Either, she killed herself, Spencer, Jason, Toby, but, I DON'T THINK IT WAS Jenna, because, you can tell that they're trying to make you think it was Jenna, so you're even MORE suprised when you find out who really did it.
Ithought Jason was pretty suspicious but why would he have been on Spencer's property? Besides you can tell he's really affected by his siters death. Maybe Alison killed herself because remeber how she was talking about how she wanted to die young in a mysterious way?
I think it was Melissa bcuz she found out that Alison and Ian had a thing and got jealous and killed her, and then she married Ian bcuz then he couldn't turn her in, and then got pregnant with him that way he also couldn't turn her in! In the season finale he kept also kept saying, "I'm doing this bcuz I love your sister," and stuff! I think that's who did it!
alison has a mental twin courteney and the only way parents could tell them apart was with a ring that had their initials on it... soo.. their parents had to send courteney off to like some mental institute, and courteney didnt wannna go so she changed rings while alison was sleeping apparently and alison ended up going to the mental institute instead of courteney so so, alison came back that night and murdered her sis courteney for taking her life. but end up killing herself try to kill the other girls and melissa who she kidnaps.
ali had a twin named courtney who had metal issues and liked to pretend to be ali. ali got sent away because their mom thought ali was courtney and so the real ali comes back and kills courtney because she stole her perfect life
I believe that because so many people that watch the TV shows read the Pretty Little Liar books, the creators of the show chose to change who A was and who killed Alison, or Courtney.
I think that while in the books, Alison killed Courtney, Melissa killed Alison in the show. Melissa had the reasons too--Alison was seeing her boyfriend that summer and Melissa probably knew (Ian), and it would have been easy for her. Ali left the barn on Melissa and her family's property that night, talked to Toby and then got in Ian's car. We Ali left the kissing rock to go back to her house, Melissa took the field hockey stick and wacked Ali in the head with it. Ali didn't die, but she was probably unconsious so Melissa shoved her in a hole and buried her alive, hence the dirt in her lungs.
The first -A is mona
The second -A is ian
Ali never really died it was her twin sister courtney who was mental and loved pretending to be ali
After Courtney and Spencer fight Alli, angry at Courtney for preting to be her, pushes courtney into a hole killing her. Shortly after they relize Ali (courtney) is missing they take Courtney (Ali) back to her mental hospital.
Ali had an identical twin sister named Courtney. Courtney had mental problems (she was crazy) and she didn't live with her family for that reason. Courtney traded lives with her sister Ali and started living Ali's life and trying to act like her so she could be "normal" like Ali. Ali, for revenge, killed her twin sister Courtney who everyone thought was Ali. So the conclusion is that Ali never died, Ali killed her sister because of what she had done. :D
The Pretty Little Liars never knew that Ali actually had a twin named Courtney, who was insane. One day, Courtney managed to switch places with Ali. The Ali that all the girls knew was really Courtney! When the real Ali finally came back, she killed Courtney.
YES! Courtney is really the dead one, not A (Ali).
Ali never died. She has a twin sister named Courtney, who is sick in the head, who pretends to be Ali all along, while Ali is away at a mental home. Courtney becomes "friends" with the four girls and learns about all of their secrets and keeps it in a diary. When Courtney (Ali) is supposed to be coming back from the home to visit her family, the real Ali murders her sister in revenge.
Okay, in the last book in the series, Wanted, you learn that Alison DiLaurentis had a twin sister named Courtney DiLaurentis, who didn't live with the family due to mental issues. The twins are identical. Later on you find out that Courtney always pretended to be Alison, causing much confusion amongst the DiLaurentis family. The night that "Alison" disappeared, it was really Courtney in Spencer Hasting's barn, not Alison like the girls thought. Alison despised Courtney because back awhile ago, Courtney dumped Alison's popular friend Naomi, and traded her for 4 new "losers," who just so happened to be Hanna, Spencer, Aria, and Emily. Many of the girls adventures with whom they thought they shared with Alison, were actually with Courtney who pretended to be Alison. In the end you discover that the actual Ali killed Courtney for throwing away her perfect life. The body that was discovered in Maya's backyard was Courtney DiLaurentis. Ali is still alive, but after Mona Vanderwaal dies, Ali takes on the role of "A." So in conclusion, Alison is the killer, and she killed her twin sister, Courtney out of fury and revenge. She ended up killing herself by trying to kill Hanna, Spencer, Aria, and Emily.
