I'll go first:

Dean: I'm batman.

Sam: Yeah.. you're Batman.
Was it that one? :)
By the way, awesome idea!

It was that one.:)
And it wasn't exactly my idea, I seen it on another club and thought it would be perfect for SPN. lol, but thanks!! :)

You're welcome. ^^
Anyway, here's the next line:
Dean: Dude, I earned that money!

Crap!!! I know what Sam says, I just don't really know how he said it. If that makes sense.
He says something like 'You won it in a poker game.' or pole game or something. Crap! I don't know.

Your first guess was right. XD So it's your turn!

XD.

Sam: He was suppose to tell me not to be afraid of the dark.

Dean: Not to be afraid of the dark? What, are you kidding me? Of course you should be afraid of the dark! You know what's out there!

Correct! I love that scene and the fight/Jessica scene before it. lol. You're turn.:)

Yeah, me too! XD
Sam: Look, I appreciate your concern...

Awh! I'm drawing a blank here! Is this a line from seasons 1 - 6?
Awh! I really don't know! Crap!:(

It's season 1. XD Sorry for not saying that.

It's okay. I was just asking because I haven't seen any of season 7 yet. So..... :)

Okay because I'm still drawing a blank here, does Sam say that to Dean about not being able to sleep?.......

Was it in Phantom Traveler? Does Dean reply with something like I'm not concern. I need you sharp, I need you watching my back. I knew that's not how he said it. But that's all I can think of. or am I far off?

Oh it's good that you say that, I'll be careful with the spoilers and stuff.
Yeah, it's actually quite like that. Would that be enough, or do you think you should know exactly how the quote was? :P

I think it should be as close as possible. I know that wasn't all that close but as I was typing my answer, the quote was slowly coming to me. After I realized it had to be about Sam not being able to sleep, everything started coming to me, everything but how the quote was actually said. So, I don't think it needs to spot on, but it should be pretty close. If you understand and know what the quote is but have trouble with how it's goes, as long as you're in the ball park it shouldn't count against you. That sounds fair right? :)

Sam: You're a demon.

Sounds fair enough to me!
Ruby: Don't be such a racist.

Right? XD

Correct! lol. :)

Now this one:
Kyle: The guy, he killed my brothers. How would you feel?

Sam: I couldn't imagine everything worse.

I think, lol. I suck at this! lol.

No, you guessed right! XD

Here's a easy one and one of my favorite moments.<3

Dean: Bitch.

Sam: Jerk.
Haha XD Very easy!

Of course! LOL, Dean and Sam's Bitch/Jerks moments. I miss those. <3

Me too! :(
Young Sam: Is Dad a spy?

I lost this one. I know this was in season 3, a very supernatural Christmas. And I know young Dean said yes and followed up with some smart comment and I honestly don't remember what it was.

Here's a clue: Bond.

Obvious clue or good clue? XD haha

Both. lol. So here's my guess.

Young Dean: Yea, he's James Bond.

But, I honestly don't know.

This game is screaming at me to re-watch Supernatural and play really close attention to the lines. lol.

You're right! That's the quote.
Well, there's some episodes I've only watched once, so what is helping me with this is the fact that not so long ago I kept reading and reading quotes from the show and that's how I remember. I should re-watch it, too though. XD

XD.

Dean: You want to kill me? Get in line bitch.

Ruby: Stop calling me bitch.
Or was it "don't call me bitch"?

You're first guess is correct. XD

Okay, then here goes the next quote:
Dean: What it sucks, but with a job like this you can't get close to people, period.

I have to go right now, my iPod's battery is dying and it's 5 am where I live... What am I even still doing here...?! XD

Sam: you're kinda antisocial, you know that?

That's the quote! :D

Okay I got one....

Michael: Two queens or one king?
Dean: Two queens.
Michael: (Under his breath) yeah, I bet.
Dean: What did you say?
Michael: ?

I think this is it. Is it ?

Michael: Two queens or one king?
Dean: Two queens.
Michael: (Under his breath) yeah, I bet.
Dean: What did you say?
Michael: Nice car.

Yep. That would be it. I loved Michael! lol.

Yeah me too. He was kinda cool guy.
Ok so here's mine (very easy):

Dean: I'm Batman.
Sam: ?

Dean: I'm Batman.
Sam: Yeah.... You're batman.

That's correct.

:D

Sam: Dean, there's ten times as much lore about angels as there is about anything else we've ever hunted.
Dean: You know what, there's a ton of lore on unicorns too. In fact, I hear that they ride on silver moonbeams, and that they shoot rainbows out of their ass!
Sam: ?

Sam: Wait, unicorns aren't real?
It was something like that, wasn't it? XD

lol! Yea, that's it! :D

Ed: Sweet Lord...
Harry:

ED: Sweet Lord...
Harry: of the rings, RUN!

lol Correct. XD

Sam : Yeah, what do you wanna do, poke her with a stick? .....