[Excuse the repeat-ness of this pick, it's valid!} Which girl do you really think is the best? {Looks, personality, talent - all that combined} Poll Results - One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill [Excuse the repeat-ness of this pick, it's valid!} Which girl do you really think is the best? {Looks, personality, talent - all that combined}

This question is now closed

103 fans picked:

Sophia Bush

44%

Bethany Galeotti

42%

Hilarie Burton

15%

Danneel Harris

no votes yet

xoheartinohioxo posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

44 comments

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: I want to do a pretty decent sized picspam, so I'd like to get an idea of which of these 4 girls is the best in your opinions =] posted over a year ago.

	OMGitsBrooke picked Sophia Bush: One word: PERFECT! posted over a year ago.

	shearer7 said: i really can't pick. as far as characters go, i love haley, she'd definitely be my favorite. & joy is also amazing. i cry EVERY time that she does. i think she is ridiculously talented. i've met her a few times before & she is insanely kind & gorgeous without effort, so i love her to pieces. sophia is also gorgeous. she was also nice when i met her, but it was just in passing, like i didn't have a convo with her or anything, so i don't really know much about her. but she is obviously talented seeing as she is the only person on the show doing any big time movies outside of oth. (john tucker & hitcher. the narrows & table for 3 aren't huge movies, but they are still work) hilarie is awesome. i don't like peyton, but i met hilarie & she is hilarious. there are times when i like her acting & times when i don't, but that might just be because i'm not a fan of the character. she is also beautiful. and danneel. never met her, i don't really know anything about her personality. & rachel didn't really have as many dynamics as the other 3 characters did, so i can't really judge how talented she is compared to the other 3. but she is hot. i just always feel bad judging the person because i don't really know who they are, i just have an idealized version of them. posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: ^^^ lol you are too funny! I'm just glad to see that I'm so not the only person who can turn a question like this into a long ass response! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	deanwastedyou picked Hilarie Burton: all the way :] posted over a year ago.

	BrookeDavisfan1 picked Sophia Bush: for me she's the only ONE (and it has nothing to do with the fact that am a huge Brooke fan) posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Hilarie Burton: I'm so over Sophia... Hilarie all the way posted over a year ago.

	ElliesOwner picked Bethany Galeotti: I just think Bethany Joy is so awesome! She is very much herself and doesn't try to be something she isn't. She is gorgeous inside and out. I don't know very much about Danneel, I'm not very impressed by the roles she chooses. I do think Hil and Soph are both fabulous! posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: I'm so over Sophia... Hilarie all the way And I'm so over comments like that. Please, It's so cliche but: if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. Sophia, Hilarie, Bethany AND Danneel are all gorgeous, talented woman who deserve praise and respect. posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Hilarie Burton: I can say whatever I want. Just because you don't like or don't agree with what I say, doesn't mean I was disrespectful by saying it. what I said wasn't disrespectful at all. Saying that I'm just over somebody really isn't that big of a deal, it's not like I insulted or bashed her. Sorry but you're in no position to tell people what they can or can't say :) posted over a year ago.

	PrettyGirl93 picked Sophia Bush: shes the best :D posted over a year ago.

	alex_sandra picked Sophia Bush: soph and joy posted over a year ago.

	backtoblack picked Hilarie Burton: As a complex Hilarie definitely. Sophia is VERY beautiful tough. And Joy is very talnted as an actress and a singer. Daneel...well I don't have an opinion. posted over a year ago.

	Shanice_12 picked Sophia Bush: Sophia Bush all the way..then Hilarie, Daneel and Joy =] posted over a year ago.

	sk91 picked Hilarie Burton: I LOVE Hil<3 Though Sophia is awesome too :D posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: Listen TBSAC, you're a rude and disrespectful person. 95% of your comments are negative and/or bashing. So how about for once you just stfu. I really don't care about being a bitch anymore when it comes to you. My comment wasn't in anyway rude to you, but don't fucking tell me what i have the right to say in my pick. All i asked your immature self to do was not say anything if you couldn't keep it nice. Clearly you have a problem with being mature and polite so maybe you should go work on that instead of finding any reason possible to be a bitch. posted over a year ago.

