Unicorn in my closet, although that's a good kind of strange! I would hate to have gnomes in my fridge because then id have to put all the food back in my fridge and get the gnomes out which would take a while!
The gnomes in the fridge. The unicorns in my closet would probably just mean I'd tossed one of my stuffed unicorns in there, but the gnomes would eat all the food in my fridge.