over a year ago:
In reading the books myself and my friends also came up with the above theory, and indeed it does look that way, ui can only hope it is not so as i am a big fan of The snow , while i only hold contempt for Daenerys, and the only reasons i can find that Jonh might well in fact be Eddards is that there are all the rumours of his involvment with some Dornish lady so perhaps the ever honourable to a fault Eddard did stary , after all Catlyn was to be his brothers, he might have been in love before he ended up with her. Also John does not resemble Rhaegar in looks or indeed actions , he is described as very Stark looking , but so was Lyanna, and John certainly does not look dornish. IM afraid that until Howland Reed is brouth into the story line nobody will know the truth, but the plain fact is Snow (much to my disappoinment that he cant reek vengenance on the Boltons and Freys) is stuck on his wall!!!