Twilight Series

He would have been perfect<3

He is perfect.

Pssshh! He does not give Edward any justice. I'm sorry, but on actor could look half as good as the book makes Edward out to be.

I think Rob is a much better Edward xx

Robert is the perfect edward no one could beat him

i think henry was the best choice for edward he is perfect and is just what i thought he would be like.i think that robert is to much like a young boy and i just think he doesnt suit,plus henry is well fitter!! !!

nO...i think he isn't apt to do edward!!Robert is so misterious,so nice,so perfect!!!he's that just!!

Robert is wayyyy better

not that henry isn't a good choice

but i can't imagine it not being Robert
he's perfect for the roll
i think the whole cast is absolutely amazing
and perfect

i totally agree w/ lyricsallullaby

i like robert as edward

ppl hu freaken cares hu plays edward what matters is that his acting is gud i mean u could put a guy in the movie that looks exactly like how ppl pictured edward but if hes not gud at acting like edward he'll stink just be happy of hus playing edward n hope his performance is awsum

:|

Rob is perfect for Edward

@ sousagurl: That's it :D Nothing more to say ;)
No one can be like Edward, but he's relly good for this

hope you are so right no actor can look like the book makes him out to b...

i dont no huthis dude is but i loovvvee robert as edward!!

I think Rob is better!

I think they are both cute

henry is good but robert is just awesomly perfect 4 Edward's role....so m glad dey didn't pick him over rob

ewww no he wouldnt have been. there is only one person that is meant to play edward, and thats robert&hearts; I LOVE HIM

Listen Idont kno What in the world u guys who like Robert pattinson r talkin about.Henry Cavill and i repeeat,Henry Cavill is the one and only Edward anthony Masen Cullen.Robert is a fag and a loser.The movie sucks cuz Kristen has NO enthusiasm wat so ever.and those of u who like robert are some crack heads cuz stephanie meyer doesnt even agree wit u.It is all about Henry.and the book was changed up way 2 much in the movie.

I personally think he would have made a great Edward. In fact they were going to use him but by the time shooting started for the movie he no longer looked like he was 17.

oh no... rob is way better <3
robert pattinson has more charm and i would say sexyness too ^^

This guy would have been perfect for edward no joke he look good.

hahahaah. this poser is not half not one eighth as hot or good as rob. he so not edward. he gives edward a bad name

Rob IS Edward!

*shrugs* He'd be OK with longer hair but Rob is Edward!

Robert Pattinson is far more gorgeous, im sorry but in my eyes HE is the perfect Edward Cullen

Ya , Robert is the perfect Edward !

Rob is perfect!

Well I think Robert is perfect as Edward since he is supposed to be stuck at 17 and this Henry looks older than that already. Plus Robert has that really cute crooked smile of his that's just so cute....

Rob is perfect don't try 2 change it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

he looks bad in that angle..he is soo hot..if he was young enough to play the part he would have been PERFECT...he going to come out in the movie Whatever Works..he look GOOD

robert pattinson all the way but i think henry would have made a emmett

He would make a good vampire...but not Edward...he looks too "hard"..like he could never look at Bella the way that Robert Pattinson does... I think they picked the perfect guy to bring Edward to "life"

NO WAY ROB IS TOTALLY BETTER AND HOTTER,ROB JSUT HAS THAT ZEST THAT SPICES-UP THE MOVIE AND HE JUST HAS THAT CONNECTION WITH BELLA..........

Henry would have been a more attractive Edward, but he wasn't and the movie turned out alright. On the other hand Kristen Stewart looked completely cracked out during the whole damn film, and I don't recall Bella looking and acting like some sort of addict in the book. Maybe i missed something though...

oh my god im glad he's not edward!!! rob is far better and its impossible to imagine anyone else playing the role of edward!

i wud say he is really gud bt robert plays it btter

Rob!
There's no way he can get replaced, Rob is doing a great job plus hes hott, even if some people dnt think soo,

I like the cast just how it is and I kind of agree with the nikki person I do like Rob though.

i think rob is way better this guy just doesn't look like edward he looks like a jock more like emmet

DAMN!! he's smokin!!!
lol

wow I hate rob pattinson but he is hoter then him

After looking at his pic again...I think he would have made a great Stefan in the Vampire Dairies...I dont like the actor they picked for him...yuck!

He's more hollister model than Edward Cullen.

rob is the only edward i can imagine!(:

seriusly pple, I think its CRASS and TRIVIAL for u all to say ONE GUYS NOT LIKE EDWARD CAUSE ROB IS HOTTER! Pfft! Seriusly, ur caring how hot he is and how he relates to Rob! I swear...u know what? I'm gonna hold back! Only cause I can do so many other things right now then listen to u obsessive fans say how hot ROB is and how better he is at playing Edward than this guy is! There's a good chance he's better! (I think I just heard you gasp, I did! lolz)
u guys need to chill on the stalkerness and seriuosly come back from the clouds and get down to REAL LIFE!!!

*CRASS=Insensitive and unrefined (adj.)
INSENSITIVE=not responsive, lacking physical sensation or feeling! (adj.)

seriously...I am not afraid to go off on ppl!

I love edward, but Jacob is smoking