One ring to rule them all, one ring to find them, one ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them...
5158 fans
 Join this Club
Search Club:
 Invite friend 
fanpop > books & literature > lord of the rings > picks > question
What do you think? Make your pick!
(Made your pick already? Remember to login!)

Which battle impressed you the most?

47 fans picked:
The Battle in Helm's Deep
   38%
The Battle in the Pelennor Fields
   17%
The Siege of Minas Tirith
   15%
The Battle of the Last Alliance
   9%
The Battle of Amon-Hen
   4%
The Battle in the Black Gate
   4%
The Fight in Mount Doom (Frodo vs. Gollum)
   4%
The Fight in Moria (Gandalf vs. Nazgul)
   2%
The March of the Ents in Isengard
   2%
The Fight in Cirith Ungol (Sam vs. Shelob)
   2%
The Battle in Osgiliath
   2%
The Fight in Weathertop (Aragorn vs. Nazguls)
no picks yet
 Stratosrozer posted 6 months ago
Make your pick! | next question >>
URL:   Bookmark and Share
Add this pick to your blog or profile! MySpaceFriendsterMultiplyXangaBloggerLiveJournalWordPressVox
10 comments
user photo
ambra picked The Battle in the Black Gate
ambra picked The Battle in the Black Gate:
but i love all the battles!!!!!
posted 6 months ago.
 
user photo
spikes_girl picked The March of the Ents in Isengard
spikes_girl picked The March of the Ents in Isengard:
My favorite are the ones at Minas Tirith, but most impressed would be the March of the Ents. All I can think of during this scene is "Wow."
It is epic!
posted 6 months ago.
 
user photo
acklesgirl87 picked The Battle in Helm's Deep
acklesgirl87 picked The Battle in Helm's Deep:
The battles at Helm's Deep and Minas Tirith were the most visually spectacular. I pretty much love any battle scene with Aragorn in it! ;) Oh, and by the way, the fight in Moria was Gandalf vs. a balrog
posted 6 months ago.
 
user photo
brittlegirl94 picked The Fight in Moria (Gandalf vs. Nazgul)
brittlegirl94 picked The Fight in Moria (Gandalf vs. Nazgul):
Tied with Helm's Deep and the Ent's march, I really love all those scenes. They are so spectacular!
posted 6 months ago.
 
user photo
Elizabeth0 picked The Battle of the Last Alliance
Elizabeth0 picked The Battle of the Last Alliance:
Tied with Helm's Deep and The March of the Ents in Isengard.
posted 5 months ago.
 
user photo
green79 picked The Battle in Helm's Deep
green79 picked The Battle in Helm's Deep:
who would choose The Fight In Mount Doom (Frodo vs. Gollum) ?? ;P
posted 4 months ago.
 
user photo
terhenetar picked The Battle of the Last Alliance
terhenetar picked The Battle of the Last Alliance:
and the battle in Helm's Deep
posted 3 months ago.
 
user photo
Fedex picked The Fight in Cirith Ungol (Sam vs. Shelob)
Fedex picked The Fight in Cirith Ungol (Sam vs. Shelob):
Sam is my fav. character. Hobbit vs. Giant Spider. What's better than that?
posted 3 months ago.
 
user photo
lotr picked The Battle in Helm's Deep
lotr picked The Battle in Helm's Deep:
they are all great
posted 15 days ago.
 
user photo
bendaimmortal picked The Fight in Mount Doom (Frodo vs. Gollum)
bendaimmortal picked The Fight in Mount Doom (Frodo vs. Gollum):
green79,

"who would choose The Fight In Mount Doom (Frodo vs. Gollum) ?? ;P"

Those who prefer psychological intensity over massive battles with weapons and lots of blood and dropping heads. And there is even more to that particular fight.

I love Frodo VS. Gollum the best. Both by the time equally corrupted by the Ring, and Frodo was at that very point the new Lord of the Rings as he had claimed the Ring for his own at the Crack of Doom. Frodo's psycho expression as he gets up and at Gollum a bit after Gollum had bit off Frodo's finger which is pretty psychotic too. Frodo VS. Gollum fight the tip of the iceberg so to say, the real climax of the ENTIRE War of the Ring. THAT's why I pick Frodo VS. Gollum. I don't care even nearly as much for the massive battles that were only supporting the chance of the good guys winning. I vote for the one fight that sealed the fate of Middle-Earth. That happened after all hope truly seemed lost because Frodo had given in, and Sam... Sam did not know what to do. Did you notice how utterly helpless and lost he looked when Frodo disappeared from sight when putting the ring on? In the moment just before Gollum knocked him (Sam) out with the rock. All three characters also put so much emotion to their parts in it.

THAT fight is truly epic, in my opinion. (:

My second favorite would be Sam VS. Shelob simply because it's the ultimate one to show the depth of Sam's love and loyalty to Frodo. I just wish they had made Shelob the bookverse version - as in at least 2 times the size She is in this film. It really wasn't THAT impressive in the film if you didn't keep on thinking why Sam was doing it.

My third favorite is Gandalf VS. Balrog. Very impressive with all the things Gandalf said to keep Balrog restrained and they had made Balrog look really awesome.
posted 11 days ago.
last edited 11 days ago
 
add pick      next pick
popular content
fanpop home - company blog - about us - advertise on fanpop - faq - sitemap - terms of service - privacy policy - contact us
connect with us on
Facebook MySpace bebo hi5 YouTube Twitter