What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Mulan do u think Shang fell in love with Mulan before or after he found out she was a girl?

188 fans picked:
Share this poll with others!
no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
   53%
yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
   39%
Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she...
Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy'
   7%
(added by emmett)
uhhh
   1%
(added by thetankmoment)
 8339emma posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

24 comments

user photo
Dada picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
Dada picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
I think he always found her 'interesting'.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiz picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
tiz picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
I think he was found/ really liked mulan as a guy, and when he found out that she was a girl, fell for her in a "love" sort of way. :D
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
xTobyxluverx picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
xTobyxluverx picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
yea that makes since cuz u can see hes as u say 'interested' but unless hes bi, i bet he was happy shes a girl
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
pretty_angel92 picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
but doesn't make shang as a gay xD
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pandp4eva picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
pandp4eva picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
well he always liked her as a troop member but seemed to mad at her to fall in love with her after he found out she was a girl. still he didn't seem like he was in love with her at the end of the movie in my opinion.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Shang is gay! he fell in love...
Vikitoria picked Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy':
Hehe...I like this answer makes me lol =P
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Shang is gay! he fell in love...
Nariko picked Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy':
Just 4fun!!! ;)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Shang is gay! he fell in love...
Mongoose09 picked Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy':
I dont think hes gay as such but i think he was developing feelings for 'Ping' but yeah.. lol
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
fhghu picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
fhghu picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
He's not gay! I think He fell in love with Her after He found out She was a Girl!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
animeluvr picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
animeluvr picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
yeah, he probably liked her. then found out she was a girl and probably realized by the way she acted around the guys that she was a girl all along. then he fell in love with her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
EmilyELewis picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
EmilyELewis picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
I think it was one of those things where he was in love with her, but didn't really realize it because he still saw her as a man. Then when it turned out she was a female it was like "Oh...so that's what that was all about."
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Shang is gay! he fell in love...
kiraragirl200 picked Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy':
lol Yaoi
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
Shang is gay! he fell in love...
Straggy picked Shang is gay! he fell in love with Mulan when she was a 'guy':
LOL. Of course, he fell for Ping. I bet he makes Mulan dress up as a man for "roleplay".
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Espeongirl360 picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
Espeongirl360 picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
he was relieved when it turned out to be a girl complementing him in a girly way. XD but im sure he was mad when he found out that a girl was beating him while training
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sunflowerchild picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
sunflowerchild picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
he admired her when she was pretending to be a guy. Then when he found out she was a girl the admiration grew.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
fiina picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
fiina picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
"Ping" was his friend but he fell in love with Mulan
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Grrrrr picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
Grrrrr picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
@fiina, totally, he was a friend with "Ping" and fell in love with Mulan
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
2cherryblossoms picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
2cherryblossoms picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
No in the begining he hated 'ping' lol
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
NadineDeer picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
NadineDeer picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
LOL this is one of the best things I like about this movie. They make you toy with their relationship when she was still Ping. But I don't believe Shang was gay. What I think it was is during all of the training and after his life was saved, he saw her as a good friend before her secret was given away.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
PinkNinja10 picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
PinkNinja10 picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
I think Shang liked her as a friend when she was masquerading as Ping but then those feelings grew when he found out she was a girl
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
thetankmoment picked uhhh
thetankmoment picked uhhh:
I don't know, but I DID know someone was gonna call him that
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
lailaritaa picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick
lailaritaa picked yes , i think he was relived wen he found out she was a chick:
i always thought that they had an interesting relationship but i agree with this one
posted 8 months ago.
 
user photo
lilspongelisa picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
lilspongelisa picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
I think he thought of her as a close friend before.
posted 7 months ago.
 
user photo
TML1988 picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her
TML1988 picked no , he saw her as a girl and then fell in love with her:
Here's what I think: Shang came to trust and respect Ping based on "his" actions (especially the avalanche and the subsequent rescue of Shang), but I think he would have questioned his state of mind if he had truly developed romantic feelings for the person he believed to be Ping. When Ping's true gender was uncovered, Shang was hurt that the "man" he came to trust and respect turned out not to be who "he" claimed to be. Although Shang showed compassion by not killing Mulan, he did throw her aside in the snow-covered mountains, which showed how hurt he felt. This even carried over to subsequent events, when Shang refused to heed Mulan's warning of the looming danger of the surviving enemy forces, and was initially reluctant to participate in Mulan's plan for the final battle. When Shang saw some of the basic elements of Mulan's plan, he decided to lend a helping hand, while noticing how beautiful Mulan looked when dressed in feminine clothing. Then, during the course of the final battle, he noticed that Mulan was still the same selfless, courageous, intelligent, and determined person that she had been while disguised as Ping, which helped restore his trust in Mulan. That, combined with the fact that Mulan was female (and a beautiful one when dressed in appropriate clothing), made Shang fall for her.
posted 7 months ago.