The person who was killed was Ali's twin sister Courtney. She was killed by Alison because she had stolen Alisons perfect life
Since I know they plan to differ from the books, it could be anyone. I don't believe that it was really Alison that was killed, but if it was, it was Mona, at least to me. I don't think Ian would've done it. He's just there to throw everyone off.
Mona has every reason in the world to kill her. She made fun of her, and with getting Alison out of the way, she made herself the new queen bee, not to mention becoming Hanna's bestie.
Plus, she's never around, especially when the texts come through. She's always just not there.
If it's not that, I'd suspect Melissa as my second choice. I feel like it'd be more a girl than a boy. And Melissa would want to get revenge for her being with Ian.
1. Spencer- Because she was the one going after Ali when she left the barn and had a huge fight, the night she wen't missing, she has the 'Guilt' look on her face all the time, she is the one that always stood up to Ali (and often got in to fights), and because she knows more than she is telling.
2. Mona- She was really often tortured by Ali, cause she was a geek...and she always points that out when the girls are around when herself and Hanna are talking...and because she's so manipulative, and from time to time it feels like she has a full control over Hanna...and because in the promo for the Hallowen episode, there is a part when Ali gets a doll with a message " Now its mine turn to torture you"...
3. Jena- Def. not blind (fakes that all the time), had a really good reason to kill her ( Ali started the fire in her garage, and knew about the videos that Ian was filming from outside other people's houses and they included Toby and Jenna's video)...
I taught of some new ones, while I was re-watching the show from the beginning....
4. Lucas- he was tormented by Ali and the other girls,and he always brings that up when he is with Hanna and she says something connected to Ali. And also has that innocent look, but he is really smart and he is good with computers and other teh. stuff, and he could use that to have his revenge on Hanna,Spencer, Emily and Aria for what they did to him in the past. And we all know that A is good with that kind of stuff...so it makes sense.
5. Jason- I can't believe I am saying this, because I once thought that it would be to obvious if he was A..but know here I am saying the opposite. Jason was really jealous of Ali, she was smarter and had the center of attention in their family, and after the "cutting of the will thing" Jason got even more furious and aggressive when It came to Ali....and he could have hurt her, without even knowing that. He also had a blackout about the night Ali went missing, and he also has pretty eyes (if you remember the diner lady said to A "Well hello there pretty eyes..." in the summer finale)...
I think Melissa killed Alison. She hated Alison because Ian cheated on her with Alison. Also she hates her sister, Spencer, since she kissed Wren and ruined her engagement to him. Also Spencer kissed Ian, I'm sure Melissa knew about this. She never has forgiven her for that. I also think that she is A since she right before Ian felll down the bell tower when he was about to throw Spencer down he told her, "your sister would want this". A little suspircious I think. A is obviously a team of people that have something againsts the Liars. I think A team included Melissa, Ian, Mona, Noel, Lucas & possibly Jenna. Everyone has a part in it.
It was Ian. In series 2 episode 4 he kills himself, and just before that he wrote a letter saying that he killed ali. I'm not completely sure if Ali framed him for it, but I am pretty sure that Ian did kill her
One I think it could be Melissa. Melissa is kind of weird to me and suspicious and plus she could have been jealous and killed her when she found out he was messing with her. Also, when Spencer was talking to her, she said something like "that's probably what got her killed." I mean, it just seem like an possible observation.
Or, I think it could be Lucas. Lucas has said she has something coming to her and never liked her. He was sweet and nerdy, and those are always the ones who does the crazy stuff. He hated her, and he probably wanted her gone.
I think -A is Mona still. I mean I don't know she always seem suspicious and it'll just make sense. She was mad because Alison wouldn't be her friend, so why not get back at the girls? She Hanna friend, but is she really? Or is that just a cover up?
Most likely the killer and -A is someone you wouldn't expect it to be. I don't think it's Jenna, Toby, Ian, or any of the others. I think Jenna has some secrets that she's not telling or that she doesn't want revealed but how could she kill Alison when she's blind? And if she wasn't blind that would b hard to fool doctors, and her parents just for a "prank".
