okay i personally think that they are both very sweet and loveable. if you take a look at the time when edward left jacob took care of bella and showed love which led to his feeling in the rest of the book. ok maybe its becoz i'm looking at this from bella's perspective but i think edward is hotter even though his like ice. i think jacob can be really over the top as to end up kissing bella without her concent and ends up making charlie kind of take his side which was seriously annoying and the fact that charlie dont really prefer edward make me feel sorry for him most of the times coz his always very polite so i'm with the cullen even though i do love jacob a pretty lot still edward rocks and bella also said he smells unbeliveably sweet and the taste of his lips oh no i wont keep complimenting him coz i could even spent a week without stopping so his eh h.o.t
actually i think that jacob is the better character because even though he threatens to kill himself. it shows how much he love bella... it's not his fault at that time that he hates edward... what would you do in that situation
I like them both in fact...Each has a lot of great qualitys..But if I have to choose one I think it will be Jacob cuz he's personality is"harder"..I mean when something happens Edward gives up quicker (for exampel when he left Bella in New Moon cuz he afraited hurt Bella but finally Bella abided cuz he left her!! or in Breaking Dawn when Bella was pregnant Edward just "killed himself" when he could help her) whereas Jacob who were in loved with Bella fight for her to the end..
Jacob is also more relax and funnier than Edward.XD