For those who want to explore the non-canon love interests of Harry
109 fans
 Join this Spot
Search Fanpop:
 Invite friend 
fanpop > couples & 'shipping > harry potter's... > forum > what are your reasons for not liking h/g?

What are your reasons for not liking H/G?

shieldmaiden posted on Jan 09, 2008 at 03:26AM
And if you do like them then why do you? I'd love to hear opinions! =) Thanks again to all who have joined!
last edited on Jan 09, 2008 at 05:52AM
user photo fawkes716 said:
Just look at smoore's "Everyone hates us" link, I dont want to type it all again.Grascias!
posted 9 months ago.
 
user photo smoore23 said:
Here are a few:
--Ginny changed too quickly. I always felt like she was just a little girl, you know, not really a main character or anything. Suddenly she becomes pretty, popular, and the object of all the guys' affections. I don't think her character was given enough time to develop.
--Their relationship seems rather superficial.
--They seem like brother and sister! I know people will argue the same thing about R/Hr, but they've always had some tension, wheras with H/G, they seemed like siblings.
--IMO, the relationship was developed too quickly for it to seem realistic.

And there's something that I just can't put my finger on that I don't like about them being together. I know that sounds lame, but really, there's just something about them I don't like.
posted 9 months ago.
last edited 9 months ago
 
user photo luvrofedward said:
eh i agree with smoore23. ginny seems like SUPER young and harry seems way way older. she kind of just pops up out of the dark in the half-blood prince book, like out of nowhere, and harry IS the main character in the series....doesnt make sense......
posted 9 months ago.
 
user photo fr34kygl said:
I agree with you guys too.. But it could've been worse, most people see them as a couple because jkr did write it quite good, not logical enough for me. But imagine they really didn't know each other like at all and suddenly pang (like how nathans hair grew in one tree hill), they're engaged... That would be so much worse!
posted 9 months ago.
last edited 9 months ago
 
user photo GCsAngelgirl said:
I just don't really like Ginny that much. I felt that her character grew up too fast and was kinda thrown at us that she's the one for Harry. And it does seem superficial, when Harry thought of her all he could think of was the way she looked, nothing else that seems important for a relationship to last. It's just... I think that JKR could have built up on this, not just put her in towards the end as someone he could be with.
posted 9 months ago.
 
user photo shieldmaiden said:
i just realized something else, ginny is quite rude to her family and others. i'm currently rereading hbp, and she was rude to her mother in the beginning of the novel and also rude to ron and her siblings while at hogwarts. not a very pleasant girl, rather...mean and too aggressive for my taste. =\ harry could have done better, like luna! which I will write a soapbox on when time permits! i have a soapbox on why they could have worked rattling in my head, just want the time to research quotes and supporting material =)
posted 7 months ago.
 
related spots