Listed below are all the cast members with a number and a brief description of why they are/aren't the killer.
5= Most Likely
4= Good Chance
3= Maybe
2= Not Likely
1= Probably Not
Chloe Carter- 5 Obsession with John Wakefield
Maggie Krell- 5 No Alibis, Able to do all deaths
Richard Allen- 4 Betrayal to family with Katherine; Able to kill; locations
J.D. Dunn 3 Too obvious; set up; but still can kill
Jimmy Mance- 3 Knows the Island; Good with boats and weapons
Beth Barrington- 2 Not shown enough yet
Cal Vandeusen- 2 Hung during the s. Hunt;
Christopher Sulliven- 2 Reason to long to be summarized
Danny Brooks- 2 No one he likes much has died by the murderer
Henry Dunn- 2 Been on the island b4; likes boats
Katherine Wellington- 2 Affair with Richard
Nikki Bolton- 2 Knows island; but not on boat to kill Ben
Shea Allen- 2 No reason either way yet
Trish Wellington- 2 Been on the island b4; but other flaws too
Abby Mills- 1 Fortune Teller said killings won’t stop till she dies
Madison Allen- 1 Interpreter and mischievous, but too young
Malcolm Ross- 1 Hard time seeing Booth die, can’t imagine him killing others
Shane Pierce- 1 In Jail; could’ve killed JD but didn’t
Sheriff Charlie Mills- 1 The Detective, not the killer
|
Join this Club
Invite friend 
Fortune Teller said killings won’t stop till she dies
Did you ever think that maybe she meant the killings won't die until she stops because SHE is doing them?
I don't necessarily think she's the killer but I think she's a great possibility. Better than Jimmy.
FT: "You have to leave"
Abby: "What?"
FT: "He wants you dead"
Abby: "Let go of me"
FT: "Please, he won't stop"
(zooms in on Abby's astonished face, then cuts off)
That is the exact conversation, which in my theory she will die in the last episode, and the sheriff will kill the killer in the end. History repeats itself sort've thing.
Here is the note he left for Trish, pretending it was from Hunter. Every letter is capitalized. But the first letter of each word is bigger than the rest of the word. And the "M" is crisscrossed in the middle.
http://i673.photobucket.com/albums/vv955/t
Now this is the note left by the killer for the Sheriff to find. Every letter is also capitalized and the first letter of each word is bigger than the rest of the word too. Also the "M" is crisscrossed in the middle too.
http://i673.photobucket.com/albums/vv955/t
The guest list is also written with all Capital letters, the first letter being bigger than the rest of the word. And the "M" is crisscrossed. Henry may have very well organized the guest positions for his own wedding.
http://i673.photobucket.com/albums/vv955/t
But the note left for Henry telling him that Hunter was at the hotel has different handwriting. Therefore I don't think it was the killer who left that note for him.
http://i673.photobucket.com/albums/vv955/t
And, for Nikki why would they keep her on if she only knows Abby? She either A has to be the Killer or B be wakefields kid...Also Nikki does not have an alibi for most of the episodes....
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment