Advertisement

answer this question

Severus Snape Question

Snape and Hermione?

OKAY what is up with all this Hermione + Snape stuff?
 xBlakeslady posted over a year ago
next question »

Severus Snape Answers

SnapesRose said:
For my person, no, I can't see Severus and Hermione together, nor can I see Severus and Lily together.

Even though Hermione is brilliant, when re-watching HBP she was downright jealous at Harry that he had out done her with Severus aid.
Severus had even spoken down to her, insufferable know-it-all. I know for others that would be like him saying something as a term of endearment :)

In the books nor in the movies was it ever hinted that Hermione ever had feelings for Severus, that is purely Fan Fiction, which, course each their own.

For my person I prefer a other person taking Hermione's or Lily's place.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Well said! I agree completely!
TheNightHawk posted over a year ago
*
I also agree with this.Somehow I think this pairing would have a clash of personality.Hermy is fortunate she gets paired with Sev in fanfic.But is it merely because she's the only major female character on the scene?.
midnightrose posted over a year ago
*
I know Severus has been paired with everyone in the Wozarding world, Hooch, Skeeter - From being a Cradle Robber to a Cougar lover, and none suit him. I think it's best to pair him with a OC!
SnapesRose posted over a year ago
*
I completely agree with everything you said
forsnape posted over a year ago
LadyNottingham said:
Beside self-insert, I think there's another reason - in my humble opinion. JKR has paired her with Ron at the end. That sucks, still in my opinion. I'm sure I'm not the only one. Honestly, Hermione needs to be with someone with brains. That she was a brilliant student (in Potions, among other things) and all the people disappointed that she ended up with Ron, had paired (or wished so) with someone more of her caliber. Severus was a good candidate. He is a brilliant man. They do match intellectually, let's face it. Hence all that stuff.

Personally, I rather support Dramione. Draco is a far better student than Ron and Harry. He would have been a good match for Hermione. Plus that pairing allows to throw in all the issues of love vs. prejudices (Slytherin/Gryffindor ; pure-blood vs Muggle-born). A vast field in which to play.

I used to love SS/HG pairing. I'm less fond now. Yet, when the fanfic is well written, it's enjoyable. If the topic is about a friendship developing between the two, it is plausible too. Yet, I prefer to pair Severus with an Original Character of mine. (I'm presently working on a very long story published on FF.net, entitled "Too Much Love Will Kill You", featuring a pairing between Severus and an OC.

However, Hermione is the only one in the trio to be able to put aside her own prejudices and feelings to really see someone as they truly are. In the HBP book, she takes the stand for Severus over the Half-Blood Prince book eventually, having enquired about him and his mother. She hated the book at the beginning (jealousy over Harry's better marks, then fear over the danger it represented), then she reckons the book was valuable and a testimony of Severus' genius. That's the proof she's able to go past all this. She was the only one to defend Severus when they discuss about his DADA speech, stating that Harry and Severus had said the same thing on the topic, though differently. No hint is given as a bond between Severus and Hermione, yet, she vindicts him more than often because she's intellectually honest. That was more than enough to imagine their pairing then.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Honestly, I think its normal to have a crush on an older and obviouly VERY hot guy (like Severus!) but acting on it in a sexual or perverted way is..............weird
Snapegirl15 posted over a year ago
*
why does it have to be perverted? many young women prefer older, matre men, especially intelligent men, and Severus Snape is definitely intelligent. Add to it sexy, with sense of humour.
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
Love your commentary LadyNottingham.
karenmiller1972 posted over a year ago
bri-marie said:
I'm torn on the whole Severus/Hermione issue. On the one hand, I can completely see why people love this paring and why it's so popular. It's the whole "he's a teacher, I'm a student. He's hot and brilliant and he's got he "bad-boy" thing going for him."

However, a lot or fanfic writers don't really stick to canon and I've read far more bad fics than good ones.

