4 months ago:
After what ShadowClan has been through, I think that he's a leader ShadowClan deserves. :) He was a good warrior and followed the code. Leader's word is law and at the time he killed Stonefur, Tigerstar was his leader, and ordered him to.
I know this poll was posted over a year ago, but I have to say, he was awesome in The Last Hope. :D