I actually know who a is because i've read the books a is mona and a is also alie she didnt die her twin sister did because ali killed her they switched places and then ali killed courtney the twin sister
so haha i was rite
i think that it is someone close to all of the 4 girls like a parent,sibling or friend,i also think that A is most likely more then just one person...welll it is not long till we find out who A is but i would really like to see what season 3 is going to be about as the show is based around A if we find out who they are at the end of season 2 then how could there be a season 3? not that i dont want a season 3,but it makes me wonder there must be something big happing at the end of S2 to contioun to S3 :D
Will People Stop saying Jenna, toby and ian .. The killer Cant be obvious thn it would be no suprise at the end. So it would have to be someone none of the girls had thought of but still had a reason to kill alison and shut her up. I think it was Melissa (well shes on my list) because Ali was with Ian on the tape while he was going out with melissa .. and when '?' was burning the log that said "Alison + Ian" it looked as if it was it the barn ... i Dont think it was Lucus either because it Showed the muck on his shoes that time and the writersare just trying to put coincidences in so you will think it is that person , to block you thinking of the real killer. Thats only my opinion but its definately not someone suspicious or someone who had any coincidences (:.
1. Jason because the day of Ians funeral he gets a note to show Aria " i know what you Did".
2. Melissa because i think she finds out that ian is cheating on her. so she kills her.
3. A. even though we still dont know who a is i think it was a because a was bout to kill Emily in one of the episodes and he doesnt feel bad/ and he feels calm about it.
4. MAYBE Arias dad because he didnt want alison telling arias mum that he was having a affair with a student.
5. She MIGHT have commited suicide. u could easily hit your self in the head and dig a hole and someone could bury u.
6. Mona because she was getting bullied by Alison beacause she was a dork/nerd
7. Lucas because she kept teasing him.
So I think everyone is now well aware that the tv show is not going to be exactly the same as the books which means Mona and Ali might not be 'A', however more recent episodes have lead the viewers into suspecting Mona. I personally think 'A' might have something to do with Melissa and that's what Ian was referring to the night in the church when he told Spencer he was "doing it for Melissa" but there are so many characters at the moment with reasons they may have wanted Ali dead so it's still very much a secret to who 'A' actually is... However I do think they will keep the Ali/ Courtney twist, as in the Halloween episode Ali told a story referring to twin girls (possibly the start of the twin secret). Despite the evidence pointing towards Jenna I doubt she is 'A' as it would be to much of an obvious choice?
u all are wrong because season one ending they told us who it was it was jenna and garett because Alison used to make fun of jenna and tease her................ and I think A is Alison and since its not the same as the books VIVIAN might be Alisons twin sister who died and Alison became A and knew all their secrets
WARNING:IF YOU ARE READING THE PRETTY LITTLE LIARS SERIES AND HAVE NOT READ THE END OF BOOK 8 YET, YOU MAY NOT WANT TO READ THIS!!
i know in the books that its the whole Courtney and Alison thing(just finished reading book 8 just wanted to say Sara Shepard is such a great author and i could not put it down!) ,but i have a different theory involving the twin for the show since a lot of things have been different in the book and the show. So, i think that the twin thats alive,Jenna,Ian,Garrett,and possibly Melissa-based on 2/20/12's episode- killed the Alison the 4 girls knew, or at least that those are the people who were involved. The living twin- if things are the same as in the books with this part- wanted courntey dead for stealing her life, Ian and Garrett with there videos could have easily known the girls secrets that alison knew and A knew the secrets "Ali" knew, and Jenna would have wanted revenge for the girls blinding her, so why not stalk and torture them if she can? i know this is just a hunch but it kinda makes sense,don't you think? (srry if i spoiled it for anyone who hasn't made it to book 8!!!! :O )
I think it's Jenna because in the episode 'If these dolls could talk' the little psychic boy describes A as having dark hair like Jenna's. But the girls dismiss this because the boy says A is not blind. Yet at the end of the episode we find out that Jenna isn't actually blind any more, she's just pretending to be and saying her surgery failed
It's Mona in the TV series, and there is probably a team A. There was a person in a red coat (vivian darkbloom) < dunno if i spelt that right. Anyway the person in the red coat i think was Ali. I have heard rumours that the series is different to the books but i dont think it is. i still think that Ali's twin sister courtney is the one who died, not Ali. and Ali killed courtney because Courtney (the twin) was pretending to be her because she had a condition. just like at the end of the episode when Mona was put in the home thingy because she needed to be cured of that personality thing or whatever and thats the same condition Courtney had, which lead the real Ali to kill Courtney, so she could get back at the girls for believing Courtney was Ali. :) hope this helped, it's just my opinion:) xoxo
Alison killed her twin sister. Ali never really died it was her twin sister courtney who was mental and loved pretending to be Ali. Ali tried to tell her parents that she was the real Ali but since Courtney was mental they did not believe her. They took her to a mental institution and she got out and killed her sister who everybody thought was Ali. But Ali is not "a" Mona is and then she dies and there is another "a" and then another. The last one is Ali.
