Most shocking moment on OTH for you?(sorry if this has been done)

This question is now closed

105 fans picked:

School shooting/Dan killing Keith

43%

Physco Derek returns S4 ep. 16

13%

Haley got hit by a car/Lucas having a heart attack

10%

Haley telling Nathan she wants a divorce in s5ep.10

It turned out to be Brooke on the sex tape with Nathan in S4

The car accident in s3 finale

Haley leaving Nathan for the tour in S2

when haley came back/lucas kissing brooke at the end of season 2!

(added by brucas4ever)

Peyton being shot...

(added by abs07)

Haley was the one pregnant

Carrie walking in on Nathan in the shower

(added by Kebab1310)

mcrfan1516 posted 7 months ago

Make your pick! | next question >>

URL:

Share this Question

Add this pick to your blog or profile!

12 comments

	iluvspike4eva picked School shooting/Dan killing Keith: It has to be Dan shooting Keith in 316 I just wasn't expecting and I was speechless after watching it. posted 7 months ago.

	JolijnAdri picked Haley telling Nathan she wants a divorce in s5ep.10: I was in total shock when this happened and i was sooo upset!! but is was so shocking for me because the reason i watch one tree hill is nathan and haley!! but my second most shocking is probably the school shooting and the accident at the end of season 3 posted 7 months ago.

	Leyton4ever picked Physco Derek returns S4 ep. 16: i had to pick this one...cuz i really thought his storyline was over...guess i was wrong....the school shooting itself did surprise me, but it wasn't a complete shock to me that dan killed keith. posted 7 months ago.

	ElliesOwner picked Haley leaving Nathan for the tour in S2: The others I knew were going to happen, but I never thought Haley would actually leave and be gone for so long. posted 7 months ago.

	cara-girl picked The car accident in s3 finale: this was CRAZY for me!! posted 7 months ago.

	livelovelaugh picked Haley got hit by a car/Lucas having a heart attack: derek as i didnt expect it and it totally freaked me out posted 7 months ago.

	love_struck94 said: cant choose all of them were shocking.they all took me by surprie posted 7 months ago.

	abs07 said: they were all pretty shocking... posted 7 months ago.

	molliexoxo picked School shooting/Dan killing Keith: all of them but this one made me cry sooo much posted 7 months ago.

	Laurra said: cant choose - all of them except from lucas kissing brooke and haley coming back! you could see it coming all the way through the series! posted 7 months ago.

	loves-oth picked School shooting/Dan killing Keith: :) this pick made me realise how good the oth storylines are! :) posted 7 months ago.

	Shelby13 picked School shooting/Dan killing Keith: I figured Derek was coming back, you can't get rid of a crazy stalker that easily haha The sex tape would have been more surprising if they did anything with it posted 7 months ago.