As they will fight for it, who will be a better leader for The Others?

it has to be ben he is the only 1 who knows whats really going on out of them both

But he is quite clearly insane! Richard may try and take charge though.

Ya there should be a richard option.

He truly does have the island first in his heart ... Ben, sadly, has been compromised and now is seeing things through his own eyes and not those of the island.

I think Ben's running them into the ground.

That would be great if Locke took over, but he has no idea what's going on with Jacob so he probably won't be leader anytime soon.

Locke is too much of a softy.... If you wanna go to war you really should bring Benjamin with all his mindgames!