It depends on the photo of Haley I'm seeing. Like the one you added, I can kinda see Clary there but...I don't know. Physically speaking, yeah, I think they do match in some aspects but I imagined Clary to look somewhat younger (because Haley *does* look her own age) and more... inoccent, maybe? Haley has that very obvious punk-rock edge about her and that's something that's less noticeable about Clary (she has it, though. The girl can kick some serious ass!).

Yeah. I've never realized that before, but they do seem similar.

no i dont think so...and i think i mite depend how she'll look in character. but she would be one of my last choices.

Um... That's what I thought when I first read the book but to me it doesn't fit for some reason. Not much help but yeah... I reckon she would be 100% perfect if they made a City of Bones Soundtrack or something.