or Ted's red cowboy boots?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Red Cowboy Boots ;)

Ted or Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
hm... Robin, I think.

Barney's magic tricks or Barney's playbook?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney's playbook. NPH's magic tricks

Ted or Marshall?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
[true about the magic. ^-^] Marshall! <3

Devil Barney or Flight Suited Up Barney?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago hstb said…
Mm..Flight Suited Up Barney

Marshall as Cher or Barney as a Lesbian?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
I gotta go with Marshall as Cher for this one.

Lily as Sonny or Lily as a parrot?
over a year ago hstb said…
Lily as Sonny.

Marshall as a Vampire or Marshall as a Gay Pirate?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Marshall as JACK SPARROW. not a gay pirate ;)

Something Borrowed or Something Blue?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Something Borrowed :)

Season 1 or Season 5?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
season 5.

season 2 or season 4?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Season 4

Would you rather be: a Lawyer like Marshall or a Teacher like Lily?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
a teacher for sure.

Barney's job or Robin's morning show job?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Barney's!

Marshall and Lily's First or Second Wedding?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
the first one! <3

Zip, Zip, Zip or Definitions?
over a year ago Eline_K said…
Zip, Zip, Zip!

Blonde Ted or brown hair Ted?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Brunette Ted! lol

Season three or season four?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Season Four :)

The Leap or Definitions?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Definitions for sure! <3

Sandcastles in the Sand or The Goat?
over a year ago hstb said…
Sandcastles In The Sand

Stella or Don?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Stella. Stella wasn't getting in the way of my BRotp. :)

Stuff or Slapsgiving II?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago hstb said…
Slapsgiving II

Life Among The Gorillas or Nothing Good Happens After 2 a.m.?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Life Among the Gorillas. I'm not a big fan of Nothing Good Happens After 2am...

Ted waking up with a mysterious pineapple on his nightstand or Ted waking up with a butterfly tramp stamp?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
With the pineapple!

Lily Pad or Marshmallow?
over a year ago hstb said…
Marshmallow!

Intervention or The Front Porch?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Intervention!

The Best Burger in New York or I Heart NJ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
I Heart NJ :)

Cobie Smulders or Alyson Hannigan?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Cobie Smulders.

Swarley and Roland or Barnman and Robin?
over a year ago hstb said…
Mm... Barnman and Robin

Ted's sister or Robin's sister?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Definitions or Robin 101?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Robin's Sister, Definitions :)

"Suit Up" or "You've Been Lawyered!"?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
...I'm not forgetting to choose this time! Suit up!

Barney in season one or Barney in season five?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney all the time!!... But I prefer season 1 :P

Chloe [Crazy Eyes] or Crazy Meg?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Crazy Eyes! ahaa..

Season 1 Ted or Season 5 Robin?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ehh... it's a tough one. I think I'm gonna go with season one Ted though.

The Bro Code or The Playbook?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Eline_K said…
smile
The Bro Code

Being naked-muggered or being monkey-muggered?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
monkey-muggered. duh.

The Lemon Law or The Platinum Rule?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
The Lemon Law

Robin's middle name (Charles) or Ted's middle name (Evelyn)?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Evelyn. xD

Ted's mom or Ted's dad?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
His mum.

The Duel or Belly Full of Turkey?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
The Duel. I just watched it yesterday! xD

Three Days of Snow or Sorry, Bro?
over a year ago hstb said…
Three Days Of Snow, for sure. Love that epi!

Atlantic City or Something Borrowed?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
Atlantic City... SO funny!

The Fight or The Naked Man?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
The Naked Man! HAHA xD

Lily's "Son Of A Bitch" line or Barney's "Haaaaave you met Ted?" line?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ah! that's a tough one. I'm going with "Haaaaaaave you met Ted?" I'm totally going to do that to one of my friends at my homecoming dance this year. xDDD

The Pencil Miracle or Barney's Christmas songs?
over a year ago hstb said…
Barney's Christmas songs. Sister, sister, sister...XD

The Leap or The Goat?
over a year ago HouseOfficeFan7 said…
ahh... The Leap.

The Goat or Twin Beds?
over a year ago hstb said…
The Goat

Toy Guy or Food Guy?