1. Leyton fans seem to forget, that Brooke broke up with Lucas, not Lucas with Brooke. I mean they talk about true love always, but if Lucas had always loved Peyton, he would broke up with Brooke to be with her, right? But we don´t know what would have happened if Brooke didn´t broke up with Lucas. Maybe they´d still be together.
2. okay then there quote "it´s you", well would be really romantic if he hadn´t said this a week before about Brooke. And who was there when all his dreams came true? And he wouldn´t went to Peyton if Brooke hadn´t told him to and earlier Skills.
3.Lucas wrote a book about Peyton, okay well he did but "Brooke is the other half", so...
4. Then he said "I do" to Lindsey, Leyton fans seem totally forget the fact that he would have married Lindsey.
5.Lucas never cheated on Peyton
Okay he didn´t but he kissed Brooke 24 hours after Peyton said "no" to his proporsal, the difference is that Brooke has self respect and pushed him away.