Does anybody else think that The Notebook is a little overrated & comparing it to A Walk To Remember is absurd since both of them are written by Nicholas Sparks? Which one do you think is better and why?

I think A walk to remember is much better, because, It's a nice, gentle, deep and honest love that will never fade, I do not wanna mean that Noah's and Allie's love faded, but, it's more a pasional-fisical love. And you can... you know feel more understanded with A walk to remember. It is a young wonderful love that everyone would love to have ^_^ (At least in my opinion). Plus, no matter how manny times I see A walk to Remeber, I will never Ever grow tired of it, and the notebook, I really liked it sooo much at first, but them... It's kinda boring after the firsts 3 times you see it.

Absolutely not. I actually feel like A Walk to Remember may be a little overrated compared to The Notebook because

ONE: in The Notebook, Noah's in the nursing home trying to make his wife remember because he loves her. and he has to keep rereading her that diary over and over and over but he doesnt care because he loves her.

TWO: the story that's being read from when they're younger is so romantic. and the speech that's made by Noah near the end of the movie is so amazing. hes just talking about how he doesnt care when they fight becuase he wants ALL of her, flaws and all, FOREVER. (: and i think that its love like that thats the truest because you cant explain WHY you feel so strongly about that person, you just DO. and you cant help it and half the time you dont even WANT to feel that way about them but you do and its almost instinctive to be and do what they want and go to the ends of the earth to reach it.

A Walk to Remember was good but i actually found it somewhat cheesey in some scenes.
theyre both very good movies though.

I think A Walk to Remember is a much better movie. There is a lot of romance and happiness.

a walk to remember is da best movie i've ever seen and the notebook is sooooooooooooo much boring and frankly speaking i saw the notebook 6 times i didn't understand a single word of it

No, The Notebook Isn't overrated. It's an amazing movie, and so is A walk to remember. I love both movies and could never choose :)

I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE A WALK TO REMEMBER.
Notebook is so overated i dont see wot all the fuss is about, A walk to remember is just so Romantic so sweet i mean u just cant hate it at all there is nothing wrong with it at all. Even though she died its jsut the thought tht she changed him for the better he fell so in love with her. They were wo completly different ppl thrown together by Fate. You can tell she was the love of his life even though she died at a young age, He made all her dreams come true it was just Magical xxxx

A Walk To Remember is my favorite movie. It's much better and more romantic. This is my opinion. It assured me that love really exists and we should appreciate it.

As a teenager it is easier for me to relate to A Walk to Remember but both are equally worthy romances.

i love both!!!because i look for the words and speeches they make and they both successfully have beautiful writing and the romance in both are great....in one hand "a walk to remember" has the young and strong romance everybody wants to have and in the other hand it shows about inner beauty for noah is a poor guy and alley is a rich girl but yet thay are meant for each other no matter how different they are....if you notice they are about the same kind of coulple:strong,brave,young,different,romantic,and magical....but i favor a walk to remember more than the notebook because i can relate to it more since i am around the same stage in life as a hogh school teen...but then again i love both!!

AWTR was BY FAR better than The notebook. I'm one of the few people who believe they wasted precious minutes of their lives watching a movie like this. AWTR, on the other hand, was better and sadder, and the couple was much better than the one in the other movie. The only thing I didn't really like was the fact that the couple got married. But STILL, I really loved the movie :)

The Notebook & A walk to remember are my favourite movies after Titanic.I think The Notebook is overrated a little bit,I love it,but If we are talking truly it's overrated.But in second side A walk to remember is not estemeed enough xD I really think they're close,but I will always choose The Notebook!

A Walk To Remember is my favorite movie. I think it's much better and more romantic :)

A walk to remember is so much better! And I dont understand why The Notebook is so much more popular!

both have different story but i really love a walk to remember!

Yes i do believe notebook is a bit overrated. I loved it but i do not like it as much as a walk to remember, which i believe is underrated. A walk to rememver is the most moving movie evet made and if it had the same opurtunities as the notebook more people would appreciate how incredible it is.