What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Mulan When do you think Shang fell in love with Mulan ?

111 fans picked:
Share this poll with others!
After discovering she was a girl
   82%
While she was disguise as a soldier
   18%
 peteandco posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

22 comments

user photo
NimfaDora picked After discovering she was a girl
NimfaDora picked After discovering she was a girl:
I think he wasn't interested when she pretended to be a boy, he's not gay.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
NCISLuverjk93 picked While she was disguise as a soldier
NCISLuverjk93 picked While she was disguise as a soldier:
Poor guy probably thought he was gay lmao, but she flirted alot& he acted interested sometimes... :)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
peteandco picked After discovering she was a girl
peteandco picked After discovering she was a girl:
lmao ?

For me , his behaviour before learning she was a girl is directed by pride and respect for the soldier he trained ( Ping was the best in the team).
I actually think he fell in love with her after the end of the movie . At the end, he's interested; and then he learned to know her as she really is while she not hiding anything of herself to him.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
friendsfan101 picked While she was disguise as a soldier
friendsfan101 picked While she was disguise as a soldier:
LOL agreed with Jocelyn!
I think that he was more "interested" with Ping, and we saw how hurt he was when he found out Mulan was a girl. *implications, no?*
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Haruka_Disney picked After discovering she was a girl
Haruka_Disney picked After discovering she was a girl:
Yeah.. I don't think it would be when she was a soldier, because if he fell in love with her while she was a soldier, he would have been gay O.o
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Taylah_Jade picked After discovering she was a girl
Taylah_Jade picked After discovering she was a girl:
i agree with peteandco
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Renjio picked After discovering she was a girl
Renjio picked After discovering she was a girl:
Yeah,boys are always falling in love with pretty girls:))
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Ellejane picked While she was disguise as a soldier
Ellejane picked While she was disguise as a soldier:
he doesn't need to be gay to fall in love with a boy. i think that when Mulan was still known as Ping, the general began to have feelings for "him", not knowing that "he" is a "she" and when he found out that "he's" a girl, he was finally able to show his feelings. and besides, even if Mulan isn't a "she", they would have still been in love, probably. your brain can't control the feelings in your heart, only deny them.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
NightFrog picked After discovering she was a girl
NightFrog picked After discovering she was a girl:
I think he did actually start to have feelings for Ping, but once he found out that she was a girl, he just let himself feel that way. Before he could have been holding back. That also could be that he was proud that he trained her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
fiina picked After discovering she was a girl
fiina picked After discovering she was a girl:
well to me Shang becomes friends with Ping and after find out he fell in love with Mulan
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Hinomari13 picked After discovering she was a girl
Hinomari13 picked After discovering she was a girl:
I agree with fiina. The general had no feeling for Ping rather than friendship and when he found out about he being a girl he fell in love with her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
2kn111 picked After discovering she was a girl
2kn111 picked After discovering she was a girl:
He was only "interested" by Ping after he/she climbed the post and became a good soldier, because he/she was the best warrior. He didn't fall in love with her until the end of the movie.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
amzel picked After discovering she was a girl
amzel picked After discovering she was a girl:
hes not gay guys
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
prussiaducky picked After discovering she was a girl
prussiaducky picked After discovering she was a girl:
Unless Shang is gay...which can't be posdible since he fell in love with Mulan O.o
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
prussiaducky picked After discovering she was a girl
prussiaducky picked After discovering she was a girl:
I guess he had brotherly love hehehe
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl:
I think it was when she was a solider but I also think he knew she was a girl before he fell in love. My reasoning is the way he starts to look at her and when he tells her to go home he is trying to protect her
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl:
So he was in love with mulan well she was a solider but he knew she was a woman that's why he didn't kill her revenue though she was suppose to he had already fallen in love because let's be honest mulan wasn't exactly a convincing as a man and if you pull up a girl's hair you can tell by her facial structure she is a woman so shang knew mulan was a girl before the medical information
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl
kater507 picked After discovering she was a girl:
*even
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LittleSONE19 picked After discovering she was a girl
LittleSONE19 picked After discovering she was a girl:
Duhhh! LOL
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
PerryTheTeenage picked After discovering she was a girl
PerryTheTeenage picked After discovering she was a girl:
Do you seriously think Disney would create a canonly bisexual main character?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
truth76 picked After discovering she was a girl
truth76 picked After discovering she was a girl:
Just like Fiina.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
TML1988 picked After discovering she was a girl
TML1988 picked After discovering she was a girl:
Here's what I think: Shang came to trust and respect Ping based on "his" actions (especially the avalanche and the subsequent rescue of Shang), but I think he would have questioned his state of mind if he had truly developed romantic feelings for the person he believed to be Ping. When Ping's true gender was uncovered, Shang was hurt that the "man" he came to trust and respect turned out not to be who "he" claimed to be. Although Shang showed compassion by not killing Mulan, he did throw her aside in the snow-covered mountains, which showed how hurt he felt. This even carried over to subsequent events, when Shang refused to heed Mulan's warning of the looming danger of the surviving enemy forces, and was initially reluctant to participate in Mulan's plan for the final battle. When Shang saw some of the basic elements of Mulan's plan, he decided to lend a helping hand, while noticing how beautiful Mulan looked when dressed in feminine clothing. Then, during the course of the final battle, he noticed that Mulan was still the same selfless, courageous, intelligent, and determined person that she had been while disguised as Ping, which helped restore his trust in Mulan. That, combined with the fact that Mulan was female (and a beautiful one when dressed in appropriate clothing), made Shang fall for her.
posted 3 months ago.