On the other, the paring doesn't make sense at all. He was just as mean to her as he was Ron, Harry and Neville. But, if done correctly, I've read some good fics.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
frostydragon said:
I have come to realize that the SS/HG subject is as much a personal acceptance or refusal as well as a cultural. We are many different people from many different countries with one common factor. We all Love and Adore Prof Severus Snape. We have all had our own experiences concerning the age thing or the student teacher thing both negative and positive. With this common factor we can learn more about each other and learn. Beside this very same dispute is going on all over the web. Some are getting really heated.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree with with you it's just personal opinion. I like just about any pairing with Severus as long as it's done properly (except for Lily). And the HG/SS is a favourite one of mine. I enjoy reading just about any fanfic with that pairing. Would I condone it in real life? Yes if it happened when she was much older and out of the classroom, no if she was still a student. The same way I enjoy reading and watching the tale of Romeo and Juliet yet in real life would be highly disturbed about a 13 year old being prepared for marriage (no matter what time period the story was set at!)
nene72 posted over a year ago
*
It's becoming a very heated argument all over the web. Art is being deleted, stories being banned. It's becoming very intense regardless of the age the characters because the other person involved was always an adult. I've worked for people from India they still arrange marriages. Pre-teens to men in their 30's, So yes it is a cultural view of tradition and exceptance. No ones wrong, no ones right.
frostydragon posted over a year ago
Ambellina said:
Self insert. Fangirls can easily relate to Hermione - and want to have sex with Snape. Combine these two and you get all those terrible SS/HG-Badfics.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly.
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
*
Agreed.
LoveforSeverus posted over a year ago
*
I don't want to be her (though she is wonderfully brilliant)! I don't want Severus to have sex with her! And I DO want to be the ones having Sex with him! :D
SnapesRose posted over a year ago
BellatrixFan said:
I don't like it either!This couple is just so wrong!It's awful and disturbing!Plus i like Snape/Bellatrix only!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Ohh okay! Well every girl would love sex with Snape, no doubt about it. Buuuuut!!!! Hermione and Snape.. No no no nooooo! And sorry, but i HATE Bellatrix, so lol. Not her either! :D LILY! Or me of course! lol
xBlakeslady posted over a year ago
*
I hate lily and i definitely don't like her with Snape!
BellatrixFan posted over a year ago
*
That's more like it!
midnightrose posted over a year ago
lilith84 said:
It's simple really, it's typical schoolgirl having a crush on her scary and hateful teacher fantasy. Quite hot actually (at least for me and I guess for lots of people out there, judging by the amount of fanfiction that pairing has). You might not like it, but I guess respect others view would be appreciated.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I understand you like it even if it's strange!I like Snape/Bella which is a strange couple,too,and many people are against it,but that just not changes my mind!So it's your choice to like Hermione/Snape and i respect that!
BellatrixFan posted over a year ago
*
To be perfectly honest, even though Hg/SS is my favourite pairing, I would be happy to see Snape with almost enyone, except for Lily. And Him and Bella would definitely make a hot couple :P
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
woooohoooo! awesome :) there are lots of great HG/SS fics archives out there. The best is of course ashwinder :) Which fic did you read by the way?
lilith84 posted over a year ago
LadyLilith said:
I don't think Severus and Hermione would ever work together, I just like the situation. :) Teacher and student, especially if the teacher is Severus. I think it's like a self-insert thing for some girls, who can read fanfics based off of Severus and "Hermione," and imagine themselves in Hermione's place.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i agree
Faith-Rulz posted over a year ago
*
Agreed.
forsnape posted over a year ago
snapeislove said:
Im really happy when i saw all those video on youtube saying SS and HG are together, then i figured out its not real, and i really got sad.(fine. im a total ass.)

im making an HG/SS fanfic now, but its not about those s*x and quite disgusting stuffs.. its just that i find hermione very smart and open-minded, and matured, muggle-born, a Gryffindor,(sounds like lily..)..

Well, for me its very sweet (w/out the s*x)..
I actually have read a fanfic of them, and its full of s*x and mastu*bating, and it disgusted me very much.. i wanna do things in the sweet way, that's all.. love is not about s*x for me, after all. :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
there are lots of HG/SS fics on fanfiction.net and especially at ashwinder and not all of them are about sex :) Although I do find those very hot :P
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
i've read some from fanfiction.net, i even read a bed scene so very detailed that its almost scientific. eww.. and yes.. some sex will be hot.. heehee
snapeislove posted over a year ago
*
check ashwinder, it's an archive entirely dedicated to HG/SS fics :) you need to register to read the more mature fics though.
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
oh .. thanks for the info .. heehee.. *goes to check*
snapeislove posted over a year ago
midnightrose said:
Guess there is a real shortage at Hogwarts of women who are worthy enough of being paired with Severus.None of them are the perfect match for him.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree
forsnape posted over a year ago
PretyLitleLiars said:
Why do people not like the Severus Snape + Lily Evans pairing? They knew each other since they were nine years old and were best friends back then.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I can't speak for others, but I can tell you why I don't like it. I don't like Lily, because she turned out to be a shallow and unforgiving hypocrite (sp?). From where I'm standing, she never really was Snape's friend, she stuck with him as long as it suited her, but when it became too much, she turned her back on him. I am not excusing what Snape did, that was uncalled for, but taking into consideration, that they were teenagers at the age where it is hard to control your emotions, especially when someone is being bullied and humiliated in front of the entire school, Lily should have had more understanding. She chose not to forgive her 'best friend' and did not accept him for who he was and for that I find her undeserving of Snape's love.
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
Thank you so much for your clarification! I haven't ready the books yet, but I have heard about this pairing and thought it was sweet. I did not realize that she never forgave Severus and turned he back on him even though he loved her.
PretyLitleLiars posted over a year ago
*
Sorry about the typos in that last comment. Its READ not ready, and HER back not he back.
PretyLitleLiars posted over a year ago
*
I have not read any of the Lily/Snape pairing, but, I've had no desire to yet, I'm still working my way through SSHG stories, SS/HG/LM, SSLL, and Severus/OC....
karenmiller1972 posted over a year ago
BlackHound said:
Personally, I find the SS/HG pairing disturbing, and the DM/HG pairing ridiculous. Oh please! Draco Malfoy? To me, it's an insult to Hermione to even suggest it. She deserved better than Draco, and she got it. She got someone who adores and cherishes her. But hey, that's just my opinion.

As for Severus' relationship with Lily: it's not really the 'mudblood' comment that sank it, Lily was a smart girl and would have come to understand it was spoken in the heat of the moment. She might have been able to forgive him. What sank the relationship ultimately was his deep involvement in the Dark Arts, and his choice of friends (all eventual Death Eaters, remember) that she could not tolerate. She tried to point it out to him several times that it was just evil, but he was too blinded by it to listen to her. It's not that *she* should have been more accepting (of the Dark Arts? Of his idiot elitist, blood-purist friends? Those aren't just little 'personality quirks'), it's that *he* should have listened to *her*. His fault, totally. I see that a lot of fans seem to forget those details.

(And Bellatrix Lestrange disgusts me to no end, I'd write a fanfic just so I could kill her myself, with every horrible curse I could think of, and then do awful things to her corpse. The thought of her touching Severus makes me want to wretch up everything I've eaten for the last week. He deserves SOOOOOOOOO much better than her.)

Aaaaaahhhhhhh Gods that felt good to get all that off my chest... O.O
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
karenmiller1972 said:
Okay, there are very many different reasons that I like this pairing.

I will admit that the Teacher/Student fantasy (college age or legal adult Hermione age) is an attractive one, but that's not the main reason.

Yes, out of Hermione Granger, Luna Lovegood, Minerva McGonagal, Ginny Weasley, Lily Evans, and Bellatrix LeStrange, (and that's the order I rank them as well), I have a closer affinity for Hermione than any of them.

And I abhorred the pairing of Ron and her. Most of that though is because it seemed the teenage dream of the perfect afterlife with the quiet swot instead of the cheerleader getting the football captain as her husband. The character of Ron was not developed enough to explain that pairing and it made no sense to me at all. Pairing Hermione with Ron made no sense for me.

