answer this question

Random Question

Do you believe people are born gay or do they choose it?

One of my best friends is gay but was raised to be straight all his life, till he chose to try being gay and realised that was what he was meant to be. And it got me thinking, lots of people say that you are born gay, others say that you choose to be gay. I was wondering what are your thoughts on this topic.
 LocalArtistist posted over a year ago
next question »

Random  best answer

Makeupdiva said:
You people are wrong, they are born gay, they don't choose it. Homosexuality has nothing to do with reproducing. You are either gay or you aren't, it's not a choice, just like being straight isn't a choice. It's not like straightening your hair or buying a pair of jeans, those are choices but choosing to be gay? you can't, not every person who is gay chooses to be gay, it's just really something they are born with. But don't realize it until they realize that they are gay.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
This.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
*best*
victoria7011 posted over a year ago
*
I agree. It took me a while to realize that I was bisexual, and it wasn't a choice. It took a lot of thought on if I truly was attracted to females and males. I didn't make myself attracted to both; it was something I discovered.
peacebaby7 posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

prussiaducky said:
I don't believe that anyone is born with a sexuality, I think it develops. You know that 95% of the brain develops from birth to the age of 5, right? Sexuality, in my opinion, is developed. If you are straight, it developed. If you are gay, it developed.

Just my opinion on things, please no hate.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
It's nice to see someone who has a different logical opinion on all of this, and it is true that the majority of the brain develops in that critical time period, but there are lots of innate responses and abilities babies are born with. The hormones that the woman gives the fetus also plays a huge role in how they develop sexually, so this might have something to do with it. No one can prove or disprove homosexuality as a gene or inherited feature, but it could deal with hormones and personality types as well as environment. But in the end no one can choose who they love, and it's okay to love. We need more of it in this world.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
True, I don't think that there is anything wrong with not being straight. Everyone is different, and being in love is a beautiful thing. Being a boy or girl has nothing to do with it. But I still strongly believe that either a) there is no such thing as homosexuality/heterosexuality or b) it develops. I think we all have someone we would go straight or gay for, we just probably will never see or meet them. Maybe we are all bisexual.
prussiaducky posted over a year ago
*
Omg I know right?! I have a paper due next month and Scholar is one of my go-to resources!
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
Roxas1314 said:
'Raised straight' as was I. As was just about everyone else in the world, and yet, homosexual people still exist, still come out, still discover what they like every day. Behaviorism is rampant in the USA(I don't know if that's where you are), so the majority of people think that hetero/homosexualities are 'molded' into the children of this country.

Well, if that were true, all kids in the US would be straight as 99% of everything we see is hetero based nowadays. But people are identifying as gay DESPITE everything straight around them. Is it innate? Is it how they were raised? Is it a developmental process?

Maybe. But someone has to provide proof of these 'choices' through extensive research. No child(except for a very few outliers) before the age of 8 can identify as anything, developmentally they are not interested in anyone, they are just exploring themselves at this stage, just learning about sexual things. During adolescence though, people are exploring lots of things about themselves and going through a storm of hormonal changes and increases, sexuality is something that might not be set in stone until after the brain has fully developed, and that is in the early to late 20's for most people.

'If their brains aren't fully developed that must mean they 'choose' to be gay during their teens!'

Not really, hormones do lots of involuntary things to teens, like menstrual cycles and random erections. Sexual hormones can increase sexual drive, and that isn't a choice. It's a choice to have sex with someone, but not to be sexually attracted to them.

So your friend is experimenting, and he will know better than anyone else if he is gay or not.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
We had a really cool assembly at school that the GSA (Gay/straight alligence club) made for the freshman class. It was very, VERY, depressing, since a lot of kids talked about how they self harmed, how they were bullied in Middle School, and how they were kicked out of their house for coming out. It was sad, but they seemed so happy about themselves now that it made me happy! :) It was a really big presetation, and everywhere in the school, every teacher has an "IT GETS BETTER" sticker :) there is quite a population of LGBT in my school, which is cool
prussiaducky posted over a year ago
*
Wow! That's a really cool community you have in your school! It does get better, but things will be worse before anything can get better, so the highs will be worth more when it does get better!
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
ShadowFan100 said:
No, they aren't. Because gays can't reproduce -_- Everyone knows that u need a guy and a girl to have babies.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Sexual reproduction =/= sole definition of love.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
Dynofox15 said:
They aren't born gay, they choose to be gay.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Okay, so you can choose to be gay and completely devote yourself to someone of the same sex, go ahead, just copmpletely love someone unconditionally right now if it is a choice you should be able to do this without any problems. If you are sexually attracted to a person of the opposite sex you should also be able to completely be sexually attracted to someone of the same sex. Yes, yes, choose to be gay. It's just THAT easy.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
^ I agree. I'm gay and I never chose this. I'd even choose to be straight if I could, but I can't turn straight any more than you, Dyno, can choose to be gay.
LaDispute posted over a year ago
AlOoOosh said:
I think they choose to be gays ..
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Then yo ucan too right? Go on, choose to love and have sex with someoen of the same sex. If it's a choice, everyone can do it, right?
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
Yes anyone can do it ,but I think someone who thinks of that isn't normal.
AlOoOosh posted over a year ago
*
No, not everyone is born normal. There are ALWAYS outliers for EVERYTHING. Got that? That is a FACT. Now, homosexuality was not proven or disproven to be a mental illness by psychiatric means. It was voted on. There is no proof as to if homosexuality is normal or not, the same way as there is no proof that ADHD exists. You want to talk about psychology/psychiatry with a Psych major? Okay, go ahead. The DSM is crap. And that theory that 'bad things happened to make you gay' has little to show for evidence, or even research.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
Book-Freak said:
I think people either are born gay or become gay (but that doesn't mean they choose it). Either they are born gay and from the moment they felt feelings of attraction to anyone it was to someone of the same gender, or over a period of time their sexuality changes as they go through puberty. For example, I have a friend who thought she was straight when we were fifteen (and fancied this guy a lot), came out as bi when we were sixteen and then a couple months later said she was a lesbian. It definitely isn't a choice though.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
'or over a period of time their sexuality changes as they go through puberty' HORMONES! Yes! They influence lots of things concerning sexuality and sexual desire. There is no denying that, it is a fact that hormones influence sexual things. Good answer!
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
Thank you! I totally believe that sexuality is a fluid thing that can change in a person's life.
Book-Freak posted over a year ago
*
Fluidity, everyone changes all the time! Some thing don't change, and some things develop over an exntended period of time, and there isn't anything wrong with that! :D
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
*
Exactly!
Book-Freak posted over a year ago
jessy_an said:
Some choose it.
And some are born this way.
Because not every gay is happy with life, are they?
If they're not then it means they are born this way.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
victoria7011 said:
People are BORN gay, they dont choose to be gay!

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Lovehinagurl44 said:
I'm not really sure. Some people might experiment some to see if they're gay or not.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
frickityfrackle said:
Really, i'm unsure.

Being bisexual, i believe it's more-so something you naturally develop.
it's not something you can just formally decide-
You can't just decide who you fall in love with, now can you? no.
and, to everyone here talking about reproduction;
Stop.
being gay/lesbian/bisexual has nothing to do with whether or not the person wants to have children.
Wanting to have/not have children is a choice, your sexuality has really nothing to do with that, other than the fact that you wouldn't be able to biologically have children together. (unless of course you went to a sperm bank, but that only applies to a lesbian couple, who could actually have that option. otherwise, you could adopt a child.)

So, no. i don't really believe it's a choice, but a mere adaption/natural attraction.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Monsterka said:
You are born with it. People cannot choose their sexuality, but some might be not sure about their own sexual preferences by long time....

I bet to homosexual people it's hard when they realize their orientation, because they are afraid of reaction of family, friends and intolerant society. Sometimes it's hard even to themselves. It's not a choice, when You wake up one day and think: "Since now I will be gay, it seems to be cool"
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
bless you
frickityfrackle posted over a year ago
AnimeFreak24444 said:
I don't think anyone is born gay but they certainly don't choose to be gay.I mean,falling in love with someone isn't something you can control,you don't choose who you fall for.But I also don't believe you can be born gay;I think you realize you're gay later on in your life like in your adolescent years.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
thetankmoment said:
Is this a trick question?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
No why would you think that? This is actually quite the serious question.
LocalArtistist posted over a year ago
*
I was joking
thetankmoment posted over a year ago
LaDispute said:
Well I sure as fuck didn't choose it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LimblessHero said:
Sexuality isn't something you can simply "choose". For all of you out there who say so, can you "choose" who you're sexually attracted to any time you feel like it? I highly doubt it. It's something your born with, but you don't realize it until later.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
swampfox31 said:
You don't choose your sexuality, you are born with it. I didn't choose to be straight, I was just born like that.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Same thing with being gay. You might not realize it at first, but either way, you can't choose it.
swampfox31 posted over a year ago
LiveLoveMusic said:
Born
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
tammy63 said:
I think they are born gay. It's not choice, it's who they are. Some people are in denial, or force themselves to love the other sex when they actually don't love them because society dictates it that way. I found a lovely song the other day which carries this message and I'd like to share it with you all if that's ok
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Liquid-Dice said:
You're born gay.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
mjlover4lifee said:
Its a little bit of both i guess cause if you chose to be gay then its your choice you just don't realize It until a certain age but sometimes you can be straight and then chose to be gay instead.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
RoisinKelly01 said:
they choose to be gay, does anyone have a problem?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I have a problem with spreading misinformation and furthing willful ignorance, so yes, that comment is a problem.
Roxas1314 posted over a year ago
EgoMouse said:
Pretty sure its mostly hormonal.
I mean, its hard to actually control blood to the...erm, yeah. And exactly why would anyone want to feel crazy over another person by choice? I rather feel rational and logical all the time than crush on some person that isn't what my brain feels him/her to be. It just sorta happens.
If I could choose a sexuality right now, I'd go completely homosexual. I have reasons, but its kinda hard to avoid attraction with women.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »