Lol. This question is going to be clouded by whether people are Team Edward or Team Jacob... but if I was making my choice from the books I would pick Edward because he sounds totally gorgeous - which Robert is but still,- and he is soo nice and sweet and... Perfect. But if I were picking my choice from the films I would pick Jacob because he is sooooo FIT!!!!! sorry, that makes me sound shallow but i prefer Edward's personality and Jacob's looks.
I'm team Edward all the way. But I think both are hot in their own way. Jacob was sweet to Bella in New Moon. But once you go Vampire you never go back. Who would want to if you had Edward by your side forever.
I really don't know when did the question "who is hotter,Jacob or Edward" turn into "who is hotter,Taylor or Robert",'cause most of the people are answering:(and I don't mean just the question here,in this spot,but anywhere)"Taylor,duuuuuuuhhhhhhhhh,Edward is soooooo ugly",it's about the books characters and not Robert or Taylor,or if it's about them,then I think the question should be"who's hotter,Taylor or Robert".Everyone are fighting around actors who play them.My answer:EDWARD BABY,ALL THE WAY!!! :D