Seasons 3 and 4 I'd keep pretty much the same. It's only Season 5 I'd change. I know some people think that Cole was unforgivable by the time he'd become the Source, but I disagree. It wasn't as if he'd done that deliberately - he'd tried fighting it.
I'd start off the same way. Cole returning from the Wasteland, trying to win Phoebe back because he still loves her, her unable to accept him because she doesn't trust the effect she has on him. That's realistic. Then he'd back off, try to just prove he can be a good person. Try to just be a friend/ally if he can't be her lover....
1st of all: I’ve wrote a fanfic if Phoebe were to die instead of Prue.
‘I’m falling apart
I’m barely breathing
With a broken heart
That’s still beating
In the pain
There is healing
In your name
I find meaning
So I’m holding on
I’m holding on
I’m barely holding on to you ‘~ Broken - Lifehouse
A deal with the Source? How the fuck did he not expect for something to happen? But this? He let out a yell that came from his soul. He even felt Belthazor...
Cole was introduced initially as an innocent and Assistant District Attorney from the Charmed Ones' viewpoint, who has seemingly been targeted by The Guardian demons when the two sisters, Prue and Phoebe, inevitably get mixed up in police business when defending innocents from demons and humans in cahoots with the evil demonic underground. In backplot fact known to the viewing audience but unrevealed to the series characters, the half-human/half-demon Cole is working against the sisters interests and is deep undercover filling a human role while looking for a way to explore and identify the...
"Charmed: Charmed Again: Part 2 (#4.2)" (2001)
Leo: Are you sure she orbed? Are you sure that wasn't something else?
Phoebe: Leo, she disappeared. Bright, white, shiny... thingies came and she reappeared.
Phoebe: What else could it be?
Leo: It just doesn't make any sense.
Cole: Why not?
Leo: Why would Shax want to kill a whitelighter?
Cole: Maybe he doesn't know she's a whitelighter.
Leo: Right... The Source sends out his personal assassin but doesn't know who he's after.
1. They loved each other passionately & they would do anything for each other. Yes, Cole gave up more but so did Phoebe in the beginning- she risked her life to save Cole and indirectly caused Prue's death
2. They connected. No cupids involved (hint Coop). A cupid told Phoebe that with forbidden love, the 2 ppl make the connection - they can't get involved.
3. They felt each other - when something wrong was with each other they knew it. In 'seven year witch' he tells Piper to believe in love and send it out to Leo because love knows no boundaries. When he...