Samuel has brought the carnival to New York City, where he tells his family that their show tonight will be very special.
He tells Emma that she needs to bring people there with her music. Emma reminds him about the dream she's had, and refuses to do it. Samuel orders Doyle to use his powers on Emma, forcing her to play the cello.
An impressive crowd is gathering at the carnival, along with news cameras. Samuel tells Edgar that the world needs to see the show.
Samuel is keeping Claire locked in his trailer. She wants to go home, but Samuel refuses to let her. He takes her to the House of Mirrors, where Noah is tied to a chair. One of the carnies uses his ability to show Claire memories from her father's past. She learns that Noah had another wife before Claire was born. After Samuel leaves the room, she also finds out that the wife was killed by a man with abilities.
Emma patches Lauren up at the carnival. Lauren tells Emma that she came there to stop Samuel. When Samuel enters the room, Lauren hides. Samuel signs to Emma that he knows...
At the carnival, Samuel steps out of his trailer, wondering where everyone is. Lydia tells him that the carnival is closed, and that the family no longer trusts or respects Samuel, after what he did.
Claire shows up at the carnival to warn Lydia that her father is coming to the carnival to kill Samuel. Eli overhears them. When Samuel approaches, Claire suggests that he should turn himself over to Noah.
Noah and Lauren are on a hill outside, overlooking the carnival. Noah is aiming his rifle at Samuel. Claire calls her dad, saying that Samuel has agreed to surrender....