A spot for all of the fans of The Chronicles Of Narnia [by C.S.Lewis] books and movies [both new and bbc] to join together, share and discuss.
3883 fans
 Join this Club
Search Club:
 Invite friend 
fanpop > books & literature > the chronicles of... > picks > question
What do you think? Make your pick!
(Made your pick already? Remember to login!)

Does it annoy you that they are making the movies out of order?

111 fans picked:
Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC
Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC
   41%
(added by jesterlady)
No
   19%
Yea it pisses me off
Yea it pisses me off
   16%
Yea kinda
Yea kinda
   14%
Why would it?
Why would it?
   10%
 ilovehinder posted 1 year ago
Make your pick! | next question >>
URL:   Bookmark and Share
Add this pick to your blog or profile! MySpaceFriendsterMultiplyXangaBloggerLiveJournalWordPressVox
17 comments
user photo
Yea it pisses me off
ilovehinder picked Yea it pisses me off:
they started with the second one and now theyre going straight to teh fourth one
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
chels05 picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
they're making the movies in the order they were written. CS Lewis wrote the books in the same order their coming out in the movies. He didnt write the chronologically
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
Meg08 picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
Yeah, if you've got the big book that has all of them in it, it says that their in C.S. Lewis' "prefered" order, not the order he wrote them in. I like the way they're doing the films, I didn't like the Horse and His Boy anyways.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
swimswamswum picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
C.S. Lewis's books were publishes in this order and somewhat began this way.
LWW
PC
VDT
SC
HHB
MN
LB
posted 1 year ago.
last edited 1 year ago
 
user photo
jamiejean picked No
jamiejean picked No:
I think it would have been easier for "non-readers" to follow if they did it in chronological order, rather than Lewis's order
"but if you think about it LOGICALLY" [you know you love that i fit that quote in there] They need to make them in Lewis's order, otherwise the characters would get to old to pass off as only a year older than the last time they were in a film.

= ]
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
heddulf picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
Im thinking they're only making the ones with the Pevensie children... atleast for now
posted 1 year ago.
last edited 1 year ago
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
shieldmaiden picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
i do want a silver chair one though =) and last battle!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
ShadowFlame picked No
ShadowFlame picked No:
no, this is nice :]
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Lunatic said:
I'm not caring.

But I think all you people who are saying: How can this bother you? It is Lewis' order!

He never meant to continue the story after LWW, which is why the publishing order is different than the chronological order.
The history of Narnia kept coming to him randomly and he felt he had to write it, although it wasn't in order.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
joyfullaughx3 picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
it depends to some people it is and to some it isn't
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
gracie08 picked No
gracie08 picked No:
If you read them in C.S. Lewis' preferred order, then they're only skipping The Horse and His Boy. While I know it is an important part of the series in its own way, I won't really miss it if they don't make the movie. It may be important to other people though, and for them, I feel bad.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Yea it pisses me off
_m_a_j_o_ picked Yea it pisses me off:
Even if C.S. Lewis originally wrote them in the order the movies are following, I like more the order that the books have now.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
DifferentFree picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
They are making the movies in the order that Lewis published them.
I think it definitely makes a LOT more sense this way and draws people in more.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
Charlie_Rose picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
they are making the movie in order that Lewis Published them!!!!!!!!
and i think they did a good job!!!!!!!!!!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
edwardcullen23 picked No
edwardcullen23 picked No:
They are making the movies that have the kids in them. that's it.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
Kaidi picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
they did the same thing with The DaVinci Code. The DaVinci Code is a sequel to Angels and Demons, but Angels and Demons is in production at the moment ;)
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Uh, they're not. It was...
becca85 picked Uh, they're not. It was written LWW and then PC:
Technically they are still going in publishing order. Besides, I think they are just trying to complete the books with the original cast so that they can get made before the actors/actresses grow up and are too old to play their parts.
posted 1 year ago.
 
add pick      next pick
popular content
fanpop home - company blog - about us - advertise on fanpop - faq - sitemap - terms of service - privacy policy - contact us
connect with us on
Facebook MySpace bebo hi5 YouTube Twitter