Harry Potter Club
Join
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
I just knew I had to write this article after seeing a lot of fans debating on the topic:

"Are the books or movies better?"

So first of all, my love for Harry Potter didn't start from the books. My mother kept recommending them to me, but I was younger when the books came out first. That days, I always judged a book by its cover. So when I saw a random boy with a scar on his forehead standing and 7 books about him, I said, "Mom, stop. I don't wanna read it, I feel like it won't be interesting,"

My mom said ok, and we left the bookshop. But from that day on, my friends started watching Harry Potter like crazy. I was left out because I didn't even know a word they were saying. Who the heck is Voldemort? What is a "muggle"? My best friends were potterheads and I knew I had to learn it, so the next day me and my sister started watching Harry Potter.

My English wasn't that good, and we opened the movies in English. I couldn't get a thing from Harry Potter. What is the purpose and you might find this funny but Minerva was scaring me. At the first scenes I quickly shut the TV, and didn't watch the movie for YEARS.

Uhh well.. One day, I thought I was enough grown up for the series to not scare me, and I opened them. The movies were amazing and as a stupid kid I couldn't help but have a crush on Harry-sorry about that. I still didn't get some parts of the movies but I kinda got the wizarding world and the fantasy JKR made just amazed me! Plus, I related to Hermione a lot, so I bought thousands of Hermione stuff.
I kept reading fanfics on the internet, watched the movies a thousand times again and again, and finally became a potterhead. I couldn't live a day without thinking of the movies lol.

Since I read a lot of fanfics and liked the first movies the most that days, I shipped Hermione and Harry. My opinion hasn't still changed though, but that's not the point. When I learned Ginny and Harry were together, I was in shock. Plus in many more reasons, (mostly the hermione x harry ruining) I started to dislike Ginny.

That's when people started to force me to read the books, and since I watched the movies and they got me in the potter world I couldn't think the books were better. And I knew I had to read them because people wouldn't accept me as a Potter head.

But I am a big bookworm, and the day I started reading the books, I finished them all in a week. Ofc, I'm still periodically reading them because they are my fav books! So I just preferred the books, still do. First of all, the books explained everything in details, and made everything clear that were mixed up in movies. For example, I missed why Dobby was saved and while reading the books it turned out Lucius threw the sock and Dobby caught it, since Lucius threw it, Dobby was free.

And I didn't get the scary soul-suckers and what they were doing in Hogwarts. But in the books, its clearly explained that the dementors came all the way from Azkaban to protect the building from Sirius, but got to the Dark Lord's way later.

Through books, I managed to like characters better ( for example I loved Ron in the books but disliked him in the movies) and Hermione became my favorite character. I like Snape more in movies and same for Ginny (even though I dislike both Ginny's) and its just it.

Just a small problem: since I watched the movies first, I imagined the character appearances in the movie, though in the book most didn't match. In the book, Hermione has big front teeth, in movies, she's perfect. In the book, Dudley is blond, in the movies he is a brunette. In the books, Harry has green eyes and Ginny has brown eyes, in movies they have both blue.

Not counting that appearance detail, the books are better for me. Just an opinion :)

C'ya !
added by glezps
added by alessiamonari
HP
added by Yuki_7
added by alessiamonari
added by alessiamonari
added by alessiamonari
added by alessiamonari
added by peteandco
added by JBDisneyDemi
added by vanillaicecream
added by RealSunshine
Source: Fanpix.com
added by James13
added by Cittycat19
added by Cittycat19
posted by Flickerflame
I was asked to do this by lorythefangirl after I responded to her earlier one.

Pros
1. Most of them did believe they were choosing the winning side at the time
2. They would likely be killed if they refused, or otherwise punished.
3. If they come from old pureblood families which share the Death Eaters' beliefs, joining up would help maintain family harmony
4. If they're naturally malicious it gives them an opportunity to kill and torture

Cons
1. Most people wouldn't want to be forced to murder. They might be pushed beyond their own limits, e.g. Draco Malfoy.
2. They'd get imprisoned in Azkaban if caught, or could be killed in self-defence
3. Leaving isn't an option once you're in
4. After they lost, those who'd survived would lose favour even if they avoided punishment
5. Voldemort doesn't seem to be a nice boss
6. It's a story really, and in most stories, the bad guys do end up losing and being punished.
(From the view of Draco)
Have you ever seen something so beautiful as light? What ever it is that you saw it would never be as beautiful as the light I have just witnessed as it stands this light which holds my heart together in one piece ceases to know I existed. Even though we walked down the same corridors to such things as laborious lessons that I cannot wish to attend, she floats on cloud nine as she embraces her muggle-born ways that I Draco Malfoy mock her with my own undying love to her... the more she floats the more I fall and the only way that I can hold onto her and actually speak...
continue reading...
The two of us; Kaitlyn and I, walked through the large doors and into the Entrance Hall. The entrance Hall was crowded as it always was on the first day. Students of all years were entering in groups, leaving the First Years a little startled. They probably didn’t know where to go, what to do, whom to look for. I smiled to myself, we were just like that! Some five years ago, I realised that we had grown only when I saw the little ones.
“Cal? Caldera?” I turned towards Kaitlyn, who looked irritated.
I raised an eyebrow, “What did I do?”
“We were talking, remember?” she said, furrowing...
continue reading...
This speech was given by Cheryl Klein, a senior editor at Arthur A. Levine books (an imprint of Scholastic Inc.), and continuity editor for the American editions of Harry Potter (books 5, 6, and 7 I believe.) She made this speech and gave it at the Terminus 2008 Harry Potter conference in Chicago, Illinois. The speech is about Harry Potter and why we love it, using these four elements: character, voice, theme, and plot. Enjoy!

•    My name is Cheryl Klein
•    I’m a senior editor at Arthur A. Levine Books, an imprint of Scholastic Inc.
•    And...
continue reading...
posted by Flora_Swift
"Pheonix, I heard that a muggle called Joan Rowling wrote a book about me." Said Harry Potter one day.
"Harry, I know and I've read it. It seems that even though I'm just as famous as you, she doesn't mention me in the book. Oh yes, niether did she mention Lily." replied a girl sitting next to Harry. She had long dark brown hair and misty blue eyes, she was so beautiful. Actually, she's not just a girl, she is Phoenix White, Harry Potter's cousin.
Harry smiled and replied, "Lily, I think she is much more famous than the two of us. She is just so brave and loyal, it was such a comfort to know...
continue reading...
Bella rules!
Bella rules!
FUUUUUUUU!
My friend just said twilight is better than harry potter!
Here is our convo:
"So twihard or potter head ? We both know who's better" Me
"Yhea"
Potters
Twilight
I think not!
Oh yhea!?
Yhea! And to prove you are wrong... I challenge you to a dule!
Your on!
And also... whoever wins is the better non-fiction fan.
*after much explaining we step into dule positions*
You go first. Me
Ok! I turn into a werewolf!
Avada Kerdavra the werewolf.
*she runs off crying*

I think she's crazy. So your opinion. Hp or Twilight?
Harry Potter!
Harry Potter!