Is there any way I can become a featured fan?

actually when you enter the site for a brief second you become a featured fan so you probably already have been. You just wont see it you will probably need a friend to screencap it for you if they see it. or try refreshing the page after you have logged in it might show up. At least that's the way it use to work way back when....lol

Just use Fanpop and it will eventually happen.

I don't think there's any specific criteria you must follow. Just be active.

i have to agree with cassie-1-2-3 i dont think there is any specifics to it so just be a fan of fanpop and you should be able to be one