(Derived from a youtube comment I made on CassjayTuck's HoH review.
Jason dealing with amnesia seemed to just be a way of saying Rick needed to iron out the character concept. Piper did not feel heroic in the slightest and her MacGuffin power did not help.
How I felt about Frank and Hazel at the time, although looking back both are super badass, fighting giants and willing to die for the greater good respectively.
Percy's anger toward Leo felt completely unjustified, unlike Jason who actually lived in New Rome being calm. That and Jason's levelheadedness boosted him to number one in my book. Annabeth didn't feel like she had these great challenges for what is essentially her book. The MoA gauntlet was really easy, the ending had a spike in difficulty that left my uncertain about how I felt. That and she was giving the...