For a start Jenna can see as the episode where she takes her shades of and kills the fly shows it all. She also was there, followed by the police man she is seeing at the time of alisons death as she said "she deserved to die that way". I heard that the twin sister is supposed to kill alison, however that was the storyline in the book. I think that the directors will change the storyline at the end as they must know that everyone would of tried to find out what happened in the original book. Mona has been revealed but she is being told by somebody to send the messages, so clearly mona is only apart of the A team so who is "A" shown in the last part of the season talking to mona? I can't wait for the upcoming episode!! It could be anyone, but i am hoping it's someone we wouldnt of even guessed to have done it, someone who is going to make is feel really silly for not clicking on all along!
i suppose i have more of a question than an answer...why would they make the tv show different to the book ok fair enough a few things but i dont think they would change the killer because that then changes the whole plot there for there would be no point in it being pretty little liars atall...plus dont forget if it is courtney(the real ali) like in the book then jason will now about her so he would be involved so to speak and also i do think it will be courtney because the last scene mona was talking to someone in the mental hospital wich would make lots of sence for it to be the twin ............when i say courtney i mean the real ali i just makes it easier to explain
I think it was Mona or Ms . hastings 1. cuz garret said in jail someone closae to you to spencer . or mellissa . Mona cuz on 'a' Mona said shw would get back at ali . she got back SHE KILLED ALI That's getting her back or revenge
Okay so I don't think it is Jenna cause that is who they want you to think and I had suspected Ian until I saw him dead then I was like automatically sure that his confession was faked. I guess my next guess would be Garrett. Somehow he is involved. And Mona is too I bet. I reckon one of them is killer and one is A. Also to alison67, who the hell do u think it is then because I am so sick of reading about you telling everybody how wrong they are. this is an OPINION and the killer hasn't been revealed so how could u know that anybody here is wrong. Just let them have their say without shutting them down.
Aria Because she never remembers anything from the night Alison went missing or has hallucinations of her and in the posters of pretty little liars aria always have her finger to her lips as if she has a bigger secret than the other girls ... and her family moved to Iceland a year after Alison went missing because of her dad's " Sabattical " which i think is a cover up because aria's family found out she killed Alison and said they were moving to Iceland for a year because of her dad's job..
I think that there are several people that could be A but here is my top 4 susspects.
#1 Aria: Aria could possibly be A because in the last season at the party they said that A would be waring the black swan dress and Aria was wearing the same colors red and black with black golves,and they said A would wear BLACK GOLVES!!!!
#2 Alis twin sister: In the book pretty little liars Ali did have a tiwn sister ,but trying not to give it away but in the book Ali's sister was her evil twin siter. In the tv show we dont know if there is a twin sister but we do remeber Ali's brother saying he does have a other sister. We might be thinking that in some parts Ali's twin sister may have been pretending to be Ali.
#3 Ezra: We may have thought that Ezra could be A because he had have seen every girl who is getting hurt and if it was Ezra was A that would explain why Aria hasn't seen Ali orgotten as bad and death risk. Not only that, but Ezra did have money buried in his socks, that was very suspisious.
#4 Jenna: Some people think that Jenna may not hae been A but if you think about it in the begining she was thoughted that she was a. Also, we thnought that jenna was the one wearing te black swan dress. Not only , but when Jenna was dating Garrett all along she could either been helping him or he was helping her.
Now lastly,I think that there is most likey that Mona is trying to help Hanna bye giving them the website and password also telling them that they are not safe they nedd to come back next tiime.Also if you watch the next show preveiw it shows how they might be opening up mona and trying to get more answers so right now no one w8ll know who A is until you keep on watching the Pretty Little Liars!!!!!!
I think that these people are on the A team: A- which is Alison. I think that Alison's twin sister pretending to be Alison, is actually the one who got killed. T- which is Toby. We all know that Toby is on the A team, because of the summer season finale. Next, I think that Ezra is on the A team only because I think that Aria is on the A team. Yes, I do think that Aria is on the A team, because she was mad at Ali, and wanted to protect her dad, because she knew about his affair. Finally, and obviously, Mona. Mona is on the A team for obvious reasons, because she wanted to get revenge on Ali for being so mean, and she was mad the the girls took Hanna away from her. If you did not catch this, the first letters in al of these people's names spell out A TEAM.
You guys, Aria's dad killed Alison. She's once mentioned "I told the wrong people the truth at the wrong time that's how I ended up here" well remember the very last episode? With the A Train?! Garrett told Spencer that he saw Ali talking to Aria's dad the night she went missing!
I don't think it was Alison who died. I think it was Courtney like in the books, and I think Alison killed her twin sister outta jealousy or something. Also I think that Alison is a part of the -A team because when you think about it, A knows everything about the girls lives.. who else could it be??
In season two there is a halloween episode "The First Secret". The girls walk past the haunted house and the girls get scared because they see someone inside. Alison says its nothing but then she see's a car that says 'Radley Sanitarium' (a mental place) and acts all weird. And when that 'thing' is attacking her she thinks it was just noel but he says it wasnt him. It could've been her twin, Courtney. i mean, if Courtney wanted to kill her then, she could've succeeded somewhere else i.e. near a hole.
One of the parents/ adults... Wren is def on the A team and so is Meredith ... Meredith knows who killed Ali she went to spy on aria dad .. Followed him when he went to talk to Ali .. Meredith got mad because she knew Ali was blackmailing Byron (arias dad) ... Wren get spencer get into the nut house at Riley hospital .. And will try to "befriend" her.. And make her feel more crazy.. Toby dies helping spencer ..
allison had a twin sister named Courtney and she was supposed to be sent to a mentally ill hospital......but they accidentally sent allison so courtney took over allisons life in rosewood but allison escaped from the hospital and killed courtney for taking over her life at one point A was mona but at another it was courtney so now allison is pretending to be A
I think its Wren. Its so easy for a doctor to get pills, steal records of ali's autopsies, and write on Hanna's leg when we was hit by a car, allow mona to leave and come back to the insane asylum when ever she would like.
This may be a spoiler for whoever hasn't watched all of Season 3 just to warn you, but if Ali had a twin sister Courtney, and like the books, she hated her because she ruined her life by pretending she was the crazy twin, and if Ali is alive, and Courtney was the one buried alive in the ground, why would the girl in the red coat who we believe is Ali at the end of season 3 (season 3, episode 24), help Courtney out of the grave?
It's definitly not Mona because in the season finale you find out that Mona dosen't know who red coat is. But in the begginig of the season finale,Toby said that Mona is the only one who knows who she is. I think its either Shauna or Jenna. Also, people say that Alison never even died and she only killed Courtney. She did kill Courtney I think. But they found her body in the very first episode...
I think that Spenser was the one who killed her because Alison was always ditching Spencer and she knew about the kiss of Spenser and Garret who was her sisters boyfriend. Also the Spenser disappeared Ali was gone and Spenser said that she was looking for her.
Ally isnt dead.she killed her twin courtney who wanted to be alison for tricking her parents into taking ally to the mental hospital.its proven on the show.she has stuff in French that says "Blessed with twins" and a family portrait of her,Jason,and courtney.
I think that locas was the won who killed Allison because he was the one that was trying to kill allison at that house on Halloween. He did it because Allison always the one who always was the mean one and she kept bullying him so he decide that he need to get revenge by killing her.