For fans of the Twilight Saga books and movies: Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.
47582 fans
 Join this Club
Search Club:
 Invite friend 
fanpop > books & literature > twilight series > articles > opinion

To all the Breaking Dawn Haters

Opinion by zuly89 posted 1 year ago
4.1
 by 23 fans
save Bookmark and Share



I am stunt. I cannot believe what the “supposedly” Twilight fans are saying about the last book of the saga, Breaking Dawn. When I first finished reading the novel I was so grateful and thankful of Stephenie Meyer. She has giving us the best love story ever written. But as I was searching the net for the opinion of other fans I was shocked. The majority of the people didn’t like the book. They are saying horrible things about Meyer. Oka…One thing is to criticize the novel with a perspective point of view and another thing is insulting and disrespecting Stephenie Meyer.

•    First people didn’t like that Bella got pregnant. In my opinion that was very awesome. As fans may know one of Edwards regrets is not giving Bella the opportunity of having children. Ok, Bella was supposedly fine with that, but as you may know that totally changed when she found out that she was pregnant with no ordinary child, but with Edward’s.

•    Second, fans didn’t like either that the personalities of the characters changed. Hello! Off course the characters changed. It’s been over 2 years for them in the books. They are all grown up. They have responsibilities and priorities. Bella & Edward are married now and the dynamic between them is completely different. Jacob finally accepted that he is the Alpha of the pack. For me that was very mature of all the characters.

•    Third, they didn’t like that Jacob imprinted on Bella & Edward’s daughter, Nessie. In my opinion that was one of the most beautiful things in the book. Is like Jacob couldn’t have Bella but at least he could have part of her. Beautiful!

•     Fourth, the fact that Bella saved the day and they didn’t have to fight with the Volturi was not very welcome in the Twilight community. People, what in the hell are thinking. A friend of mine was saying to me that maybe the author was making a point. Not everything in life has to be resolve with a war. Communication is the key to success. I’m very glad that there wasn’t a fight and nobody got hurt.

•    And finally Twilighters didn’t like that the ending was too happy. Okay that is just ridiculous. The end of the book was perfect. Off course they live “Happily Ever After” they are immortals. They have each other for the rest of eternity. That was how it was suppose to end all along. Hello!!!
I’m just gonna say this; stop complaining and disrespecting Stephenie Meyer. You have to be grateful that she published the saga at all. She said that she wrote these books for her own entertainment, not because she wanted to become famous of anything. We have to thank her not punished her for giving us this amazing story of love, passion and friendship. She gave us Edward, the most beautiful and perfect character ever created. Don’t pay her back with hateful thoughts. If you didn’t like the book that’s okay, everybody has different points of view, but please watch what you say and write about the author.
In my opinion Stephenie Meyer is one of the most talented and creative authors of all times.

URL:   Bookmark and Share
20 comments
user photo
i totally agree with you zuly89!
i absolutely love the book!! i dont understand why people keep hating on it...im glad they didnt have a war cuz i was afraid that some of my fave charaters wouldve died...so very glad the fight didnt happen!
i love the fact that bella did have a baby...at first i was shocked that it happened...and then i started to warm up the the idea...and the fact that jacob imprinted on nessie made me very happy!! i was excited that he finally found someone that isnt bella but part of her like you said!

i love the whole twilight series and im glad SM published them!! she is one of my fave authors!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
i do agree with a lot of your points. i IN NO WAY hated breaking dawn, but i didn't love it. My review seemed VERY negative but really i did enjoy the book. i have since re-read it a few times and now i find it more enjoyable. I don't think Breaking Dawn was all it was built up to be, but i don't consider myself a 'hater'
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
tiz said:
I agree for the most part. I loved breaking dawn, but in some respects it did seem kind of fan-fictiony. I do see what you mean between just dissing the book and constructive criticism. Thanks for your well-written soapbox. :D
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
shortynme said:
I agree with you 100%!!!!!! I LOVED the book! I was so impressed/shocked/pleased/and received my closure. This serious is fabulous. I loved it. And if ANYONE says anything bad about Stephenie Meyer I'll hunt you down and guy you like a fish *said in a very Jim Carry/Grinch voice* lol.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
Good job with this! I totally agree with everything, but for the part where no one got hurt....ummm Irina was murdered....lol, yeah just had to point that out.

But the first time I read it through it was hard to love because it was so shocking! lol, so the second time through I completely loved it...it was just so DIFFERENT from what I expected so I was in shock the first time around.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
OMG, You are soo right!!! LOVE LOVE this article I toatlly agree with you!! I love how you said that Communication is the key to success because that soooo right! over all i really did love the book, but you know people and there reasons.....

love your article!

you know i'v realized that the people on fanpop had alot of love for breaking dawn, if you go other fansites they'll just bash it but i've found that fanpop is almost like a sanctuary to really appreciate the book for what it is. It really good that alot of people on fanpop at least really like the book!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
I totally agree.

I cringe when I see a hateful comment about the book. Stephenie Meyer did her best. There was NO WAY she could make EVERYONE happy.

Truth is, I didn't care who Bella ended up with or how SM decided to do it. I just wanted a good book with closure for the end of this Saga. I got both.

Perhaps my expectations weren't as high as some of the so-called Twilighters out there who wanted it THEIR way or NO way.

I do agree -- People on FanPop do seem alot nicer with their opinions on the book versus other sites (like YouTube).
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
i do agree with you on most points also. the only thing i was a little disappointed on was Bella's transformation. I wanted Edward to change her when she wasn't dying. I feel that if Stephenie did write that, it would be one of the best things I have ever read. I believe that without a doubt. But, I like the book! Im trying to get that point across so I dont get chewed out or bitten!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
kitkat211 said:
Okay, if you all could stop kissing her ass for 3 seconds, you would realize that this book was pretty bad. "Nessie" was even the problem! The problem was Bella pregnancy, Jacob, Bella Out of Character, imprinting on babies, Jacob, Bella not going through her "newborn" stage, Who the hell "Jazz" was, people feeling sorry for Jacob,(OUT OF EVERYONE, HE IS THE LAST PERSON THAT YOU SHOULD FEEL SORRY FOR) Charlie being cool that his daughter is marrying and going to become a vampire, and Edward wanting to kill the baby. Great father, I hope that when Nessie get 17 she kicks her father in the nuts, kills Jacob and runs off and joins the Volturi! Now thats a story! I will end with the few thing I did think she did right. Vampire on human sex, the wedding(when it wasn't borning) and that fact that she did get turned into a vampire. Thats about it!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
the book was NOT bad! just because it was different than the other ones doesnt make it bad! and kitkat211--the pregnancy put a twist on the story, jacob was not doing anything wrong in this book, bella was an entirely different character (vampire, duh!), the imprinting was kinda weird, but not bad, ditto on the jacob thing, if bella had gone through the newborn stage it would have been like "blood blood blood" the whole entire book, i didnt particularly like the nickname "jazz" but it didnt bother me that much, there was reason to feel sorry for jacob in this book, charlie didnt know that she was a vampire exactly (need to know only), and edward only wanted to kill the baby in the beginning when he couldnt hear its thoughts and he thought it was gonna be some kind of monster that killed bella and then attacked everyo;ne else. and if you didnt like the pregnancy how come u liked the sex? the sex lead to the pregnancy, if you didnt get that.\
i did like the wedding. the wedding was really cute. and i liked that she got turned into a vampire.

all in all i thought it was a really good book and even though it was differnt i liked it a lot.

and we're not "kissing her ass" we're stating our opinions.
which isnt illegal, by the way.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
kitkat211 said:
Yeah, but your excuses are lame! You are just saying, well I liked that part, so your wrong. BTW...sex doesn't always lead to pregnancy...if you didn't get that!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
uh, if im saying "i liked it so youre wrong" then ur saying "i didnt like it so it sucked".
same thing

and i know that, but in this particular case it did!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
zuly89 said:
I like your point of vivew funnyshawna!!!.....100%..
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
kitkat211 said:
forget it! You don't know how to debate!
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
haha thanks:)
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
sawabear said:
i agree with you completely
i guess i was alittle peeved that jacob imprinted on bella's baby,
but then i remebered feeling bad for him because he might never get his happily ever after and now he did and as long as bella was ok about it then its all good.
posted 1 year ago.
 
user photo
-Jane- said:
I HATE BREAKING DAWN!!!!!
Okay, first off, the honeymoon---fine, until she gets pregnant!!!!
Jacob should have fallen in love with Leah, and Leah should have liked the Cullens!!!!
Edward should just get over himself and bite Bella already!!!!!
They can get Jacob on their side and fix the treaty that way!!!
I loved Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse, because they were great, Breaking Dawn was pointless and stupid!!!!
Bella is dumb for letting that THING mutilate her and kill her!!!!!
And the THING should NEVER have happened!!!!!
I HATE BREAKING DAWN!!!!!!!
P.S. renesmee carlie is a stupid name!!!!!!!!!!!
posted 8 months ago.
 
user photo
-Jane- said:
Oh yeah....i also forgot to mention that i like the legendary loch ness monster!!!!!
the mutant spawn befouls the loch ness monster!!!!!!
BREAKING DAWN SHOULD GO DIE IN A HOLE!!!!!!http://images.fanpop.com/images/emoticoons­/an­gry­.jp­g
angry
posted 8 months ago.
 
user photo
angelic
I tottaly agree with -jane-.Not about the hating Breaking Dawn part because I loved the book but about Renesmee.I don't think she was necessary and i didn't like her.All of a sudden everyone cares only about her.Bella was willing for Edward to die to save Renesmee.I mean come on this is so not related to the other books where Bella would do anything for Edward to be safe.I loved Breaking Dawn but I hated Renesmee.I try to ignore her as much as I can.And of course I thank Stephenie for sharing this awesome dream she had with us and for creating Edward Cullen the best character ever but I think she made a mistake by putting Renesmee in her book.She was my only complaint about BD because I loved every part that SHE wasn't in.Sorry but that's my opinion

PS:I don't belong to the Breaking Dawn Haters.
posted 6 months ago.
last edited 6 months ago
 
user photo
worried
manoora95 said:
omg i cant believe any "fans" would hate the last book i love it the most!!!!!!!!! I did think Jacobs POV was quiet long but i am not saying that sucked. no offence twilight haters but plz think again!!!!!!!!
posted 3 months ago.
 
related links
popular content
fanpop home - company blog - about us - advertise on fanpop - faq - sitemap - terms of service - privacy policy - contact us
connect with us on
Facebook MySpace bebo hi5 YouTube Twitter