'Crucial,' says Jo: Why did Dumbledore have James' invisibility cloak at the time of James' death, given that Dumbledore could make himself invisible without a cloak?
This question is now closed
76 fans picked:
It holds a clue to Harry's past, possibly a secret message
36%
I've no idea - why do you do this to us, Jo?!
29%
So it could be used for an Order mission
14%
It's a Horcrux, stumbled upon by James
12%
It has hidden powers
5%
Snape was at Godric's Hollow that night and tried to steal but was stopped by Dum
tubby2002 picked So it could be used for an Order mission:
I seen this on mugglenet and I liked the question so I thought I would put it on here and see what everyone hear thinks
posted 2 years ago.
dramallama56 picked It holds a clue to Harry's past, possibly a secret message:
Ok, basically, I have my own theories on Dumbledore, which I keep to myself. They're insane and everyone I know is gonna be jealous when they're right. It's so true. So I had a hard time answering this. I felt like what I picked best fit my personal idea.
posted 2 years ago.
miiamya picked It holds a clue to Harry's past, possibly a secret message:
i dont think its a secret message necessarily...
posted 2 years ago.
SKQ62 picked So it could be used for an Order mission:
Or just to be given to Harry. It's a very good magical item! I think that's it?
posted 2 years ago.
potterfan6 picked It holds a clue to Harry's past, possibly a secret message:
It is very important.Why would Dumbledore be mentioning Harry's father then?
posted 2 years ago.
Aileendamen picked So it could be used for an Order mission:
Who knows maybe James forgot it at dumbledore's place after a nice meal.
posted 2 years ago.
suuz picked It holds a clue to Harry's past, possibly a secret message:
I really think it could hold a clue to Harry's past..but what if it is one of voldemorts Horcrux that james found..Did we ever find out why Voldemort made it a key point to get James and Lily? Just something to think about.
posted 2 years ago.
snoznoodle picked I've no idea - why do you do this to us, Jo?!:
Grrr so annoying!
posted 2 years ago.
piperpayton22 picked It's a Horcrux, stumbled upon by James:
i never thought of that but i dont think it really matters but whatever
Join this Club
Invite friend 
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment