answer this question

Peeta Mellark Question

Dif Peeta and katniss have sex in mocking jay when she said then his lips were there to comfort me and then the hunger was there again?

Mocking Jay
*
yes. i think so.
flirtforever24 posted over a year ago
*
hahaha yeah. You can't have kids without it and it's sounds like it anyway... LMFAO
Tamanax posted over a year ago
*
so true Tamanax
pookie152 posted over a year ago
*
They won't show it
kitkatgymnast posted 4 months ago
 hannabanana123 posted over a year ago
next question »

Peeta Mellark  best answer

okebooop said:
I think, no. They did not. Some of you are simply not understanding the question. In the epilogue, katniss mentions it is almost 10 to 15 years before she agrees to have kids with peeta. So yes, maybe ten years later they do. Some of you are referring to when katniss says "And the hunger that overtook me at the beach. . " Yes she says this. But You are only looking at this phrase individually. Katniss says "And on the night the hunger overtakes me again, I know this would have happened anyway.." Now some of you are saying the thing that happened is that they had sex. Wrong. Because after this sentence, she says "that wahat I need is not gales fire, but the dandelion in the spring.." In other words she loves peeta now, not gale. This doesn't mean they had sex. Now some of you remember when she says, "So after, when he whispers You love me real or not real, I whisper real.." Some of you think, "So after," Means after they have sex. Again, this is wrong. She means, after he asks this question, she says, "Real.." You have to pay attention to phrases. So if this clears it up, they did not have sex at the end of mockingjay. But yes, they did later in the epilogue because, of course, they have kids.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »

Answers

pinkhorse144 said:
NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
elstef said:
She is not too clear about it, but I did take it to mean that they had sex, so I say yes.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
peetasperfect said:
When katniss says "and after" she means after they made love on that night she felt that thing again, the hunger that overtook her on the beach.... Then peeta whispered you love me real or not real and she says real (:
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
that does not happen ! u can tell me the page number and i will look it up if your not sure
katniss19 posted over a year ago
*
well you got the last part right.. but they don't have sex and kids till panem is calm and president snow is dead
katniss15 posted over a year ago
*
Wrong. By "And after," She means after he asks real or not real, she says real. Did you people not take english class in school?
okebooop posted over a year ago
anniina said:
The epilogue doesn't have anything to do with this, since it happens like ten years later.. Of course it's obvious they have sex later because they have kids. I just finished Mockingjay and I got the feeling they had sex for the first time when Katniss told Peeta she loves him. So I would answer yes :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
pedwards712 said:
To answer your question, I think the answer is that yes, I interpreted it as they did have sex. The last line before the epilogue says "So after, when he whispers "You love me real or not real." The after is implying is that he whispers his question after something has occurred. After what? I think this does go back to her saying "on the night I feel that thing again, the hunger that I felt on the beach." Then, she goes through all her realization that Peeta is the only one who can give her the rebirth and hope she needs. I got the impression that in that she was giving herself completely to loving him, and I think the onky thing that would get him to ask that question of her at that point was if they had made love. So, I think the answer is yes.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
when sh is saying so after, she means thats after he says you love me real or not real thats when she says real !
mockingjay2 posted over a year ago
*
I respectfully disagree. The comma coming after "So after," is a break, meaning she is talking about after something happening. If she was meaning after Peeta says the question it would have no break like "So after he whispers you love me, Real or not real." That would have teh connotation that we she is talking about after his question she gives the response. The comma changes teh meaning to meaning after an event on the night she feels the hunger, Peeta asks the question.
pedwards712 posted over a year ago
titanicfan1 said:
YUP! if you read it carefully, you will see, because it said i felt the hunger again, i knew it would happen anyway, and when we were done he asked if she loved him so ya!:D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
poopyou said:
yes they did haha
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
codyo1 said:
she didn't say that specifically but they did to have their kids
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
purplegirl1017 said:
Nope!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
alexthomas said:
I guessed that they did...but it should have been her and Gale...they would have cute babies......she said that she loved and didn't see why she ever thought otherwise...so
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
klarolinelove said:
it wasn't clear but that's what I got from it so I'm going to say yes they did .
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
katniss19 said:
no i do not belive they had sex. all it says was they kissed which doesnt mean anything else.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
you obviously didnt read mockingjay. the epilogue states that they had two kids 15 years later. laterso hey had to have had sex.
mockingjay2 posted over a year ago
brightcolors444 said:
yeah, i guess so, cuz they had kids :P
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Fanpup10101 said:
They did... read the epilogue
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
They had kids 15 years later not then
jillian718 posted over a year ago
headblast123abc said:
Ewwwwwwwwwwwww... How Could You Think that!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
shugochara74 said:
yep cause you can only have kids by having sex. there was some other way from a hospital donation thing though i dunno what its called.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
charisma4 said:
no they dont... I think she means by the hunger of love and that she felt distant but they do later in the epilogue when they have two kids.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
katniss15 said:
no they did not. Katniss would have killed him if he touched her like that. They just kissed
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
jillian718 said:
What part is that I read a few months ago so I can't remember but I thinks its at the very end and Its a teenage book and a preteen book so they can't put a word in their that some kid that doesnt know what sex means u know ask their parents so yeah
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
aaowshamonegirl said:
Yes, I believe.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
minbiscuit9 said:
no
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Katniss321 said:
They had kids so duh and if u read closely u can tell
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Tarabear16 said:
Well they have two kids by the end of the book...there's only a certain way people have kids
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Ahm_Shere said:
To all you people saying "Duh of course they did at the end of the book because they had kids..."

