Who was the better character/actor of the Gyllenhaal/Darko siblings?

They've both got the sexy/psycho thing going in every publicity shot I see. Still, in the film, Jake shines as an actor, Maggie is interesting, but let's face it, the film is basically the Jake Gyllenhaal show.

Jakey G totally rocks in this film, and he wasn't really that old when he made it. But I do like his siter.

"you can go suck a f**k"

"Tell me, Elizabeth, how exactly does one suck a f**k?"

He's a better actor, but Maggie is rather nice. :)

They're both nice and great actors, but I have to pick Maggie in Donnie Darko, because she had a wonderful character and did a great job. Just like 5% better job than Jake.

i agree with AmyFitz!! lol

I loove Jake he is so awesome in this movie :)

Its hard to compare when Maggie got very little screen time compared to Jake. My vote goes to Jake though because he was obviously fantastic.