you know what, i've been thinking the same thing. maybe it'll be mentioned in a future episode cuz i'm pretty sure it's never been mentioned

Now that is a very good question, I suppose it's just like Jasper and the smurf on the show Bones, we may never know.

I bet it's going to come back in another episode in like season 3 or something when everybody has forgotten it. She lives in an apartment, though, so she probably couldn't keep it. She could be keeping it at a stable somewhere or given it to a neice or nephew.

I didnt even know the Jane got her a pony. lol :) sorry I couldnt help. But you answered my question. I was wondering what he did actually get her.