Thanks, I'm REALLY glad you cleared that up for me. /sarcasm -.- That is not what the question is asking.

I personally did not think that they had sex at that point in the book, I'd have thought it would have went into a bit more detail or at the very least would have suggested a bit more than "the hunger was there again". That doesn't prove anything. So, no. I don't think they did.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
sabrina10101 said:
Okay you can't take it as in they had sex. Yes they obviusly had to if they had kids
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
dotsalot said:
If you read the first book after their very first meaningful kiss, she had a hunger for more. The hunger she had after that kiss in Mockingjay was the same hunger in the first book. No they did not do it on the beach. They just kissed.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
horsesarehott said:
i personaly think they do at the end of mockingjay, but people can read and interpret it howeve they want! c:
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hungryreader said:
I've read that passage so many times and not once did I get they impression that there was sex involved. They did kiss and I do agree it's weird he would ask her if she loves him just after the kiss. But remember it's a book so adding the question makes the fans happy that she does tell him she loves him as we fell she does. Plus, Peeta is confused so its normal for him to have to ask for clearity on a subject. Personnaly, if I was constantly questionning myshelf and was told that katniss fells like everybody thinks that she loves me but won't awnser how she does feel and kisses me, I would probably ask her to know where she stands as well.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree with other comments that they are very young to do this, but I do think after reading it that they did, because of his need for clarity. They had kissed so many times before that I don't think more kissing on this night would prompt him to ask that questions. It would have to take something bigger than that, I think.
pedwards712 posted over a year ago
knifethrower101 said:
Well I haven't read Mockingjay yet but I hope they don't,they are to young to be having s*x yet they are 17 years old that is very young in my mind😱
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
thg_lover said:
I don't know it's sounds like it though because later they had kids and it takes awhile before u get pregnant like a coupe of months so I think the probably did or just made out.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
pookie152 said:
i think they were
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hbcheerforlife said:
No they wouldn't have because there was cameras everywhere during the games and then everyone would have been able to see them. Katniss and Peeta would never have done that right then and their. Especially with all of their alleys.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
JDaug_67 said:
Obviously they did, because at the end of the book, it said something about the two kids running around in the yard, making them sound around ten years old, so they had to have had sex somewhere around then, as to whoever said that they wouldn't with the whole world watching, i disagree. you have failed to take into account that they are; a: rebels, b: madly in love, c: they were willing to both die in order to stay together, and d: they might die at any moment, so why not go out with a bang! (so to speak)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
kitkatgymnast said:
They won't show it I don't think??
select as best answer
posted 4 months ago 
next question »