My first creepypasta was the BEN Drowned one. You know, the one about Majora's Mask? Anyway, the first I heard of it was years ago on the comments of a Youtube video of the Elegy of Emptiness song. I saw loads of comments about BEN and loads saying 'You shouldn't have done that...' and they all had many thumbs up. Years later (the other day, actually), I saw the club 'BEN {Majora's Mask}' on Fanpop. I posted on the wall of that club 'Who is Ben? I've been wondering this for YEARS.'. Eventually I googled it (I don't know why I didn't just do that ages ago XD silly me) and found this:
link .
It is the only crepypasta I've read so far, actually... I've HEARD of Slenderman, but never read it. BEN Drowned kept me awake nearly all of last night and the night before (for me, it's not the statue but the happy mask man's angry face that scares me the most). A really good, interesting, realistic creepypasta, not that I really have any others to compare it to. Sorry if this answer was a little long... XP