|
The Voluntary Rating Squad Of Fanpop
|
|
Invite friend
Not A Fan Of The New Rating System...
|
|
|||||
... and here is why.
There are a number of ways in which Fanpop will be affected by this new rating system, and I can't think of a positive one. Here are the main issues for me. Cheaters Ahoy! As the new system does not indicate how many people have rated an image/video/link, this will make it much, much easier for people to use multiple accounts to rate their own contributions. As other people cannot see how many people have rated an image, someone with multiple accounts could rate their images 10 times and none of us would be any the wiser. This is unfair on honest Fanpoppers who do not abuse the system just so that they can get their medals quicker. Mass Rating Epidemics In addition, it will be impossible to detect when users are asking for 10 other people to rate their contributions, while ignoring the contributions of others. Personally, I don't mind if people ask a couple of their friends to rate their contributions if the contributions haven't been rated after a while (that is what this spot is all about), but there are already many, many Fanpoppers who will ask as many as 15 people to rate their contributions. Meanwhile, other users who contribute equally good content do not get ratings. Thus, there is an imbalance between good, regular spot attendees and random, mass-raters getting medals that, quite frankly, they don't deserve. Under the new system, we will not be able to detect this kind of activity. The Death Of The ATSOF With the new system, we do not know how many people have rated a contribution. Thus, if an image is rated 1 star, we do not know if it is because it has been trolled, or if it has been rated 1 by 100 different people because it is genuinely a crap image. Thus, much of the good work that the ATSOF does will no longer be able to happen. We are now far less capable of identifying trolled content and thus, more and more trolls will get away with being jerks. Goodbye VRSOF! Now we are no longer able to tell how many times something has been rated, we are going to be less able to identify who is worthy of the VRSOF's help. This, again, will open the doors for more people to abuse the kindness of other Fanpoppers in order to medals. This happens enough now, but this new system will undoubtedly make it very difficult to trust anyone who asks the VRSOF for help. I have read in a couple of comments that the aim of changing the rating system is to stop people obsessing over ratings and medals. However, I believe that this new system will create more ratings-mongering and medal-cheating, as it has now become more anonymous than it was before. I mean, the old system made it relatively easy to spot people who were getting 10 people to rate their contributions/using multiple accounts because you could easily see how many people had rated those contributions. Now, people can use multiple accounts or ask 20 people to rate their stuff and no one will be able to stop them. As someone who has been a passionate rater from my early Fanpopping days, I understand how frustrating it is to contribute content that never gets rated. So I understand that people want their contributions rated. But the previous system was already being abused by dishonest fans, as well as taken advantage of by more honest fans who simply wanted to see their work rated. I need to say that I have always supported Fanpop and the Fanpop Four, and I have never had any major issues with any other updates that have been made to Fanpop. I have always adapted to them quickly and have enjoyed them. But this one just baffles me. I think it will lead to more cheating and trolling and ultimately, it is the honest Fanpoppers that will suffer. So those are my thoughts. I love rating and rating is a big part of fans feeling appreciated and part of their spots. I will continue to rate, but I do feel like it will probably be a waste of my time. In the weeks leading up to this change I was already very disillusioned with the rating process, as I had noticed a sharp increase in the number of people getting other Fanpoppers to rate their contributions in some of my favourite spots. Now that one of the ways of policing such behaviour is gone, I'm pretty sure this kind of issue is going to become rampant through many spots. Sorry about this, but I had to rant about it. It has kinda been like a giant slap in the face to the people who belong to this spot, the ATSOF spot and people who rate fairly in general. And so ends my melodramatic ranting and raving. |
||||||
| connect with us on | |||||
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Join this Club
Thanks for commenting!
Edit: I seriously can't type today
One of my own videos is yellow (did someone else rate it? has no one rated it?) and one of the images I posted is green. If I can't rate my own stuff, why are there different colors?!
Uh. Not sure if that made sense.
Anyway, I can see that this article has been rated by 7 people, but I can't see that count on images or videos.
:( :( :( :( :( :( :( :(
Another problem is that the actual meaning of rating is ruined.How can I find a really awesome content when I can't see for example that 20 people have rated with five?Or how can I know that the content that is rated with 5- or 4+ is beacause it worths 4 or many people rated with 5 and just one troll with 1?
I totally understand why fanpop 4 did it but my sister now can not rate anything she watches or looks at. Which means people lose out and don't get the recognition they deserve.
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment