Will the movie live up to the book ?

I couldn't agree more. I think it will be very good. And like any other Hollywood movie, it changes some things, but it will definitely be good. I can't wait to see it.

I don't agree with your opinion that the movie might be better than the book. That is rarely ever the case, and a lot of parts just can't be done properly in a movie because it is supernatural in some ways, and those parts are made for your imagination. And it will get tons of mixed reviews, because no two people have the exact same images in their heads and opinions of the book/characters. I have to wait and see to make my final judgment, but I do hope that they get it right. I hope they do a good job.

I am not going to keep my hopes high. As Timbitzk said the movie being better than the book is rarely ever the case. Everyone has their own "meadow scene" in their mind so yes it will probably get mixed reviews. Though i do applaud people that are involved like Catherine Hardwicke ( The director) to take a risk like this . Twilight has a huge fanbase , and the movie might excel or umm...flop .?? so it is a really big risk theyre taking.
I also cant wait to see how it turns out.

i'm sorry, but i don't think the movie will be as good as the books are. but i am excited to see how the movie does

i think the movie is probably going to be good to all the twlight fans but not as good as the books :)

Although it's still very earlier and from the excerpts that i've seen thus far...like the scene when Bella tells Edward that she's not afraid of him, was not the same as the scene in the book. (He didn't fly out the window)!! I think they should stay as remotely close to the book as possible, which will leave us (the fans) with the same emotion we had while reading the books. JMHO!

I think the movie will be great! The books are phenomenal, Stephenie is a creative writer. The love story is really intense and I think that is what the fans love. Rob who plays Edward really gets into his character. He is really a terrific actor. Kristen is almost like a veteran in acting at age 18. The chemistry they have on screen is unbelievable.

I can't wait to see the movie. November 21st can't get here fast enough. However I do worry about the changes. I have seen alot of clips and behind the sceens. One thing that I saw that was odd was Victoria was at Prom, that doesn't make sense. I can't wait to see the meadow and to see how they can make Edward shine. So I guess we will wait and see.

/agree with ravens5a. Plus, I'm not happy with the casting.

it wount be 100% what the book is thats pretty obvious
i am dissapointed that some scenes got changed.
like when she goes to da restarant with edward and he tells her like everything...... they are doing it in the forest...
so those things to me mean a lot and i hope that the movie will be as good.