	OMGitsBrooke picked Sophia Bush: couldn't have said it better myself! posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Hilarie Burton: I never said you were being rude. I said that you aren't in any position to act like my mom and tell me what I can or can't say. Who cares if this is "your pick"? That doesn't give you the right to censor peoples comments or opinions. Me saying that I'm over Sophia is not a big deal... and quite honestly, really doesn't concern you in the least. If you don't like it then I'm sorry. But you're still in no position to tell people "if you don't have anything nice to say don't say anything". Because i/we can say whatever we want... whether if you made this pick or not And I'm not the one that "finds any reason possible to be a bitch". All I did was say that I was over somebody (which I have every right to say, it wasn't an offensive comment at all). then YOU were the one that decided to act all high and mighty, and single me and my comment out, and tried to tell me what I'm allowed to say or not allowed to say. Seriously get over yourself and let people say what they want. Nobody needs your approval posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	3_ThePretender picked Sophia Bush: Sophia IMO is the gorgeous, the nicest and the most talented. I think Hilarie is a great actress and I think Joy has a great personality but Sophia is my favourite :) posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: 1.) I didn't say anyone needed my approval so don't go putting words in my mouth. 2.) It IS rude to just be like "I'm so over ______" You're still being negative, but i guess because you did it subtly i should applaud you? NO. 3.) Actually, when it comes to stuff like that, "if you don't have anything nice to say..." WE ARE ALL IN THE POSITION TO SAY THAT! There is entirely too much rudeness and hatred on this whole site and it's disgusting. But what troubles me even more is the people like you who think there is something wrong with going by that tried and true saying. Maybe if people would take that advice a little more often, we wouldn't have so much fighting and drama throughout the site. 4.) Yes, yes hun you DO find any reason to bitch and bash. I've seen you in so many picks finding any way you can to bash Brooke and/or Brucas, so lets not even try to lie on that one sweetie. You find any way you can to start bashing, even if it's not relevant to the pick. 5.) And I'm so over comments like that. Please, It's so cliche but: if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. Sophia, Hilarie, Bethany AND Danneel are all gorgeous, talented woman who deserve praise and respect. ^^^ Where in that comment do you see the words "You are not allowed to..." Nowhere because you're a liar. You try to twist around everything and it's ridiculous! I asked you nicely to please keep the negative out of here. I didn't demand, or tell you what you could and couldn't say, i just flat out, bluntly stated how i felt. And as usual, you have to turn it in to a long drawn out argument. So let's solve this the easy way - You stfu and I'll stfu. Easy peasy lemon squeezy. posted over a year ago.

	OCFan123 picked Sophia Bush: Nothing to do with the fact that im a huge Brooke fan! posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Hilarie Burton: What on earth are you even talking about at this point? You're rambling on about nothing. What do my negative comments or opinions on brucas have to do with any of this? What I said about being over Sophia is NOT a big deal and didn't warrant any response from you whatsoever. Bottom line is that If you aren't trying to tell people what we are/aren't allowed to say... Then why butt in and say anything about my comment at all? You're totally contradicting yourself. And yes, clearly you do think that people need your approval otherwise you would just (heaven forbid) let people have their own opinions and say what they want without butting in and giving your two cents about whether someones comment was appropriate or not I'm going to say what I want. And what I said in this pick wasn't even bad or offensive or wrong. If you don't like it then oh well, that's life. posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: And if you don't like what i have to say then that's life as well huh. Funny how it never seems to go both ways with you. You can say whatever you want, but I'm not allowed to? Yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense. posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Hilarie Burton: See... There's a difference between what I say and what you say though. What I say is just my personal opinion about whatever topic is being dicussed. But what YOU say isn't about the topic, but about other peoples comments. If you want to give your own opinions about these picks then great. But don't try and tell me what I can or can't say or that I can only say nice things or nothing at all. That's the difference between my comments and yours. I stay on topic. You however, feel the need to call people out personally and give your two cents about why their comments were right or wrong. Just do me a favor and go play "mom" to someone else. I already have a mom, I don't need another one posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	yaknowyaloveme picked Bethany Galeotti: Beth is just stunning at all!!! She's so nice and beautiful person & ofc AMAZING;TALENTED singer/actress. Even I REALLY LIKE Sophia :* Joy rocks for me since the beginning! <333 ALL OF THEM ARE AWESOME! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: I'll probably get to work on this over the weekend so for all you Bethany fans, if you have any favorite appearances or other projects besides OTH, feel free to link me to some pics =] posted over a year ago.

