What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

The Walking Dead Do you think that Rick did a right thing to kill Shane?

47 fans picked:
Share this poll with others!
Yes, he was too dangerous
   72%
No, he should gave him one more chance
   28%
 Bubble73 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

15 comments

user photo
GamerChick picked No, he should gave him one more chance
GamerChick picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
I just like Shane!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
salemslot picked No, he should gave him one more chance
salemslot picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
No one has a right to kill anyone for any reason, whether the end justifies the means. I had the same stand with the whole Otis situation and I don't see this any different. Rick is a sanctimonious moron who acts with different weights and measures. Yeah, 'it was self-defence' blah blah crap but that doesn't justify the fact that Rick put the gun in Shane's hand with his overall conduct.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
ForsakenMoon19 picked Yes, he was too dangerous
ForsakenMoon19 picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
I wouldn't say it was the right 'right' thing BUT Shane was psychotic and would've killed him or possibly anyone else who'd get in his way! Besides Rick felt remorse over what he'd done and didn't want to take his life but the SOB gave him no other choice since he was unreasonable so...really what other choice did he have?!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SpikesSlayer08 picked Yes, he was too dangerous
SpikesSlayer08 picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
How many more chances did he have to give him? I'm not saying killing someone is right but Shne has tried to kill Rick quiet a few times and this last time Rick tried to get him to walk away repeatedly, in the end Shane left him with little choice, Shane was going to kill him Rick difended himself.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
allis143 picked Yes, he was too dangerous
allis143 picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
Left Rick for dead in the hospital, tried to beat Rick to a pulp, and now this....yeah, he deserved it. He was a psycho.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
linkbella picked No, he should gave him one more chance
linkbella picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
well if shane wouldnt have left rick in the hospital lori and carl would have dyed so who whould u rather have dyed lori adn carl or rick
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
xElvenPiratex picked Yes, he was too dangerous
xElvenPiratex picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
Shane was given more than enough chances. It's not like Rick sneaked up on him and killed him in cold blood (you know, the way that Shane killed Otis and Randall). Shane was a murderer who showed no remorse and took no responsibility for his actions. He was a threat to the entire group and despite that, they gave him every opportunity to change and control himself. It really irks me that people are blaming Rick for this, especially when earlier in the same episode, Rick was gunning for Shane and trying to convince Hershel that Shane was different and was trying to be better. Killing Shane was the last thing he wanted to do, but Shane left him no choice. I don't think killing someone is ever the right thing to do, but in that case, it was absolutely necessary to the survival of the group. Rick did what Shane was always claiming he was best at - he did what he had to do to protect the ones he loved, even though it completely gutted him. It's as simple as that.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
malone79 picked Yes, he was too dangerous
malone79 picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
If he failed you think Shane would have been sorry, cause Glen and Daryl know what happened to Randal, an would avenge rick?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Linz94 picked No, he should gave him one more chance
Linz94 picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
Another chance!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Bubble73 picked Yes, he was too dangerous
Bubble73 picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
If Rick tried to kill Shane like this, Shane would not even hesitate about what to do.
How many chances Shane wasted? It was terrible that Rick had to kill his own friend and it was obvious that he also suffers. If he didn't do it, it would be only a matter of time when Shane will kill next person.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
MarlenaLovett picked Yes, he was too dangerous
MarlenaLovett picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
Rick gave Shane enough chances. He didn't deserve another.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Jumbilo picked Yes, he was too dangerous
Jumbilo picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
The dude tried to kill him three time. The fuck you want to give him another chance for.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
HarleyQuinn277 picked No, he should gave him one more chance
HarleyQuinn277 picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
No!! He was my favorite character...damn!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Surpr1zzm33 picked No, he should gave him one more chance
Surpr1zzm33 picked No, he should gave him one more chance :
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUU­UUC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CCC­CKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK­KKK you Rick!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Claudizzz picked Yes, he was too dangerous
Claudizzz picked Yes, he was too dangerous :
If Rick did not killed Shane,Shane killed Rick
posted over a year ago.