My whole search and finding of fanfiction was because of finishing reading Deathly Hallows, and being outraged at how Severus Snape was dealt with. Here was this character that I think JKR only meant to be a bit part, but then she started using him here and there, he was the Head of Slytherin, he was Harry's hated teacher, he was a Deatheater, he was the childhood friend of Harry's mother, the childhood nemesis of Harry's father, he was the double agent that worked for Dumbledore, he was a member of the Order of the Phoenix....well, she used Severus to fill and merge so many plot lines, he became this multi-faceted character and then was thrown out in the trash when he was no longer needed to further the plot line. I was outraged, searching and I found fanfic.

I read a lot of fanfics, but my favorite were the ones where Severus Snape was his snarky, sarcastic, witty, dominant best, but was loving only with his one friend/companion/love. And most of those that are really well written were with Hermione or Original Characters.

And since, of the characters I most affiliate with are either Hermione Granger or an Original Character, then those are the fanfics that I read the most. I love when they are post-Deathly Hallows, mainly because that is the point that Severus was killed, and reading fanfic that is post-Deathly Hallows rewrites the ending so Severus lives. Whether with an adult Hermione or Original Character, I don't care. LOL

(WP not mine, thanks to the creator!)
select as best answer
Okay, there are very many different reasons that I like this pairing.

I will admit that the Teacher/Student fantasy (college age or legal adult Hermione age) is an attractive one, but that's not the main reason.

Yes, out of Hermione Granger, Luna Lovegood, Minerva McGonagal, Ginny Weasley, Lily Evans, and Bellatrix LeStrange, (and that's the order I rank them as well), I have a closer affinity for Hermione than any of them.

And I abhorred the pairing of Ron and her.  Most of that though is because it seemed the teenage dream of the perfect afterlife with the quiet swot instead of the cheerleader getting the football captain as her husband.  The character of Ron was not developed enough to explain that pairing and it made no sense to me at all.  Pairing Hermione with Ron made no sense for me.

My whole search and finding of fanfiction was because of finishing reading Deathly Hallows, and being outraged at how Severus Snape was dealt with.  Here was this character that I think JKR only meant to be a bit part, but then she started using him here and there, he was the Head of Slytherin, he was Harry's hated teacher, he was a Deatheater, he was the childhood friend of Harry's mother, the childhood nemesis of Harry's father, he was the double agent that worked for Dumbledore, he was a member of the Order of the Phoenix....well, she used Severus to fill and merge so many plot lines, he became this multi-faceted character and then was thrown out in the trash when he was no longer needed to further the plot line.  I was outraged, searching and I found fanfic.

I read a lot of fanfics, but my favorite were the ones where Severus Snape was his snarky, sarcastic, witty, dominant best, but was loving only with his one friend/companion/love.  And most of those that are really well written were with Hermione or Original Characters.  

And since, of the characters I most affiliate with are either Hermione Granger or an Original Character, then those are the fanfics that I read the most.  I love when they are post-Deathly Hallows, mainly because that is the point that Severus was killed, and reading fanfic that is post-Deathly Hallows rewrites the ending so Severus lives.  Whether with an adult Hermione or Original Character, I don't care.  LOL

(WP not mine, thanks to the creator!)
posted over a year ago 
ComoLoca said:
The main reason I like these two together is because the best fics I've read have been of this pairing. For some reason these two characters have an enormous amount of chemistry when written together. There's so much to work with this pairing that the fics piratically write themselves. You have the obvious (ex)student/(ex)teacher dynamic, the good girl/bad boy thing, the very smart girl/man who finally meet their match, the brooding misunderstood mature man of the world with the young fresh innocent girl angle, the hate/dislike that turns into love and admiration, the list is endless. Plus they are also the 2 most liked and popular characters in the whole series. My theory is that lot of the girls/women who love Snape also identify themselves with Hermione the most, so they instinctively end up pairing these two together.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »