We apologize for the missing images - one of our image servers went offline and we're working on a recovery solution.
For more information, click here to read a forum thread on this.
okay so you know how you can only see thestrals after you have seen death? well how come at the end of the fourth book after harry sees cedric die, it still says that the carriages were pulling themselves? he cant dee the thestrals until the beginning of the fifth book when school starts, but not at the end of the fourth book when school ends. its confusing...does anybody have a way to ask jk rowling about that cos i suck at finding adresses and stuff like that. has anybody noticed that, or am i just a freak who reads the books too many times (about seven times each) and too carefully....oh well i dont really care... i love hp!
yea i noticed that too, like i was always confused with the subject of the thestrals, but didn't harry see his parents die? so couldn't he of seen them all the time? or did he even see his parents die? im confused. but yeh your right, harry should of seen them at then end of book 4. Ummm....not sure about reaching jkr.
Well, hun, just so you know, this would have been better in the forum section. But, don't complain. With that massive of a plot line, containing so many tiny interlocking details, she was bound to make a mistake.
ya tat was right... but harry had also almost seen his mother die so y not on his 1st day at hogwarts itself????????????? ummmmmmmmmm these r qqqqqqqqqq tat makes us ponder
Join this Spot
Invite friend 
But then what about seeing his parents die? Do you have to remember the deaths as well as seeing them? :-S
OWNED JK ROWLING.
Not sure how to say this...
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment