Debate

A place for fair, respectable, and intellectual conversation
1162 fans
 Join this Club
Search Club:
 Invite friend 
fanpop > politics & current events > debate > answers > question

Which do you think is right when it comes to the topic of abortion: It is illegal and there should be punishments against it, or it is legal and every expectant mother has the right to request an abortion?

I personally think abortion is wrong in any type of situation. If you abort a fetus, you are terminating a life that has not even started; a life of a person who could not speak for themselves at all and I believe that is just horrendous. Also, since you are ending the life of a human being, abortion might as well be a synonym for murder. But that is what I believe. What does everyone else think of problem with abortion?
Which do you think is right when it comes to the topic of abortion: It is illegal and there should be punishments against it, or it is legal and every expectant mother has the right to request an abortion?
*
I know I didn't really put up a good argument. I just joined this spot and am interested in learning what to do in a debate, so this is just practice for me.
sapherequeen posted 7 months ago
*
This has been discussed on here a lot of times. Search for the pick question. And the answer feature is not the right place to start a debate: make a pick.
Sappp posted 7 months ago
*
Ok.
sapherequeen posted 6 months ago
*
ANY type of situation? What if the fetus was killing the mother? Should she abort, or should she keep the child and lose both her and her child's life in the process?
Bibaraguroria posted 5 months ago
*
There have been some cases like that where the mother and child came out safely and abortion was either dismissed from being a solution or just never mentioned.
sapherequeen posted 5 months ago
 sapherequeen posted 7 months ago
next question »
URL:   Bookmark and Share
answers
Cinders said:
Pro-lifers propagate the myth that abortions are only obtained by women who are lazy, selfish, and/or underage.

They also claim that the majority of abortions are late term-- this isn't true. In fact, the United States has laws against late term abortions.

Under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a fetus is not considered alive until it has taken its first breath of air and can live independently of the mother. If a man murders a pregnant woman, he is not charged with double-homicide. On a lighter note, lone pregnant women cannot drive in the carpool lane simply because they're "driving for two."

The real question about this is when does life begin? That's where line drawing comes in. Is the morning after pill as morally reprehensible as an abortion? If you say yes, then are you against contraceptives? Uninterrupted, the sperm would have hit the egg, and created a fetus, which would grow into a baby. Does that mean condoms, which prevent this from happening are wrong?

St Thomas Aquinas believed that God would not bestow a soul onto a vessel that had no use for it. This is why he did not believe a fetus had a soul until quickening-- when the brain and nervous system are developed enough for the fetus to kick in the womb.

Several Catholics believe that life begins at conception-- in which case, the morning after pill is wrong. The same Catholics believe that it's wrong for a woman who was raped to take the morning after pill proceeding her attack.

Abortion-- and regulating it-- has been a tool of political manipulation of women since the 1960s. I read an article in one of my classes detailing how if a woman wanted an abortion, she had to go up in front of a panel of doctors (all men in those days), who would decide for her if she could do it. More often than not, their answer would be no.

Personally, I cannot say what I would do if I was backed so far into a corner I thought I needed an abortion. Some cultures will kill a woman if she has sex out of wedlock (called honor killings), in which case pregnancy can literally be the death of a woman (and often her child) if she does not terminate. It should be noted that honor killings often occur even if the woman was raped.

In the play Mitzi's Abortion, a woman who did not initially want the child bonds with it during the first trimester only to find out later that her baby has suffered a severe birth defect known as anencephaly. Straight from Wikipedia, that means that "Children with this disorder are born without a forebrain, the largest part of the brain consisting mainly of the cerebral hemispheres (which include the isocortex, which is responsible for higher level cognition, i.e., thinking). The remaining brain tissue is often exposed—not covered by bone or skin... Most anencephalic babies do not survive birth, accounting for 55% of non-aborted cases. If the infant is not stillborn, then he or she will usually die within a few hours or days
select as best answer
posted 3 months ago 
*
after birth from cardiorespiratory arrest." In cases where both the lives of the fetus and the mother are in jeopardy, unless otherwise told by the parents or their advance directive, the doctor's main focus is to save the mother first, then try and save the fetus. This is especially true if the pregnancy has not advanced far enough for the fetus to be able to live on its own outside of the womb, even with premature birth life support equipment. In short (haha, "short"), abortion and prenatal health are far more complicated than both the prochoice and prolife debaters make it out to be. One must consider all sides of the equation and remember that there are <i>always</i> extenuating circumstances for everything. There are and should be restrictions on abortions. They are painful procedures, and women are educated on what they are doing. Women are often also told about every other opportunity available to them-- so abortion is never pushed on an expectant mother by a licensed doctor. More often than not, it's used as a last resort by desperate women. It is not something people take lightly.
Cinders posted 3 months ago
Milah said:
Well, I really don't care about the politics. Whether it's legal or illegal. But I don't think abortion is right though. I just couldn't stand the fact of being a murderer. I just couldn't stand the fact that I took a person's life away who never had a chance to open their eyes and see the world. Who never had a chance at life.
select as best answer
posted 7 months ago 
*
WOW! Did I really just say that? Surprising! AWESOME!
Milah posted 7 months ago
adavila said:
I think it should be legal for one month pregnant women not more
select as best answer
posted 7 months ago 
greeneyedvamp said:
I find abortion wrong in so many ways. What if your killing the next brad pitt or president of the united states just because you are afriad to tell your mom? Yes abortion may be legal but in my opinion it is wront to want to end a life before it has even had a chance to take its first step or big breat of fresh air. How would you feel killing a baby before you can look it in the eyes and say i love you? this is just my opinion and i hope i dont offend any one.
select as best answer
posted 6 months ago 
*
I absolutely agree :)
sapherequeen posted 5 months ago
*
And what if you're killing the next Hitler?
Cinders posted 3 months ago
*
BTW-- there are several legitimate reasons for obtaining an abortion. There's a stigmatic stereotype floating about that it's only teenage girls and selfish women who don't want to gain weight. Cases can be and have been made in the case of rape, incest, terminal deformities of the fetus, concern for safety of the mother, complications in pregnancies and miscarriages, and various other reasons. So no, it's not just because you're afraid to tell your mom.
Cinders posted 3 months ago
*
...and what if you're killing the next Lindsay Lohan or Kanye West? =D
DarkSarcasm posted 3 months ago
ashesandwine said:
Personally I think that people have a right to choose whether they want to abort or not! It's up to them and we shouldn't make them feel bad for doing it (not accusing anyone, just saying)...
If someone decides that an abortion is the best for them then they should do it! Of it's a bad to end a life but it's a person's body, and people can do what they want with their body!


PS: just joined! LOVE debates! hope to meet people here and to have fun:P Portuguese so sorry for the mystakes!
select as best answer
posted 3 months ago 
*
Welcome! I'm glad you love debates! We love seeing new debaters, with fresh insight and opinions. Most of us are very level-headed and open to all rational opinion and thought. So whatever you want to share, don't be afraid to say it loudly and prouldy.
Cinders posted 3 months ago
*
Thanks:D I'm glad that everyone is open... sometimes in some spots people are a bit mean! so,,,, thanks:D happy to be a part!
ashesandwine posted 3 months ago
next question »
popular content
fanpop home - company blog - about us - advertise on fanpop - faq - sitemap - terms of service - privacy policy - contact us
connect with us on
Facebook MySpace bebo hi5 YouTube Twitter