	BreytonHaley picked Hilarie Burton: I love Hil <3 She has a great personality and is soo funny. And i really love her acting, it's amazing _ Joy is really talented, she has a great voice and is an amazing actress. Sophia is great, too. I really love the movies she is in, but i think it's just her acting, which i love so much. nothing else xD Danneel is great, but i don't know about her so much. She was really good at playing Rachel and i loved her also in Fired Up. (: posted over a year ago.

	SophiaBrookefan picked Sophia Bush: It was very hard to pick,My fave are Soph&Hil But i chose Sophia cause i like her a bit more! She's sweet,funny&Just Amazing! I Adore Her<3 But Hilarie Is Gr8at,Funny&nice so it was really hard to pick! posted over a year ago.

	brucas_naley101 picked Sophia Bush: i love sophia sooo much! & i cant really judge hilarie bc i dnt like her character & bc of that her scenes. so idk if its her or the character i lik. but i love the rest. i just cnt judge hil. hope that makes sense. posted over a year ago.

	jehan picked Bethany Galeotti: i guess they're all talented but i picked bethany because her voice is so great and when she acts mean,she really! posted over a year ago.

	mila18 picked Sophia Bush: fcken GORGEOUS, soooo classy, AMAZING actress.. this girls perfect.<3 i also LOVE danneel, well i like all but yeah posted over a year ago.

	anetted picked Bethany Galeotti: Ahh, I had a really hard time deciding. Hilarie is my favorite actress, but I just felt like picking Bethany here. posted over a year ago.

	HotStunner picked Sophia Bush: Sophia Bush Defo Has It All (: And I Also Feel Bethany Does Aswell posted over a year ago.

	BrucasFTW picked Sophia Bush: I am so in love with Sophia. She is so beautiful, funny, amazing and has a personality to die for. She is my favorite actress ever and i think she is the best actress on the show. She's incredible talented and so down to earth. That's why people love her so much and she deserves to be loved because she's the nicest, most down to earth celebrity ever and she cares alot about her fans. She's a REAL role model. posted over a year ago.

	OMGitsBrooke picked Sophia Bush: I'm so over Hilarie... Sophia all the way ^^ posted over a year ago.

	BLhardcorelover picked Sophia Bush: i LOVE Sophia. She is way more than just a pretty face or a good actress. She actually has a brain and cares about people. posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: Can we please stop with the "I'm so over" like i said before, they are all beautiful, talented woman who deserve nothing but respect! =] posted over a year ago.

	laughingGrl picked Bethany Galeotti: hard pick! all of them are talented nd good looking...but it was between Joy & Sophia. they both seem rly nice nd yada yada yada. but i just had to pick joy. even though sophia has been the most successful actress. tough pick! :) posted over a year ago.

	lucas_sawyer picked Bethany Galeotti: How is this "valid"?? posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: ^^^ Ummm because i wanted fresh opinions, not just randomly choosing one of the various other times it's been asked. Like i said, I'm planning on doing a picspam so i wanted to see who was the most liked right now. Why does it matter to you?? posted over a year ago.

	sophialover picked Sophia Bush: Isn`t it totally clear? posted over a year ago.

	SOPHILCHAD picked Sophia Bush: Sophia has an amazing personality and is so beautiful. She is incredible talented and i just love her to pieces. She's my fave actress ever! posted over a year ago.

	xoheartinohioxo picked Sophia Bush: Ahh okay so apparently Sophia won! I think I'll still do a smaller picspam for Bethany & Hilarie, I'm not sure about Danneel though. posted over a year ago.

	Nibylandija said: Hard choice between Bethany & Sophia... posted over a year ago.