Sams Father????

Eddie knows who the father is I think, I hope it's Nick to, but maybe Eddie and Hannah hooked up when Nick left, :) so maybe he's the father...lol it's good for the drama on the show
But I hope so it's Nick, so he can be a father for sam instade of big cat

I totally agree with you lilie2 but I hope its Nick

For several reasons, I think Phil is the father. I would much prefer it to be Nick, but I have come to think it is Phil. On abc.com's website I posted the reasons in a thread called WAY WAY WAY out theory or something like that.

sucha a drama show...but its awesome lol...umm i think eddie is going to turn out to the be father...especially after last nights show and what hannah and eddie were talking about...and then i thought she was gonna tell Big Kat at the end..but we gotta wait at least 2 weeks now...sucks...

it is eddie it was mentioned in an early episodes where he wanted to tell nick about it.

eddie is sam's dad

i've watched the entire first season last night (bored i know!) and really, the twist comes in second season when Eddie wants to tell Nick SOMETHING. He probably hooked up with Hannah once or twice after Nick left but NEVER have they said, "EDDIE'S THE FATHER" OR [HANNAH TO EDDIE]" YOU'RE HIS DAD"

i still think (hope) that nick is sams dad and they wand us to think its eddie

MAYBE WE'LL FIND OUT IN THE SEASON FINALE! WHY DOES HANNAH GO TO JAIL!?

When does hannah go to jail?

i really hope Nick is Sam's father, but something tells me it's Eddie!

My vote is Nick. The whole peanut allergy thing and the fact that the Commander said that Sam's has Nick's mothers eyes. That has been the lingering question from the first episode and only one of the reasons I love october road so much.

May be why Big Cat hates Eddie so much?

I agree with martinez_is90. I think that Eddie and Hannah probably had a relationship after Nick left, but that Nick might still be the father. I hope he is!

If you guys love october road as much as you say you do, then here's your last chance to get it back. even if you think its a hoax, give it a shot, what could it hurt?

apparently there is a way we can save OR! I'm quite excited. Theres a thing called Save One Show and a few shows have been nominated. but OR isn't on there! so first things first, we gotta get it on there. so go on to http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/watch_wwit­h_k­ris­tin­/b1­0..­.tm­l and comment like crazy about why you love the show and why it should be nominated. then email the girl in charge of the nominees Kristin at tvdiva@eonline.com and tell her the same. also tell WHOEVER you know who loves this. this is our last chance to get it back!

It`s Nick.
You find out in the last wrap-up episode that`s only 10 minutes long.